Jalur Gemilang Patriotism Can Never Be Mandatory


 



“A [national] flag has no real significance for peaceful uses.”
- English writer HG Wells
Do you know when governments are wary of the people they govern? When they march on the streets for whatever reason. When people of their own volition raise the national flag.
A national flag is an object, a thing, which people imbue with certain ideas. The ideas are the dangerous part, which is why depending on who is raising the flag, those ideas either ensure the social cohesion of a populace or destabilise it.
So, you see, it is not the object but rather the ideas imbued in the object or contained within it. Take the banning of books, for instance. The government banned books because of the ideas contained within them.
This is why, faced with a possible ban by Madani for two of their books, Islamic Renaissance Front (IRF) founder Ahmad Farouk Musa said, “It seems to us that this issue of creed - asha’irah and maturidiyah - has been weaponised by the religious authorities in this country to suppress any ideas that were deemed to be critical of the issues faced by Muslims concerning the revision of history associated with the Muslim scholars of the previous generations and any issues related to critical thinking.”
It is the same with religious totems. The items themselves are not important, but rather the ideas they inspire for those who hold them in reverence. It gets to the point when it is Pavlovian in nature.
See the object, and certain emotions are stirred. Fortunately for us, the Jalur Gemilang does not have such powers. If it did, there would not be this need to constantly make people aware of its existence.
How do you teach kids?
The Education Ministry is now making it mandatory for school kids to wear the Jalur Gemilang badge. The thinking behind this diktat is - “The Education Ministry plays a key role in inculcating patriotism and love toward the country among students and educators.”
My question is this, what are the ideas behind the badge that the Education Ministry wants to inculcate? Everyone is supposed to be equal before the national flag, right? But does reality reflect that?
Deputy Education Minister Wong Kah Woh asks, “How do we teach our children to take pride in being Malaysians? How do we educate them to unite under the Malaysian flag?”
That is a good question. How do you teach kids that some kids cannot do certain things as “equal” citizens of this country? How do you teach kids that other kids have special privileges that cannot be questioned?
How do you teach kids that they are barred from certain educational institutions? How do you teach kids that there are quotas for their educational aspirations?
How do you teach kids that their religious beliefs are open to demonisation even though laws that prohibit that kind of behaviour are enforced against them if they are perceived to step out of line, but not against others?
How do you teach kids that there are political parties that cater for a specific race or that political operatives will say that it is their duty to defend a specific race and religion even though everyone is supposed to be equal before the national flag?
Defining patriotism
So, when it comes to symbols, the ideas behind those symbols are important. Whether you choose to imbue those symbols with power is entirely up to the individual, but the reality is that only the state has any power when it comes to enforcing ideas behind the symbol.
Enforcing “respect” towards a symbol has always seemed fascist to me. After all, if you have to force people to respect symbols, what does this tell you of the “need” of some people to disrespect what is supposed to be a symbol which represents all that we are supposed to believe in?
Here is another thing about patriotism. It is about people and not allegiances to totems. And in this country, mired in the toxic politics of race and religion, can the Education Ministry define patriotism that would make sense to children who are living in a polarised world?
Here is a great example of how patriotism is about people. In fact, this letter is a blueprint as to what defines patriotism and how the state has trampled on egalitarian sentiments that used to define patriotism in the military and, yes, in this country.
Close to a decade ago, Persatuan Patriot Kebangsaan (PPK), under the aegis of Arshad Raji released a statement on the enrolment of non-Malays in the military.
Here are five important parts:
(1) For such fighting men of valour to function, there has to be genuine love and care between the commanders and personnel. Everyone has to feel needed and important. The accomplishment of the mission is the ultimatum.
(2) The government’s affirmative policies of the 1980s had seeped into the military administration. Strange sayings like “orang kita” (our people) have crept into the minds of military commanders. Slowly and surely, the commanders saw some of those under their command as half-brothers or stepsons, unlike the “all are equal” mindset of previous years.
(3) Yearning for a merit-based promotion system, the non-Malays would not mind if their Malay subordinates were promoted if they were really deserving. Perceived as incapable by many non-Malay officers, there had been a haphazard promotion of officers very much undeserving of their roles and ranks.
(4) Needless to say, a mediocre officer given promotion and command would breed mediocrity and substandard results. Further, numerous deserving Malay officers of merit were also adversely affected. Malay officers who were promoted based on their merits earned an endearment of loyalty and respect from the non-Malays.
(5) Starting from the late 1980s, the military had become increasingly religious-centric, and non-Malays felt ever more alienated. The officers’ mess life and the lives of soldiers became very much dictated by religious sensitivity. This eventually affected esprit de corps and comradeship negatively in multi-racial military units.
So what can we learn from this letter? Patriotism is about one’s empathy for his or her brethren regardless of race and religion. Equality encourages such sentiments. Politics, race, and religion nullify such sentiments and create a toxic environment.
Does anyone really think that a flag on a badge is going to create a sense of simpatico amongst kids?
Well, as the prime minister says, it is free, so just wear it. That is how much Madani thinks the Jalur Gemilang is worth. - Mkini
S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy. Fīat jūstitia ruat cælum - “Let justice be done though the heavens fall.”
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2025/03/jalur-gemilang-patriotism-can-never-be.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Seragam Sekolah Wajib Semat Lencana Jalur Gemilang

