Whistleblowers Must Be Genuinely Protected


 


Some weeks ago, Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Parliament and Law) Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar informed Parliament that amendments to the Whistleblower Protection Act 2010 ("WPA") are being studied and evaluated by the government, and will be tabled to the Cabinet next month.
The minister told Parliament that there had been 73,545 complaints received under the Act since 2011, but only 527 of those complainants received protection under Act 711.
"This is a very small percentage of those who have received protection, and it either shows flaws in the enforcement of the law or actual weaknesses in its legal framework and provisions, and that is why we are currently studying amendments to the Act," he was quoted to have said.
According to him, there are seven issues in the WPA which have been identified and will be improved. He cited, amongst others, several sections which are being studied.
While these reviews are timely and much needed, it is hoped that the government will truly have the political will to amend the fundamental weaknesses of the Act.
The WPA has been around for more than a decade since it was made law in 2010. It was enacted to give protection to whistleblowers.
The Act was designed to facilitate disclosures of improper conduct in the public and private sector, protect them from detrimental action, and provide for investigations to be carried out, amongst others.
According to the Act, a 'whistleblower' is any person who makes a disclosure of improper conduct to an enforcement agency.
Meanwhile, according to the Act, ' improper conduct would be any conduct that constitutes a disciplinary or criminal offence.
Once a whistleblower makes a disclosure to an enforcement agency, the whistleblower shall be conferred protection under the WPA 2010.
This protection comes in three forms.
First is the protection of confidential information. The whistleblower's confidential information, such as information about identity, occupation, address or whereabouts of the whistleblower, shall not be disclosed in any civil, criminal or other proceedings.
The second is immunity from civil and criminal action. The whistleblower shall not be subject to any civil or criminal liability for disclosing improper conduct.
The third is the widest form of protection – that against 'detrimental action'.
Flaw in the Act
'Detrimental action' includes any action causing injury, loss, damage, intimidation or harassment and any adverse treatment or action whether it is in employment, trade, business or protection of a person because the whistleblower has made a disclosure of improper conduct.
The Act empowers enforcement agencies to investigate complaints of detrimental action and allows the court to order damages, compensation, injunction and other remedies against the party who makes the detrimental action.
One major flaw in the Act is that the disclosure made must not be prohibited by any written law.
This would mean that disclosure of matters covered by the Official Secrets Act 1972, for example, would not attract protection under the WPA 2010.
Consider the offence under Section 203A of the Penal Code of 'disclosure of information'. Under the section, a person who discloses any information or matter which he has obtained in the performance of his duties, or the exercise of his functions under any written law, commits an offence.
So, for example, if an individual uncovers improper conduct in a ministry, but that information is classified by the Official Secrets Act (OSA), even if he discloses it to an enforcement agency, he will not be accorded protection under the WPA.
Laws such as the OSA and Section 203A of the Penal Code resulted in many whistleblowers and potential whistleblowers not falling under the ambit of protection within the WPA.
Excluding disclosures that are prohibited under the law is a major weakness in this Act. If the government truly intends to give proper protection to a whistleblower, this must be addressed. - Mkini


SYAHREDZAN JOHAN is a civil liberties lawyer and political secretary to Iskandar Puteri MP Lim Kit Siang.

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2021/11/whistleblowers-must-be-genuinely.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Agc Must Explain Appeal Withdrawal In Ku Nan S Graft Case Malaysian Bar

Agc Must Explain Appeal Withdrawal In Ku Nan S Graft Case Malaysian Bar

papar berkaitan - pada 20/11/2021 - jumlah : 136 hits
The Attorney General s Chambers must explain its decision to withdraw an appeal against former federal territories minister Tengku Adnan Tengku Mansor s acquittal in a graft case In a statement the Malaysian Bar said it was perturbed by the...
Gulf Asian Nations Must Remain Vigilant In Fighting Extremism Hishammuddin

Gulf Asian Nations Must Remain Vigilant In Fighting Extremism Hishammuddin

papar berkaitan - pada 20/11/2021 - jumlah : 107 hits
Hishammuddin said the developments in Afghanistan may serve as a morale booster to dormant militant groups in Southeast Asia giving rise to the concern that both regions may once again become a haven for terror groups seeking a new base 821...
Pakatan Must Embrace Unanimity Rule To Avoid Costly Election Mistakes Like Accepting Political Frogs Says Kit Siang

Pakatan Must Embrace Unanimity Rule To Avoid Costly Election Mistakes Like Accepting Political Frogs Says Kit Siang

papar berkaitan - pada 22/11/2021 - jumlah : 82 hits
Pakatan Harapan must make decisions as a coalition so that it can avoid mistakes such as fielding political frogs which cost it Melaka in the just ended state election DAP veteran Lim Kit Siang said today The Iskandar Puteri MP stressed tha...
Anti Hop Law Proposal Must Consider Constitution Sabah Speaker

