Death Penalty Report Notes Gaps In Legal Aid Secretive Pardons Process




A report on the death penalty in Malaysia has highlighted inmates’ struggles with legal representation and with a “secretive” pardons system and called on the government to reform both these processes
Compiled by human rights NGO Amnesty International, the “Fatally Flawed: Why Malaysia Must Abolish the Death Penalty” report noted the gaps in existing legal aid mechanisms
There are three legal aid schemes for death penalty cases, managed respectively by the judicial system, a free-services government agency called the National Legal Aid Foundation (NLAF) and the Malaysian Bar
According to the report, the Bar provides aid to all who need it before and during their trial. The system run by the courts is also available to all but does not cover pre-trial procedures like police arrests, questioning and bail

The NLAF steps in for such procedures but its services are only limited to Malaysian citizens
Amnesty’s report states that of the 1,281 people on death row as of February 2019, foreign nationals make up a significant 44 percent (568 people)
Aside from depriving foreign nationals of complete legal aid, the international NGO also found that insufficient funding for these mechanisms hinders Malaysians from accessing proper representation, especially those who live in rural areas and who are not able to afford a lawyer
This proves most problematic when charges carrying a mandatory death sentence are involved
“Lawyers and other representatives of prisoners on death row told Amnesty International that it has been a common experience for those arrested for offences that could result in the death penalty - and who cannot hire a lawyer independently - not to receive legal assistance at the time of arrest or during their time on police remand, before the charges are brought
“[...] when a conviction may lead to the death penalty, the geographical disparity in the provision of free and competent legal assistance raises further concerns in relation to the unequal protection of the law against arbitrary deprivation of life
“It is further concerning that because of how legal aid is structured in the different schemes that provide no free legal representatives until the trial is due to start, many defendants are left awaiting trial without any legal assistance for significant periods that have extended from months to, in most cases, two to five years,” the report read
For foreign nationals, the report noted delays of more than 24 hours to several days before their respective embassies were informed of their arrests. This is despite international law which states that prompt communication is necessary
Amnesty, which campaigns to end to capital punishment worldwide, called for competent legal representation be made available to all defendants
It also called upon the police to inform all detainees of their right to legal aid
‘Secretive’ pardons, executionsAside from the pre and post-trial stages, gaps in legal aid also affected the ability of inmates to acquire assistance when filing their pardon petitions, noted Amnesty
When it was available, the report cited a lawyer’s testimony about how prison officials pre-selected inmates who would be able to receive legal aid, all of whom were Malaysians
“The decision on who gets that support is not transparent and creates an additional degree of arbitrariness and discrimination in the death penalty system,” it said
The NGO further urged the government to solve the delays and lack of transparency in clemency proceedings
Pardons can only be granted by the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong and the state rulers after consulting the Pardons Board. However, clear procedures for them are not laid out in Malaysian law except for some guidelines in the Prison Regulations 2000
In practice, the report noted that inmates are often informed of their right to clemency but not the criteria for pardon consideration
Inmates and their families are often left without any news from the authorities for a long period after submitting their petition
The report also noted instances of delays by prison authorities in communicating the result of a pardon petition to an inmate’s family
“Amnesty has received information related to two positive decisions which highlighted how the outcome was communicated to the prisoners and their families with a delay of many weeks or months [...]“Left without any feedback, many prisoners re-submit their pardon applications every four years,” the report read
In the case of rejected clemency petitions, Amnesty noted that families were not informed of the date and time of impending executions except that they would happen “soon”
“Some of the letters handed over to the families were dated two weeks earlier, suggesting that the prison authorities had held on to this information until only days before the scheduled date of the hangings,” it said
Amnesty urged Pardon Boards to disclose all relevant information to inmates to allow them to prepare adequately for the pardon petitions
It also wanted the boards to promptly update inmates, their families and their lawyers on the progress of their applications
Following objections to abolishing the death penalty in toto, the Pakatan Harapan government is now looking at replacing the mandatory death penalty for 11 serious criminal offences to allow for judicial discretion
A moratorium on executions has been in place since October 2018 as the government mulls law reform
A special task force led by immediate past chief justice Richard Malanjum has also been set up to study alternative penalties for laws carrying mandatory capital punishment
Today, de facto law minister Liew Vui Keong said he expected to table a bill to abolish the mandatory death penalty in the March 2020 Dewan Rakyat sitting
Harapan had promised in its GE14 manifesto to abolish the mandatory death penalty.  - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2019/10/death-penalty-report-notes-gaps-in.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Must+

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Ag Pledges To Support Bill For Legal Aid Law

Ag Pledges To Support Bill For Legal Aid Law

papar berkaitan - pada 15/10/2019 - jumlah : 64 hits
Attorney General Tommy Thomas paints on a lion head part of the dance troupe performing at the opening of the Bar Council Legal Aid Centre s new premise in Kuala Lumpur KUALA LUMPUR Attorney General Tommy Thomas today called for a new law t...
Short Notes What Is Business Process Management