Seragam Sekolah Wajib Semat Lencana Jalur Gemilang

papar berkaitan - pada 27/3/2025 - jumlah : 116 hits
Terkini Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia akan melaksanakan pemakaian lencana Jalur Gemilang pada pakaian seragam murid di semua institusi pendidikan bawah kelolaannya mulai 21 April 2025 secara berperingkat Perkara ini yang telah diluluskan ...
Education Ministry To Distribute Free Jalur Gemilang Badges To Students

Education Ministry To Distribute Free Jalur Gemilang Badges To Students

papar berkaitan - pada 27/3/2025 - jumlah : 109 hits
PETALING JAYA Each student will receive two free Jalur Gemilang badges to be worn on their school uniforms says the Education Ministry In a statement released on Thursday the ministry said it would give each student two free badges for the ...
Lencana Jalur Gemilang Patriotisme Atau Pembaziran

Lencana Jalur Gemilang Patriotisme Atau Pembaziran

papar berkaitan - pada 30/3/2025 - jumlah : 96 hits
Penghayatan bendera Malaysia atau Jalur Gemilang sering kali dikaitkan dengan semangat patriotisme Bagi Kementerian Pendidikan pemakaian lencana Jalur Gemilang pada seragam sekolah adalah satu satunya cara memupuk semangat patriotisme dalam...
Will Wearing Cute Jalur Gemilang Flags Make The Kids Patriotic Netizens Give A Resounding No

Will Wearing Cute Jalur Gemilang Flags Make The Kids Patriotic Netizens Give A Resounding No

papar berkaitan - pada 28/3/2025 - jumlah : 115 hits
IS THERE any better way to show your love for your country besides joining the army For the Ministry of Education patriotism now has something to do with attaching slick badges of the Jalur Gemilang on the uniform of the school children One...
Lencana Jalur Gemilang Kpm Panduan Pemakaian Mulai 21 April 2025

Lencana Jalur Gemilang Kpm Panduan Pemakaian Mulai 21 April 2025

papar berkaitan - pada 27/3/2025 - jumlah : 151 hits
Mulai 21 April 2025 semua murid di bawah institusi pendidikan Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia WAJIB memakai Lencana Jalur Gemilang pada pakaian seragam masing masing Keputusan ini dimaklumkan secara rasmi melalui Surat Pekeliling Ikhtisas K...
Pemakaian Lencana Jalur Gemilang Membebankan Jawapannya Tidak Kerana Ia Diberi

Pemakaian Lencana Jalur Gemilang Membebankan Jawapannya Tidak Kerana Ia Diberi

papar berkaitan - pada 30/3/2025 - jumlah : 75 hits
Pemakaian lencana Jalur Gemilang membebankan Jawapannya tidak kerana ia diberi secara percuma Tak pasti jangan kongsi biarbetul delight ranges image ranges inline style ranges aggregated ranges ranges entity typename Hashtag isEntity Hashta...
Deputy Minister Defends Jalur Gemilang Badge Amid Criticism

Deputy Minister Defends Jalur Gemilang Badge Amid Criticism

papar berkaitan - pada 28/3/2025 - jumlah : 172 hits
Deputy Education Minister Wong Kah Woh has defended the ministry s decision to introduce the Jalur Gemilang badge initiative for students stating that it is aimed at fostering patriotism and national unity and should not be dismissed as a m...
Pupils Who Don T Wear Jalur Gemilang Badge Won T Face Action

Pupils Who Don T Wear Jalur Gemilang Badge Won T Face Action

papar berkaitan - pada 29/3/2025 - jumlah : 114 hits
The Jalur Gemilang badge initiative will be carried out in stages from April 21 the education ministry said PETALING JAYA No disciplinary action will be taken against schoolchildren who fail to wear the Jalur Gemilang badge on their uniform...
Tak Guna Pelajar Pakai Lencana Jalur Gemilang Ahli Politik Terus Main Isu 3r

Tak Guna Pelajar Pakai Lencana Jalur Gemilang Ahli Politik Terus Main Isu 3r

papar berkaitan - pada 28/3/2025 - jumlah : 91 hits
Kelmarin KPM memaklumkan akan menguatkuasakan pemakaian lencana Jalur Gemilang pada pakaian seragam pelajar bagi memupuk perpaduan antara kaum PETALING JAYA Kumpulan ibu bapa ragu ragu keberkesanan pemakaian lencana Jalur Gemilang pada paka...
Pondok Abuya Lakonan Faizal Hussein Vanidah Imran

The Hachi Skyscape A Floating Sanctuary In The Heart Of Bangkok

Kebakaran Saluran Gas Kebarangkalian Letupan Susulan Rendah

Menteri Besar Pahang Kalau Abang Belon Nak Berniaga Di Kuantan Dia Boleh Cuba Buat Permohonan

It Takes More Than Just A Badge To Instil Patriotism

Ibu Terjun Ke Laut Bersama 2 Anak Di Sabah Anak Lelaki 5 Tahun Tenggelam Anak Perempuan 6 Tahun Masih Hilang

Benteng Melayu Terakhir Dengan Menara Kl Sejak Bila Menara Kl Mahu Bertukar P

Gen Z Can Help To Future Proof Workplace By Bridging Fobo


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


Joker123th 100

Dior188

Turning Your Startup Dream To Reality

Tarikh Masa Dan Lokasi Majlis Sambutan Aidilfitri Madani 2025 Peringkat Selangor Bersama Pm

Ayah Jangan Nangis

Pasaran Memerlukan Bukti