We Re Khat In Yet Another Controversy



Dr Mahathir Mohamad was prime minister (during Ops Lalang) and he is prime minister now, and Anwar Ibrahim was education minister then and prime-minister-in waiting now. A Kathirasen, Free Malaysia Today
Lim Kit Siang is right of course. Learning anything good from any culture will benefit us.
In this case, the DAP supremo was talking about the introduction of khat (Jawi calligraphy) in the Year 4 Bahasa Melayu syllabus in vernacular schools next year.
Some Chinese and Indian educationists and politicians are opposing the move, and I can understand why.
Chinese educationist groups Dong Zong (United Chinese School Committees’ Association) and Jiao Zong (United Chinese Schools Teachers’ Association) and 10 other Chinese and Tamil groups want it to be delayed until a proper explanation is given about its implementation, including whether it will be a test subject. They feel khat is not going to help Chinese and Tamil primary pupils improve their Malay language skills.
Sabah, too, wants consultations before khat is introduced as a subject.
On Aug 4, Lim gave an excellent example of why learning something of another culture doesn’t mean we lose our identity. He said he learned Jawi while in detention under the Internal Security Act in 1969.
The Iskandar Puteri MP added: “It did not make me any less of a Chinese, and may have helped in making me more of a Malaysian.”
We are not “betraying” our race if we learn Jawi or khat or, for that matter, the joget. Just as we are not betraying our race if we learn the lion dance or Chinese calligraphy; or if we learn the Tamil language or the Bharatanatyam; or if we learn the ngajat (Dayak dance) or learn to weave the Iban Pua Kumbu.
Knowledge and new skills are to be welcomed always.
However, I understand the reason for the resistance to learning khat, too. The Chinese, and to a lesser extent the Indians, are always wary of any new “Malay” field of study being incorporated into the vernacular schools syllabus.
There is fear that it might be the beginning of a strategy to slowly replace Chinese schools or “take over” the managements of these schools.
I believe many Malaysians still remember the education ministry’s move to post about 100 non-Mandarin speaking senior assistants to Chinese schools in 1987. Many Chinese educationists and politicians felt this would change the character of their schools and that it was the beginning of what they saw as direct encroachment into vernacular education.
About 2,000 Chinese, led by the two Chinese educationist groups leading the current khat protest, and politicians, gathered on Oct 11, 1987 to demonstrate against the decision to send non-Mandarin speaking teachers to Chinese schools.
On Oct 17, Umno Youth, led by a young man by the name of Najib Razak who was then trying to make his mark, responded with a large rally, often estimated at 10,000, to support the education ministry’s move and condemn the earlier group of Chinese protesters. There was talk that Najib uttered some inflammatory words that day but no one has proved this.
However, according to Lim, the government White Paper entitled “Towards Preserving National Security” tabled in Parliament on March 23, 1988 “recorded that in the Umno Youth rally led by Najib on Oct 17, 1987, banners bearing strong words were displayed, including one which said: “Soak it (the keris) with Chinese blood.”
Umno secretary-general Sanusi Junid was later reported as threatening to hold a larger gathering on Nov 1.
But on Oct 27, the infamous Ops Lalang took place. Initially, 19 people were arrested, but by mid-November, a total of 106 people had been detained under the ISA, including Lim and his son Guan Eng, Karpal Singh, V David, Ibrahim Ali, Kua Kia Soong, Muhamad Sabu, Khalid Abdul Samad and Dr Mohd Nasir Hashim.
But that was in the past. Why should the Chinese educationists and politicians worry about something as innocent as khat?
One reason could be that Dr Mahathir Mohamad was prime minister then and he is prime minister now, and Anwar Ibrahim was education minister then and prime-minister-in waiting now.
Although Anwar has since suggested the move to send non-Mandarin speaking teachers as senior assistants might have been ill-conceived and that vernacular schools should remain, Mahathir is saying a single-language system would better promote unity. Since becoming prime minister again on May 9, 2018, Mahathir has said a couple of times that vernacular schools are a stumbling block to unity.
But he has never called for vernacular schools to be shut down.
In April this year, Mahathir spoke about housing national and vernacular schools on a “single campus” to enable the pupils to mingle, so that unity can be improved.
There is also the fear among Chinese educationists that what happened to national schools could happen to vernacular schools. Today everyone, including Mahathir, acknowledges that national schools have become almost Islamic schools. This, of course, did not happen in a year or two; it happened slowly, starting with one or two moves that looked innocent enough.
That is why, I believe, these groups want clarification. It is unfortunate that the education ministry did not engage educationist and parent groups before announcing the decision to introduce khat. It goes to show that the education ministry – no matter who is governing – does not learn from the past.
Some politicians have suggested that khat lessons be held as a co-curricular activity. That is one way to seek a compromise.
Education Minister Maszlee Malik offered another. He said on Aug 4 that he was open to proposals for the introduction of other styles of calligraphy in the school curriculum. So, why not? Let’s also include something from Chinese, Indian and Dayak culture in the syllabus. That’ll be good for unity.
Lim, in talking about learning Jawi, also called for an end to the siege-mentality, warning that this “extraordinary situation” could further erode unity.
“This extraordinary situation is one where the Malays feel threatened, the Chinese feel threatened, the Indians feel threatened, the Kadazans feel threatened and the Ibans feel threatened. Every community is made to believe that its culture and ethnicity is facing an existential threat.”
So true. This fear has to go. We have to learn to trust each other and work for our common good, for this is our shared home.
 
