The Real Issue Is Intra Malay Economic Inequality

MP SPEAKS | Our 2019 Merdeka and Malaysia Day celebrations were marred by calls from certain quarters for the Malay community to prioritise Muslim businesses and boycott non-Muslim businesses
The supposed reasons for this initiative is to improve the economic standing of the Malays, as well as to somehow defend the position of Islam and Malays. The underlying reason was the upcoming Umno-PAS gathering
But is a boycott a viable solution for both causes
The economic problems of the Malays are not new. The British Colonial policy of divide and rule, as well as the failed laissez-faire policies of the post-Merdeka Alliance government, contributed to the May 13, 1969, tragedy
After that, the New Economic Policy (NEP) was introduced, which aimed to eradicate poverty irrespective of race and to eliminate the identification of ethnicity with economic function.In its earlier stages, the NEP involved large investments in education, with extensive scholarship opportunities. This is what largely drove the creation of today’s Malay middle class
But the NEP was only supposed to last for 20 years, meaning its “expiry date” was back in 1990
Today, the NEP, as well as the practices it inspired, are still in place. However, the gap between rich and poor Malays has widened
No one is denying the good the NEP did
However, today, this policy that only takes race into account disproportionately benefits the Malay elite. It gives them better educational and economic outcomes than their fellow Malay counterparts: the urban poor, low-ranked government employees, Felda settlers and fishermen
Why? Part of it is because the NEP became a victim of its own success
Let us consider the bumiputra-reserved Amanah Saham Bumiputra’s (ASB) investment statistics. A total of 7.4 million unit holders or 76.92 percent of them have unit sizes below RM5,000, based on ASB’s 2018 Annual Report
Only 0.24 percent have a holding size of RM500,001 and above. However, 9.15 percent of the unit holders have subscribed to 81.83 percent of total units or more than RM127.5 billion. The 7.4 million holders of the smallest units only have RM4.1 billion or just 2.65 percent of the total units
The same is true for Tabung Haji (TH). The original function of TH was to enable savings by the Muslim community to perform the haj. It was not supposed to morph into a form of investments for the public
However, 50 percent of the funds in TH’s savings accounts come from only 1.3 percent of its contributors. There is, according to media reports, an individual who contributed RM190 million
Widening gap between rich and poor MalaysThese statistics show that although the NEP created a Malay middle class, it has done little to close the widening gap between rich and poor Malays. This is the community’s biggest economic challenge today
Our focus has been on the disparities among the races, but not within Malaysia’s ethnic groups - including the Malays. Continuing to ignore this will condemn the less well-off Malays and Malaysians to indefinite penury and exclusion
Progress away from this paradigm has been hampered by the fact that our economic model is still stuck in the old, low-wage export model framework. It’s typically used for emerging economies to compete
This was the transition that South Korea, Taiwan and Singapore - economies that were once at the same level as us - had gone through. However, they increased productivity and wage rates by adding value to their economies
However, unlike them, wages in Malaysia have stagnated. Our open policy in hiring foreign workers has also not helped
We must also not forget how our economy fell victim to corruption and abuse of power
The damage that the 1MDB, TH, Yapeim and other alleged scandals have caused on not only Malaysia’s public image, but also the credibility of bumiputera institutions, is well known
Interestingly, PAS, which has backed the boycott campaign, had visited the 1MDB and TH managements when they first began to ally with Umno. PAS’ leaders reportedly even stated that they were satisfied with the excuses given to them over the various allegations
Rather than act as a check-and-balance, PAS instead inexplicably chose to provide “cover” to the abuses of the previous government
What must we do to move our community forward? We have a choice
Yes, there have been studies on discrimination faced by the bumiputera in the private sector, and that must be dealt with
But are we going to be swayed by demagoguery or are we going to take concrete steps to resolve the Malay - and hence the wider national economic crisis - by looking at the problems within our community
Countries like Vietnam have surpassed us while Malaysia wallows in its archaic economic model and endemic corruption
Need to free T20 Malays to compete with other racesWe need to free the T20 Malays to compete with other races while providing support to the urban poor, farmers and workers, many of whom are Malays and bumiputera
Bumiputera affirmative action must be appropriate and needs-driven: T20 Malays should no longer exploit benefits meant for their B40 and M40 compatriots
For instance, the government should consider whether ASB accounts that are over the investment limit of RM200,000 should be allowed to reinvest their dividends or if accounts only below that value are to be prioritised - because the latter make up the majority
Currently, accounts are still permitted to collect dividends that can be invested on top of the RM200,000 cap, arguably benefiting only a small Malay elite
TH should also return to its roots as a savings fund for haj at a reasonable rate
In 2019, the Muassasah haj cost stood at around RM22,900 while the subsidy given out by TH is RM12,920. Therefore, those who wish to perform the haj only need to save RM9,980
Non-core GLCs and those that have overlapping functions at the federal and state levels can be rationalised through management buyouts (MBOs), subject to terms and conditions
The majority of GLC managements consists of bumiputeras. Therefore, they will benefit from the experience of competing and succeeding in the corporate world. Also, the government sector will not monopolise the financial market
It is likely that these proposals may spark further controversy. But if we are not ready to face these issues head-on and honestly, ordinary Malays will continue to be left behind
I have delved more deeply into these issues in my book, Moving Forward: Malays for the 21st Century, which was first published in 2009 and has now been re-released with a new foreword and additional notes
Boycotts are not the solution to uplift the Malays. Rather, our salvation will lie in a willingness to adopt bold and wise policies, as well as having leaders who are willing to see them through
NIK NAZMI NIK AHMAD is the chief organising secretary of PKR and Setiawangsa Member of Parliament. He regularly writes in Malay and English. His two latest books, 9 May 2018: Notes from the Frontline and a revised edition of Moving Forward: Malays for the 21st Century, are out in the market. - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Who Cares About The Non Malay Voters

