Umno Pas Alliance Who S To Blame

The just solemnised alliance of Umno-PAS is bad news for Malaysians who have worked for anti-racist solutions to our nation’s challenges since colonial times
At the same time, while Pakatan Harapan leaders try to mock this Malay/Muslim-based alliance on the basis of racial alignment and leadership, shouldn’t they be asking themselves how this scenario has come about and how they have contributed to it
After all, isn’t Harapan itself led by a leader who heads a purely race-based party that is only for the “Pribumi”? Why question the Umno-PAS alliance’s ability to select a PM-designate if they should win the next elections when Harapan has chosen a proven dictator who had squandered so much of our resources for so many years? Why bring up the Memali massacre when it should be the prime minister at the time who should answer to the relevant charges
PAS in the opposition coalition
PAS has been one of the country's strongest opposition parties for most of its existence. Its electoral base is in Malaysia's rural districts although in recent years it has been attracting the urban middle class as well
The party has governed the northern state of Kelantan since 1990 and has also, in the past, formed governments in Kedah and Terengganu
The 1980s saw the party's ideological shift away from Malay nationalism towards a puritanical brand of Islamism. Thus, after an important policy speech by then PAS Vice-President Haji Abdul Hadi Awang who declared that “…the question of privileges for the Malays will not arise under Islamic law”, I wrote an article in The Star on 10 October 1985 entitled: “PAS’ present perfect stance.”It immediately evoked the predictable response from Umno that PAS was “traitorous to the religion, race and country…selling out the birthright of the Malays.”Then prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad said the attorney-general would determine if the speech was seditious. Even the Home Minister indicated that his Ministry was studying the speech. Not only was the Sedition Act invoked, some quarters also maintained that Hadi’s speech was tantamount to treason
The only voice of reason emanated from the former prime minister Tun Hussein Onn who said:“The Sedition Act should not be invoked too easily just because people express views which do not conform with established views…the authorities should not stretch the provision of the law to make every non-conformist statement seditious or the law itself would fall into disrepute
“There is the political aspect which involves the rights of the people to express their views. If it is blatant, one has to be careful in invoking the Act as it involves the freedom of speech.” (The Star, Sept 20, 1985)Without a doubt, PAS’ policy statement on the equality of all peoples before Allah was a game-changer. At a stroke, PAS had undermined the communalist ideology of Umno which had dominated the Malay community for so long
The contrast with Dr Mahathir’s call to Umno members at the time to “defend their special rights by holding fast to the spirit of nationalism” could not be starker
Seeing an opportunity to engage with the leaders of such a large Malay-based party and to combat the racist ideology of Umno, it was not the DAP but the leaders in the Civil Rights Committee (CRC) of the Chinese Associations (of which I was a member) who initiated a dialogue with the PAS leaders in 1985
During the 1986 general election campaign, leaders of the CRC went around the country calling on the Chinese electorate to vote for the opposition, including PAS
PAS in Gagasan Rakyat/Angkatan Perpaduan UmmahThus, at the 1990 general election, DAP forged a successful coalition with Semangat 46 and PRM under “Gagasan Rakyat” while S46 had, in turn, forged another coalition with PAS under “Angkatan Perpaduan Ummah”
While the opposition had failed to defeat the BN, the attitude of Malay voters toward the DAP had changed positively because of its alliance with S46, PRM and indirectly, PAS too. In fact, the realisation of this opposition front and the hope of a multiracial challenge to the Barisan Nasional had been the main reason for the entry of civil rights activists, including myself, into DAP in the first place
Nonetheless, DAP’s stance was characterised by a constantly shifting attitude toward PAS depending on the way their “Chinese ground” shifted. The debates within the party leadership over relations with PAS and Gagasan Rakyat revealed this opportunistic mindset instead of a clear non-racial strategy
Events following the 1990 general election, especially the poor showing by S46, led predictably to DAP’s leadership reappraising their relationship with Gagasan Rakyat. Thus, while S46’s other alliance with PAS had not posed a problem during the 1990 general election, by the time of the 1995 general election, DAP leaders had started having second thoughts about any link at all with PAS claiming that their “Chinese ground” had been shaken