 


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

https://www.malaysia-today.net/2019/08/06/were-khat-in-yet-another-controversy/

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Don T Implement Khat Just Yet Say Educationist Groups

Don T Implement Khat Just Yet Say Educationist Groups

papar berkaitan - pada 7/8/2019 - jumlah : 192 hits
Chinese educationist groups Dong Zong and Jiao Zong today reiterated their stand against the government s move to introduce a chapter on the Malay Arabic calligraphy of khat in the Year 4 Bahasa Melayu syllabus in vernacular schools next ye...
After Khat Issue Dap To Hold Another Pow Wow Over Lynas

After Khat Issue Dap To Hold Another Pow Wow Over Lynas

papar berkaitan - pada 12/8/2019 - jumlah : 263 hits
DAP will once again summon its elected representatives nationwide to Kuala Lumpur this time over the impending renewal of the operating licence for Lynas rare earths processing plant The pow wow set for Tuesday comes just a week after a whe...
Mahathir Kepada Pemimpin Dap Tulisan Cina Boleh Mengapa Penulisan Khat Tak Boleh

Mahathir Kepada Pemimpin Dap Tulisan Cina Boleh Mengapa Penulisan Khat Tak Boleh

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2019 - jumlah : 323 hits
Keputusan kerajaan untuk memperkenalkan seni khat dan tulisan Jawi bagi mata pelajaran bahasa Melayu Tahun Empat adalah kekal kata Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad Perdana Menteri berkata kerajaan selama ini tidak pernah menghalang kaum lain untuk m...
Mereka Belajar Khat Dan Ia Sangat Cantik Jadi Apa Masalahnya

Mereka Belajar Khat Dan Ia Sangat Cantik Jadi Apa Masalahnya

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2019 - jumlah : 708 hits
SEORANG penggiat seni khat Malaysia hari ini mempersoalkan golongan yang takut dan anti seni tulisan berkenaan sedangkan ia menarik minat ramai pihak termasuk dalam kalangan masyarakat Cina di negara ini Abu Hazieq yang juga seorang tenaga ...
Mereka Pun Belajar Jadi Apa Masalahnya Luah Seorang Penggiat Khat