Anti Hop Law Proposal Must Consider Constitution Sabah Speaker

papar berkaitan - pada 17/11/2021 - jumlah : 94 hits
Datuk Kadzim M Yahya KOTA KINABALU The proposal to table the anti hop law must consider Article 10 of the Federal Constitution before it could be made effective Sabah Legislative Assembly Speaker Datuk Kadzim M Yahya opined that it should b...
What Ph Must Do To Win Back Govt

What Ph Must Do To Win Back Govt

papar berkaitan - pada 17/11/2021 - jumlah : 96 hits
From Ramesh Chander Murray Hunter and Lim Teck GheeThe next general election is a more important watershed than GE14 for three reasons First the Covid 19 crisis has put Malaysia into a deep recession where many Malaysians are suffering fina...
The Reason Why Zeti And Shamsiah Protected Jho Low S Father

The Reason Why Zeti And Shamsiah Protected Jho Low S Father

papar berkaitan - pada 24/11/2021 - jumlah : 80 hits
Hence if Zeti and Shamsiah revealed that Jho Low s father had received RM48 456 million from 1MDB the RM65 million that Zeti s husband received from Jho Low would also come to light So they had to protect Jho Low s father to protect Zeti an...
Kisah Amat Sedih Pelarian Islam Orang Islam Mesti Baca Muslims Must Read

Kisah Amat Sedih Pelarian Islam Orang Islam Mesti Baca Muslims Must Read

papar berkaitan - pada 17/11/2021 - jumlah : 73 hits
Tuan Tuan as you are reading this there is a serious refugee crisis going on in Europe This crisis has been going for over SIX years already Right now thousands of migrants from the Middle East the majority of whom are Muslims are strugglin...
Tommy Thomas The Home Minister During Ph S Time And Dr Mahathir Must Give Us Answers

Tommy Thomas The Home Minister During Ph S Time And Dr Mahathir Must Give Us Answers

papar berkaitan - pada 23/11/2021 - jumlah : 101 hits
Lim Sian See YB Baling asked about Zeti s case and the Law Minister officially replied in parliament That the police only knew about Zeti s husband being paid close to RM700 million by Jho Low in the year 2019 during the time of PH and that...
Show Must Go On Vide0 Walaupun Berdepan Mas4lah Teknikal Kumpulan Zapin Ini Dipuji Tetap Profesional

Show Must Go On Vide0 Walaupun Berdepan Mas4lah Teknikal Kumpulan Zapin Ini Dipuji Tetap Profesional

papar berkaitan - pada 24/11/2021 - jumlah : 60 hits
Para penari tarian tradisional di luar sana pasti ada yang pernah mengalami situasi berdepan dengan mas4lah teknikal ketika beraksi di pentas kan Tak kesah lah mas4lah tu datang daripada silap sendiri ke antara sesama ahli ke ataupun daripa...
Saham Azam Baki Speaker Ada Kuasa Buka Pendengaran Psc Pada Awam Diterbitkan Jan 17 2022 10 42 Am Dikemaskini 10 42 Am

Gadis Serik Amal Diet Air Mineral Selepas Takut Tengok Kesannya Sekarang Pagi Pagi Dah Makan Nasi Lemak

Tarikh Dividen Kwsp 2021 Cara Semak Dividen Kwsp Online

Batu Dalam Pedal Ayam

Sedapnya Lauk Pucuk Ubi Masak Lemak

10 Pantun Sindiran Untuk Orang Yang Tak Bayar Hutang

Tak Berani Pergi Hospital Swasta

Penganggur Khayal Dadah Penggal Kepala Ibu Kandung Guna Parang



Saya Tidak Berani Tidur Sendirian Gempa Bumi Gegarkan Indonesia Iqbal Kongsi Detik Cemas

5 Terowong Jalan Raya Terpanjang di Dunia

7 Gempa Bumi Paling Dahsyat Pada Abad ke 21

Senarai Lagu Tugasan Konsert Akhir Gegar Vaganza 2021 GV8 Minggu 10

Keputusan Markah Peserta Konsert Gegar Vaganza 2021 GV8 Minggu 9 Separuh Akhir


Love Of My Life

Terima Kasih 6 Juta View

Menjadikan Setiap Hidangan Biasa Lebih Istimewa Dengan Haco Suiss Culinary Dry Mix Edaran Qsrt

Sambung Kepopularitian The Red Sleeve Di Mbc Tracer Terus Raih Rating Tinggi

Mengenal Tren Mochi Skin Dari Jepang Tren Kulit Selembut Dan Sekenyal Kue Mochi

Terlebih Makan Pisang Beberapa Makanan Ini Punca Anak Sembelit