Tax The Rich Rings Hollow When Many Loopholes Remain


 


YOURSAY | ‘Treasury risks ignoring mounting frustration over inequality by defending status quo.’
PM consistent on taxing the rich despite complaints: Treasury sec-gen
Elgato: While the Treasury secretary-general has defended Malaysia’s progressive taxation framework, asserting that the wealthy are contributing their fair share, this stance fails to acknowledge several critical gaps in the current system.
First, the term “progressive” taxation rings hollow when loopholes and exemptions disproportionately benefit the ultra-rich and large corporations.
Many high-income individuals and conglomerates continue to exploit tax planning strategies, including transfer pricing and offshore structures, to reduce their effective tax rates, sometimes even lower than middle-class wage earners.
Second, Malaysia’s top personal income tax rate of 30 percent for those earning over RM2 million annually may appear progressive on paper, but it only affects a small fraction of the population.
The absence of a capital gains tax (beyond real property gains), inheritance tax, or meaningful wealth tax means that passive and inherited wealth remains largely untouched.
This skews the tax burden toward wage earners and consumption taxes like the SST, which are inherently regressive and disproportionately affect the lower- and middle-income groups.
Furthermore, the government’s reliance on indirect taxation through SST, rather than a more comprehensive and equitable goods and services tax (GST) with robust rebate mechanisms for the poor, raises questions about the overall fairness and efficiency of the tax regime.
In defending the status quo, the Treasury risks ignoring mounting public frustration over inequality and the perception that the tax system favours the elite.
A truly progressive tax policy would require not just higher nominal rates for the rich, but a more holistic overhaul to ensure that wealth, not just income, is taxed, and that all Malaysians contribute equitably to national development.
KKVoter: Can you please explain, then, why the LVG (low-value goods) tax was implemented immediately while the luxury goods tax, meant to target those who can afford it, is delayed for two years?
The only tax aimed directly at the wealthy is held back, while the one targeting low-value goods kicks in right away.
Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim’s so-called war against the “maha kaya” (ultra-rich) and “elitists” seems to be hitting the middle class and urban poor instead.
To this day, we’ve seen no reclassification of who qualifies as “maha kaya” after he initially claimed it referred to those earning a combined income of RM100,000 per year.
When public ridicule peaked, he suddenly shifted the narrative to “what’s wrong with taxing those who earn RM100,000 per month” - a move straight out of his avocado playbook.
The story changes, but the tax stays the same. And he similarly attacks those who don't buy the story as “elitists” or “liberals”.
And just like the PMO staffer who was “interviewed” over three days by Malaysiakini to justify Nurul Izzah Anwar’s appointment and those non-existent reforms, now we have another one stepping in to defend the PM - this time by calling the most inconsistent PM in history... consistent.
That one takes the cake.
Esviel: There is consensus that the wealthy contribute more to the nation’s coffers, and I don't think anyone is complaining violently.
The problem is that the PM is making it sound like they are bloodsuckers and must be punished. The messaging is quite often distorted and highly combative. This is the wrong strategy.
The wealthy are wealthy for a reason: they are generally smart, competent, intelligent, and have a growth mindset.
They will fight fire with fire when you rile them up. Take a combative stance and see if they will oblige. Many will find ways to mitigate the additional taxes in ways you cannot easily understand or address.
Treasury secretary-general Johan Mahmood Merican, you must be smart to be in the position you are in.
However, lately, you have been trying to defend some of the policies with infantile logic. I hope that you will stop this and give us some decent arguments. Use ChatGPT if you must.
Coward: I think the T10 or T20 don’t mind contributing more to the government coffers, they just object that the prime minister has put them out as the straw man whenever his tax or subsidy policies hit resistance.
That’s uncalled for, and the PM is dividing our society in new ways on top of existing divisions.
Can’t the prime minister have an adult conversation about these issues? Tell people why they must take the pain of reduced petrol subsidies, for example.
Don’t promise them the impossible, that they won’t be affected as he will only target the high-income group.
It’s fair that the high-income group takes a heavier burden on the increase. It’s also fair that the very low B40 group get support from the money the high-income group contributes.
However, it is unfair that only the high-income group pays. The middle-income group just takes their fair share of responsibility.
That’s what the prime minister should say, just like the now viral speech his Singapore counterpart said when Donald Trump announced his liberation day tariff.
Have a proper conversation, treating everyone as an adult. Don’t start distorting reality.
World Citizen: We agree you want to tax the rich more - progressive taxation. So why then impose the sales tax on imported fruits like apples, oranges, pears and bananas?
These items are consumed by the middle class and lower-income groups. I believe you have confused this with the government’s objective of encouraging the consumption of local fruits.
In that case, find ways to increase the production of local fruits by getting state governments to allocate more land, especially for fruit production, and many other ways of incentivising local fruit production.
Fund more research and development into better methods of fruit cultivation and improving the quality of local fruits. Find better methods of distribution, as fruits are a highly perishable commodity.
Food security is very important, and that includes keeping prices low.
A healthy population is essential for national development and to avoid spending money on many things, like healthcare.
The government should get this priority right. Always. - Mkini