Mereka Pun Belajar Jadi Apa Masalahnya Luah Seorang Penggiat Khat

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2019 - jumlah : 167 hits
Sumber New Malaysian PostBaru baru ini hangat diperkatakan mengenai isu yang ditimbulkan oleh 138 pemimpin akar umbi DAP termasuk 13 Anggota Dewan Undangan Negeri mendesak pemimpin parti yang berada kerajaan untuk menolak rancangan memperke...
Khat Sepatutnya Bangga Tetapi Ditentang Pula Apa Masalahnya Prof Teo Kok Seong

Khat Sepatutnya Bangga Tetapi Ditentang Pula Apa Masalahnya Prof Teo Kok Seong

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2019 - jumlah : 784 hits
Penentangan DAP terhadap pengenalan mata pelajaran khat dalam bahasa Melayu kepada murid murid Tahun 4 merupakan bangkangan membabi buta tanpa ada sebab sebab konkrit Bantahan tersebut juga dilihat sebagai satu rancangan licik dengan menggu...
Cukup Khat Tidak Perlu Pertimbang Pembelajaran Kaligrafi Lain Dr Teo

Cukup Khat Tidak Perlu Pertimbang Pembelajaran Kaligrafi Lain Dr Teo

papar berkaitan - pada 6/8/2019 - jumlah : 250 hits
Penentangan DAP terhadap pengenalan mata pelajaran khat dalam bahasa Melayu kepada murid murid Tahun 4 merupakan bangkangan membabi buta tanpa ada sebab sebab konkrit Bantahan tersebut juga dilihat sebagai satu rancangan licik dengan menggu...
Khat An Unnecessary Distraction

Khat An Unnecessary Distraction

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2019 - jumlah : 118 hits
Insisting that khat is suddenly an integral part of Malaysia s national identity and Bahasa Malaysia which is the national language and the language of unity the education ministry has confirmed that khat will be part of the Year 4 Bahasa M...
Dap Leaders Meet As Party Threatens To Implode Over Khat Rage

Dap Leaders Meet As Party Threatens To Implode Over Khat Rage

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2019 - jumlah : 316 hits
A DAP supporter outside DAP s Menglembu assemblyman s service centre in Ipoh where he vented anger over the move to introduce khat for Year 4 vernacular students by throwing eggs PETALING JAYA DAP grassroots members are up in arms over the ...
8 Karakter Di Drama Korea Ini Bisa Jadi Contoh Bahwa Emansipasi Bukan Cuma Cita Cita Wanita Indonesia

Penyalahgunaan Kuasa Penyakauan Harta Rakyat Oleh Mahathir Wajib Didedahkan

Bersih Slams Hulu Selangor Funds Ahead Of Kuala Kubu Baharu Polls

Wee Barking Up The Wrong Tree

Zus Coffee Ice Green Tea Latte

Let S Be Reasonable Tun M Don T Call The Kettle Black

Isu Buang Beras Sardin Semuanya Sudah Rosak Busuk Bekas Ahli Parlimen Kuala Krau

Membongkar Kejayaan Pembayaran Dan Pemenang Di Wecopytrade Dan Wemastertrade



Kisah Restoran Colonel Sanders Selain KFC Yang Tidak Boleh Dikembangkan

Info Dan Sinopsis Filem J2 J Retribution J2 J Retribusi Filem Malaysia 2021 Di Netflix Sekuel J Revolusi

Info Sinopsis Kutipan Sheriff Narko Integriti Filem Malaysia 2024

Info Dan Sinopsis Dough Doh Filem Malaysia 2023 Lakonan Syafiq Kyle Kini Di Netflix

Info Dan Sinopsis The Djinn s Curse Khong Khaek Filem Seram Thailand 2023 Kini Di Netflix Malaysia


Moira World Tour 2024 Malaysia Dipilih Sebagai Lokasi Pertama

Pengertian Pungli Contoh Dan Hukumannya

Lelaki Bunuh Bakar Saudara Sendiri

Filem Reversi

Pucuk Manis Khasiat Dan Kesan Sampingan

Arief Apa Salahku Chord