Malaysia Day More Than A Holiday Less Than A Celebration

---

 


For many Malaysians, Sept 16 arrived not with a bang, but with the quiet sigh of a welcome day off. It felt like any other public holiday. There was a certain happiness, of course, that comes from memories of the past.
But as the flags flutter, a more complex and ambivalent feeling settled in. What, exactly, are we celebrating? We want to experience the joy of being an independent nation. We want to celebrate the happiness of being one people united under a single flag.
But our feelings are mixed. The sky is downcast. The weather is uncertain.
There is no question about it. That day in history was significant. This was the day in 1963 when the Federation of Malaya was joined by Sabah, Sarawak, and Singapore to create a new nation: Malaysia.
ADSIt was a milestone in our evolution, a moment when our country grew in size, population, and stature overnight. We became a more significant political entity on the world stage, fortified by formidable leadership and rich diversity brought by our new partners.
Reflecting on this genesis should fill us with a sense of pride.
But our national story is not a simple one. The family portrait from 1963 is now different. The painful schism of 1965, which saw Singapore leave the federation, remains a source of national contemplation.
Whether they left or were expelled is a debate that still stirs controversy. It was the result of a fundamental clash of visions between Lee Kuan Yew’s concept of a "Malaysian Malaysia" and the Malay leadership of Umno, who saw dominant Malay leadership in Malaysia as the sine qua non of our very being. Separation was inevitable and permanent.
Complicated emotions
Today, we look across the causeway at Singapore’s remarkable advances and feel a complicated mix of emotions: a sibling’s pride in their success, tinged with the melancholic question of how different things might have been.
This feeling is made all the more poignant by the knowledge that much of Singapore’s achievement was, and continues to be, built on the talent of Malaysians.
Johor CausewayWe are a nation that produces immense talent, yet we watch with a heavy heart as talent moves abroad, seeking greener pastures, contributing to the success stories of other nations.
But what of us who remain? Has the expanded Malaysia been a great success for all its members? The wealth generated from the vast oil and gas reserves in Sabah and Sarawak has undoubtedly benefited the nation’s coffers.
Yet, a persistent murmur of discontent from our East Malaysian partners forms the most troubling counter-narrative to our celebration.
For decades, leaders and citizens in both states have voiced their grievances, pointing to a lack of development and infrastructure that stands in stark contrast to the immense natural wealth extracted from their territories.
They claim they do not receive a fair share of the revenue, and a deep-seated unhappiness with their treatment at the hands of the federal government simmers beneath the surface of national unity.
ADSThey should also look to their own leaders and ask the difficult questions. There has been failure at both ends.
What do we celebrate?
And here in West Malaysia, what do we celebrate?
Our achievements are considerable. We are an industrial nation producing chips and computer peripherals for advanced nations. We have hundreds of degree-awarding institutions.
Our landscape, especially in the major cities, is that of a developed nation. As is our infrastructure - roads, railways, ports and airports, telecommunications, fixed and wireless. We are into 5G today.
But there is political turbulence.
PAS wants an Islamic state where non-Muslims will not be in leadership positions? Bersatu wants “ketuanan Melayu” (Malay supremacy) to be the operating ideology of the government.
Anwar Ibrahim struggles to maintain his coalition with Umno and with several East Malaysian parties. With uncertain Malay support, DAP takes a back seat, afraid Malay support will disappear altogether if DAP were perceived to have a more visible role.
Malays are threatened by non-Malays. Non-Malays are getting increasingly anxious about their place in Malaysia. But is it about race, or is it about poverty and the cost of living?
Poverty in the country remains high. The B40 could be the B50 or higher. Many families struggle to put food on the table. Universal education does not seem to be lifting people out of poverty.
Is it the quality of education and low productivity? Is it the presence of large numbers of foreign workers that depresses wages for our own people? Is it corruption?
Moments of reflection
So this brings us back to the central question: Who is truly celebrating Malaysia Day? The answer is as complex as the nation itself.
Perhaps the most honest celebration is not found in grand parades or public displays of patriotism, but in these quiet, candid moments of reflection.
It is celebrated by those who acknowledge the unfulfilled promises, who question the established narrative, and who dare to look at our national journey with clear eyes, seeing both the triumphs and the tribulations.
Acknowledging this complexity - the hopeful beginning, the painful separation, the shared wealth, and the lingering inequities - is not an act of disloyalty.
On the contrary, it is the most profound form of patriotism. It is the necessary first step toward building the more equitable and prosperous union that was envisioned back in 1963.
So yes, for many, Malaysia Day is just a holiday. But it is also an annual invitation: to reflect, to question, and to recommit ourselves to the spirit of a partnership that, while strained, is still worth fighting for.
In that honest assessment lies the true cause for commemoration.
Happy Malaysia Day, indeed. - Mkini
DAVID DASS is a lawyer, Malaysiakini subscriber, and commentator.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.

---