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2025/06/tax-rich-rings-hollow-when-many.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
When Code Replaces Connection The Rise Of Trustless Systems

When Code Replaces Connection The Rise Of Trustless Systems

papar berkaitan - pada 9/6/2025 - jumlah : 180 hits
Letter to EditorIN TODAY S fast moving world a strange new term is now making waves trustless society At first glance it sounds like a dystopian nightmare which refers to a world where no one trusts anyone But the truth is more complicated ...
Honey Trap When Seduction Meets Spycraft In The Shadows Of Power

Honey Trap When Seduction Meets Spycraft In The Shadows Of Power

papar berkaitan - pada 21/6/2025 - jumlah : 258 hits
Honey Trap When Seduction Meets Spycraft in the Shadows of Power Are you ready The date 20 June 2025 is about to get dangerously addictive Astro Originals is back with a bang and potentially a dagger behind its back with its latest premium ...
When The Heat Rises So Do The Mosquitoes And Dengue

When The Heat Rises So Do The Mosquitoes And Dengue

papar berkaitan - pada 17/6/2025 - jumlah : 161 hits
MALAYSIA is currently experiencing prolonged periods of extreme heat and while much of the public concern has focused on heatstroke and energy consumption another pressing issue is unfolding quietly an increase in mosquito activity particul...
Pmx Should Minimise Speaking Off The Cuff On Unfamiliar Subject Gst Isn T General Services Tax

Pmx Should Minimise Speaking Off The Cuff On Unfamiliar Subject Gst Isn T General Services Tax

papar berkaitan - pada 18/6/2025 - jumlah : 124 hits
SHOULD 5 appear too small Be thankful I don t take it all Those immortal lyrics were a sarcastic jab aimed at Her Majesty s revenue collector and sung by the Beatles way back in 1966 in the tune Taxman Those same sentiments appear to remain...
Why Develop Local Talent When You Can Hire From The Amazon

Why Develop Local Talent When You Can Hire From The Amazon

papar berkaitan - pada 14/6/2025 - jumlah : 180 hits
SATIRE Ah the beautiful game Where dreams are made national pride is bought and football agents laugh their way to the bank while selling you a Brazilian who could have played in the Siberian Beer League Move over Drive for show putt for do...
Goat Grazes On Grass High Above On Power Line Glitch In The Matrix

Goat Grazes On Grass High Above On Power Line Glitch In The Matrix

papar berkaitan - pada 11/6/2025 - jumlah : 174 hits
A BIZZARE video recently captured the attention of social media users showing a goat perched on an overhead power line The incident thought to have occurred somewhere in Indonesia was filmed from a moving vehicle on a busy roadway In the sh...
Teori Profil Rahsia Alicia Apa Sebenarnya Peranan Tersembunyi Dalam Ejen Ali The Movie 2

Teori Profil Rahsia Alicia Apa Sebenarnya Peranan Tersembunyi Dalam Ejen Ali The Movie 2

papar berkaitan - pada 11/6/2025 - jumlah : 170 hits
Dalam Ejen Ali The Movie 2 ramai peminat mula tertanya tanya Siapa sebenarnya Alicia Kenapa dia makin misteri dan macam ada agenda sendiri Berikut ialah beberapa teori menarik dari peminat yang mungkin dedahkan profil rahsia Alicia 1 Alicia...
Navigate The World Of Online Business

Navigate The World Of Online Business

papar berkaitan - pada 11/6/2025 - jumlah : 222 hits
Top Ways to Navigate the World of Online Business E commerce and Digital Entrepreneurship Starting an online business can feel like riding a roller coaster exciting unpredictable and sometimes a little scary In this guide we dive into every...
Mps Have The Right To Criticise Their Own Party

Mps Have The Right To Criticise Their Own Party

papar berkaitan - pada 11/6/2025 - jumlah : 122 hits
YOURSAY PKR is on the path towards self destruction under Anwar EmEmKay In the realm of politics the pressures can be overwhelming As representatives politicians often bear the weight of their constituents hopes and frustrations A holiday e...
Teguran Kerana Sayang Bukan Kerana Benci

From Panel To Screen Why Webtoons Are Hollywood S Next Blockbuster Pipeline

Malaysian Couple Defy Norms Celebrate Love Despite Disability

Tahniah Good Boy Capai Rating Tertinggi Sementara Our Movie Cipta Rekod Baru Sabtu

Rendang Daging Brisket Dan Ujian Kehidupan

Hiburan Bakal Tak Ada Syarifah Tapi Ada Dayang Uai Jawab Pertanyaan Syed Saddiq Tentang Perkahwinan Syed Amp Syarifah

Mayat Berbicara Pakar Patologi Forensik Bantu Mayat Berbicara

Jabatan Mufti Pahang Dedah Fahaman New Age Movement Mula Menyusup Dalam Masyarakat Di Negara Ini


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


Elected Decay

Penyokong Najib Tidak Perlu Terpengaruh Dengan Kenyataan Rafizi

10 Perkara Yang Buat Blog Menjadi Viral Diminati Ramai Pembaca

Eddy Azman Suram Chord

Masdo Begini Jadinya Chord

Speed Read The Luxe Brough Superior X Richard Mille Rmb01 And More