Short Notes What Is Business Process Management

papar berkaitan - pada 15/10/2019 - jumlah : 108 hits
BPMProcess should be Modeled Automated Integrated Monitored OptimizedBPM Higher performance of organisations Understanding Design Execution OptimizationBPMS Technological solution that supports the strategy of BPM within the organisationBPM...
Najib Shafee S Second Bid To Oust Sri Ram Abuse Of Legal Process Agc

Najib Shafee S Second Bid To Oust Sri Ram Abuse Of Legal Process Agc

papar berkaitan - pada 4/10/2019 - jumlah : 49 hits
The Attorney General s Chambers and two others want the Federal Court to determine whether Najib Abdul Razak and his lawyer Muhammad Shafee Abdullah s second legal bid to oust Gopal Sri Ram from prosecuting the duo s criminal cases amount t...
Sabah Probes Report Of Teacher Who Stapled Pupil S Ear

Sabah Probes Report Of Teacher Who Stapled Pupil S Ear

papar berkaitan - pada 1/10/2019 - jumlah : 45 hits
Sabah director of education Misterine Radin PETALING JAYA Sabah education officials are investigating a report of a teacher who was alleged to have stapled the ears of a 10 year old pupil in Likas State director of education Misterine Radin...
Submission Of Uec Report To Government Delayed

Submission Of Uec Report To Government Delayed

papar berkaitan - pada 1/10/2019 - jumlah : 45 hits
The summary findings by the Unified Examination Certificate task force which was supposed to be submitted to the government today has been postponed The report is intended to help the government decide on the recognition of the qualificatio...
Police Yet To Receive Adib S Inquest Report Igp

Police Yet To Receive Adib S Inquest Report Igp

papar berkaitan - pada 4/10/2019 - jumlah : 48 hits
The police have not received the official inquest report for firefighter Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim Inspector General of Police Abdul Hamid Bador said today Once we receive it we will go through it and then we will see what we can do he told...
Uec Panel Chief Positive Over Report Depressed Over Racialisation

Uec Panel Chief Positive Over Report Depressed Over Racialisation

papar berkaitan - pada 1/10/2019 - jumlah : 39 hits
Unified Examination Certificate task force chief Eddin Khoo who will submit a summary finding on the education qualification used by Chinese independent schools to the government soon said he is positive about the report which provides cont...
Nrd Lodges Police Report Over 200 000 New Citizenship Claims

Nrd Lodges Police Report Over 200 000 New Citizenship Claims

papar berkaitan - pada 30/9/2019 - jumlah : 56 hits
The National Registration Department today lodged a police report on the claims made by Twitter and Facebook accounts holder Tengku Raja Alam Shah regarding a posting titled 200 000 new recipients of citizenship vow to repay the government ...
Sorry All My Old Notes Taken By Ph Najib Tells Self Styled Antique Collector

Sorry All My Old Notes Taken By Ph Najib Tells Self Styled Antique Collector

papar berkaitan - pada 11/10/2019 - jumlah : 147 hits
PETALING JAYA Former prime minister Najib Razak took a swipe at the Pakatan Harapan government today in what appears to be a light hearted response to a spam message on social media enquiring about antique coins The message was left as a co...
Gaji Rm140 000 Sebulan

Iphone 12 New Design Leaks Four Cameras Up To Price

Tikus Dijumpai Di Marikh

Filem Dia Pun Kualiti Rendah Ahmad Idham Dikecam Bila Gesa Kerajaan Tapis Netflix

Model Antarabangsa Tawan Dunia Dengan Muka Jeragat Mereka

Drama Titian Takdir

3d Corridor Wallpaper Wall Decor

Wow Mufti Wp Temui Sesuatu Semasa Spot Check Ke Wisma Fam Hanya 24 Jam Sebelum Aksi Malaysia Indonesia



6 Kisah Orang Sanggup Gadai Nyawa Untuk Matlamat Tersendiri

8 Wabak Penyakit yang Paling Membinasakan

Superiority Complex Orang China Ingin Kuasai Dunia Semangat Tianxia

7 Fakta Dahsyat Tentang Krisis Vape Yang Semakin Membimbangkan

6 Bandar Utama Dalam Sejarah Kegemilangan Islam


Dilema Rm52 Juta Pochettino

Polis Hong Kong Turut Menahan Sukarelawan Perubatan Dan Wartawan Di Luar Universiti Politeknik Hong Kong

Hishammuddin Khianati Rakyat Lagi Kata Lokman Adam

Punca Dari Main Basikal Lajak Sempat Lagi Membahan Zizan Lega Uai Makin Sembuh

Datang Mesyuarat Parti Wan Azizah Beritahu Azmin

Masalah Tinja Melekat Pada Mangkuk Tandas Diselesaikan Dengan Lapisan Permukaan Adilicin Ini