Consequently, DAP decided to pull out of Gagasan Rakyat in 1995 apparently because they did not want to have a tainted association with PAS, even though their association that had not posed a problem in 1990
PAS in Barisan AlternatifThe impetus for the formation of Barisan Alternatif was the Reformasi movement after the 1998 arrest and subsequent conviction of former Umno deputy prime minister Anwar Ibrahim. The Reformasi movement had set new political forces into play and on Oct 24, 1999, PAS, DAP and Parti Keadilan formed an electoral alliance and issued a joint manifesto
In the 1999 general elections, BA cooperated to ensure only one candidate would contest in each constituency. PAS managed to capture the states of Kelantan and Terengganu and increased its parliamentary seats from seven to 27
DAP increased its share from seven to 10 but with two of its most prominent leaders, Lim Kit Siang and Karpal Singh losing their constituencies. This disappointing performance for DAP was again blamed on the DAP’s alliance with PAS. Keadilan took only five seats while the Barisan Nasional retained a 77 percent absolute majority with 148 of 193 seats
With the disappointing results in the 1999 general elections, DAP once again began to review its alliance with PAS. Shortly after the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Centre in New York by Islamists, DAP announced its withdrawal from the Barisan Alternatif on Sept 21, 2001
The split led to infighting between the opposition parties in the 2004 general election, resulting in many seats having multiple contestants. Nevertheless, it was a lesson to be learnt by the opposition and by the 2008 general election, the main opposition parties had realigned themselves to avoid three-corner contests in that election
PAS in Pakatan RakyatOn 1 April 2008, the leaders of PKR, DAP and PAS announced the new official alliance of Pakatan Rakyat (PR) and it led to the political tsunami at the 12th Malaysian general election. Together the three parties won 89 of the 222 parliamentary seats, its biggest electoral victory yet
After the political tsunami of 2008, DAP did not have any problems being in the same coalition with PAS and PKR given their overwhelming support from the Malaysian electorate in the 12th Malaysian general election. In fact, during GE13 in 2013, there was a video in which the DAP secretary-general accepted PAS’ own commitment to the Islamic State while abiding by the common platform of PR
Name-calling, insolence and letting loose rottweilers on the PAS presidentUnseasoned observers presume that the fallout with PAS was over the latter’s Islamist agenda. In fact, the fallout predated the asinine “Kajang Move” when we saw the former Selangor menteri besar being openly maligned by lesser DAP leaders for being inept and corrupt by lesser politicians as the justification for his ousting as Menteri Besar
Was the PAS president consulted about this irresponsible political move? The Kajang Move showed not only contempt for the voters in Kajang but also insensitivity toward the PAS leadership who were a part of the PR coalition
What Malaysians saw during the 2014 Selangor menteri besar controversy was the contempt shown toward the PAS president not only in not being consulted from the start about the former MB’s alleged misconduct and the consequent Kajang Move but also in being set upon by DAP’s Rottweilers
There was clearly a dearth of leadership in Pakatan Rakyat that allowed lesser party leaders to be publicly insolent toward the president of a component party in the PR coalition
Before long, the DAP top leaders entered the fray with the DAP secretary-general calling the PAS president “mad” among other things in the ongoing spat between the two PR parties. The coalition was formally declared disbanded by the DAP on June 16, 2015, citing their inability to work with PAS
It was Pakatan Rakyat that drove PAS into the arms of UmnoThus, PR also has to bear responsibility for this alarming new racial political scenario. The disbanding of PR after the DAP declared it could no longer work with PAS was a sad day for all Malaysians who have hopes for a viable non-racial alternative to Barisan Nasional
It was certainly a sad day for Malaysians who had carefully nurtured a working relationship with PAS since the Eighties, to see this Alternative Coalition wrecked by total lack of sensitivity to coalition principles, human relationships and a dearth of leadership
KUA KIA SOONG is the adviser of Suaram. -Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Zahid Pas Umno Alliance To Solve Society Woes Touted By Pas Leader Since 1998

Zahid Pas Umno Alliance To Solve Society Woes Touted By Pas Leader Since 1998

papar berkaitan - pada 15/9/2019 - jumlah : 213 hits
A PAS leader suggested the alliance of the country s biggest Malay political parties long ago to solve the country s problem said Umno President Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi He said that former PAS spiritual adviser the late Datuk Haron Di...
Harapan Needs To Redouble Efforts Instead Of Downplaying Umno Pas Alliance

Harapan Needs To Redouble Efforts Instead Of Downplaying Umno Pas Alliance

papar berkaitan - pada 17/9/2019 - jumlah : 191 hits
Pakatan Harapan and the PAS Umno alliance may have put their own spin on the realignment of national politics in the country but PSM believes the inking of a political charter between the country s two largest Malays parties should not be d...
New Alliance Could See Pas Eclipse Umno

New Alliance Could See Pas Eclipse Umno

papar berkaitan - pada 11/9/2019 - jumlah : 189 hits
Zainal Epi Malay Mail Online On Saturday the two biggest Malay parties in the country will come together and form an alliance that could shift the political landscape for Malay Muslims in Malaysia Leaders of PAS and Umno will sign a histori...
Umno Pas Alliance Is Good For Malaysians

Umno Pas Alliance Is Good For Malaysians

papar berkaitan - pada 18/9/2019 - jumlah : 222 hits
Zahid and Najib are two leaders who have been accused of massive corruption and if their cases are speeded up and they are found guilty then PAS and Umno will be shouldering what the Malays called memikul biawak hidup Prof Dr Mohd Tajuddin ...
Umno Pas Alliance For Benefit Of Najib Zahid And Their Supporters Veteran Newsman Says

Umno Pas Alliance For Benefit Of Najib Zahid And Their Supporters Veteran Newsman Says

papar berkaitan - pada 16/9/2019 - jumlah : 279 hits
A Kadir Jasin says PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang played third fiddle to Najib Razak and Ahmad Zahid Hamidi PETALING JAYA The historic charter signed by Umno and PAS to formalise their political cooperation was in fact for the benefit of Na...
Najib Would Have Fully Approved Of The Pas Umno Alliance

Najib Would Have Fully Approved Of The Pas Umno Alliance

papar berkaitan - pada 16/9/2019 - jumlah : 245 hits
MP SPEAKS Barisan Nasional Adviser Najib Abdul Razak would have fully approved of the PAS Umno Alliance as his global kleptocracy is continuing to make waves paving the way to make PAS and Umno one family Imagine getting an Islamist party t...
Umno Pas Ink Charter Formalising Political Alliance

Umno Pas Ink Charter Formalising Political Alliance

papar berkaitan - pada 15/9/2019 - jumlah : 252 hits
With the signing of the Piagam Muafakat Nasional opposition parties Umno and PAS have now formally joined hands The five point charter was signed by Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi and PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang in the this afternoon ...
Umno Pas Alliance Challenges In The Immediate Term

Umno Pas Alliance Challenges In The Immediate Term

papar berkaitan - pada 20/9/2019 - jumlah : 194 hits
After four decades of animosity Umno and PAS have renewed their political alliance by signing a National Consensus Charter last weekend The solidification between these two parties will likely to send reverberations to the political landsca...
To Believe Or Not To Believe In The Umno Pas Alliance

To Believe Or Not To Believe In The Umno Pas Alliance

papar berkaitan - pada 21/9/2019 - jumlah : 212 hits
But then people who believe in a certain religion or political ideology party write as if they know for a fact they are right and others are wrong They are merely expressing their opinion but that does not mean their opinion is correct It m...
Demi Tuntut Pengeluaran Caruman Kwsp Noorazlan Berjalan Kaki Dari Johor Ke Istana Negara

Berbanding Ab Rauf Kenapa Tidak Ditonjolkan Ketua Pemuda Umno Dr Akmal Sebagai Ketua Menteri Melaka Berbanding Ab Rauf

Nelson Piquet Lewis Hamilton Memuji Pemerintah Brasil Karena Mendenda Mantan Juara F1 Atas Komentar Ofensif

Mahathir Lupa Beliau Perdana Menteri Yang Pernah Diaibkan Oleh Pemimpin Negara Lain

Mahathir Wages Holy War Against Anwar

Isu Harga

Isteri Tan Sri Musa Hassan Fail Permohonan Cerai Nafi Sebar Video Pergaduhan Di Media Sosial

Punca Sulaiman Ali Letak Jawatan Ketua Menteri Melaka Tersebar

Info Dan Sinopsis Saat Hilang Cintamu Drama Slot Cerekarama TV3 Yang Berdasarkan Kisah Benar

5 Syarikat Pengiklanan Terbesar Dunia

Yanjin Kawasan Bandar Paling Sempit di Dunia

Biodata Daniel Fong Pelakon Drama Berepisod Bintang TV3

5 Kekurangan Jadi Pelajar Pandai Kelas Depan

Mencari Tempat Berkumpul Dan Bergembira Bersama Tersayang Raya Ini Tony Roma S Lah

Ccris Dan Ctos Apa Beza Hutang Bayar Tak Cantik Boleh Blacklist

Koleksi Mug Kit Kat Malaysia X Mimpi Kita

7 Cara Claim Tuntut Mysalam

Menu Berbuka Hari Ke 7 8 Puasa Mee Kolok Dan Bakso

Resepi Kuih Lapis Tradisional