Who Cares About The Non Malay Voters

papar berkaitan - pada 20/9/2019 - jumlah : 145 hits
Moaz s comment that with Umno aligning with PAS the non Malay voters would abandon both the parties clearly shows this person is no political analyst The non Malays have already abandoned Umno and PAS With 97 Chinese and 85 Indians voting P...
The Kind Of Economic Management We Have

The Kind Of Economic Management We Have

papar berkaitan - pada 6/9/2019 - jumlah : 94 hits
I DON T wanna contemplate what s brewing at the top It s their business it s their turf I am just concerned about the economy which is already having an adverse bearing on the nation and its people Worry is not my domain now it is becoming ...
The Reason Malay Professors Are Called Professor Kangkong

The Reason Malay Professors Are Called Professor Kangkong

papar berkaitan - pada 18/9/2019 - jumlah : 118 hits
The fact that Mahathir Daim and Anwar escaped punishment is not because they are innocent It is because Pakatan Harapan is abusing its power by NOT taking any action against Mahathir Daim and Anwar after promising to do so before GE14 NO HO...
Setting Up Of The New Political Alliance

Setting Up Of The New Political Alliance

papar berkaitan - pada 10/9/2019 - jumlah : 171 hits
This weekend will witness the formalisation of a new political alliance between the two largest Malay parties Umno and PAS It happened once before when the nation was in turmoil following the 1969 tragedy but the pact did not last long It w...
Seeing Through The Haze Comment

Seeing Through The Haze Comment

papar berkaitan - pada 10/9/2019 - jumlah : 126 hits
For months Malaysia has been treated to a relentless deluge of advertisments and ministerial statements promoted by the palm oil lobby denouncing environmentalists concerned about the effect of their mega industry on the environment made fa...
Warner Bros Bikin The Matrix 4 Sebab Tak Nak Keanu Reeves Sertai Mcu Atau Dceu

Warner Bros Bikin The Matrix 4 Sebab Tak Nak Keanu Reeves Sertai Mcu Atau Dceu

papar berkaitan - pada 10/9/2019 - jumlah : 138 hits
Keanu Reeves kini kembali gemilang setelah namanya pudar beberapa tahun lepas Semuanya gara gara watak lakonannya dalam filem John Wick yang berjaya memberi namanya sinaran Dan seperti biasa lamaran untuk lakonan bagi pelakon lejen ini suda...
Unlock The Full Potential Of Social Media In Your Company

Unlock The Full Potential Of Social Media In Your Company

papar berkaitan - pada 10/9/2019 - jumlah : 152 hits
div emailPreHeader display none important We ll hand you the keys in our Summer Social Series PRE HEADER TEXT Here s how we can help PRE HEADER TEXT OUTER if endif BACKGROUND BACKGROUND INNER TABLE if
Hindu Coalition Stung Over Agc S Decision To Let Zamri Vinoth Off The Hook

Hindu Coalition Stung Over Agc S Decision To Let Zamri Vinoth Off The Hook

papar berkaitan - pada 10/9/2019 - jumlah : 93 hits
A coalition of Hindu NGOs today demanded the Attorney General s Chambers to review its decision not to press charges against Islamic preacher Zamri Vinoth who allegedly insulted Hinduism and its followers in a ceramah in December last year ...
Same Day Flower Delivery Customizing A Bouquet For Delivery Within The Day Little Flower Hut

Same Day Flower Delivery Customizing A Bouquet For Delivery Within The Day Little Flower Hut

papar berkaitan - pada 10/9/2019 - jumlah : 104 hits
Same Day Flower Delivery Customizing a Bouquet for Delivery within the Day Little Flower HutFlowers are the most touching and meaningful gift that you can give to a very special person in your life especially during occasions and events If ...
Bung Moktar Calon Ketua Menteri Sabah

Kluster Sivagangga Bertambah Kes Baharu

Lebih 200 Kanak Kanak Hadiri Kem Musim Panas Dijangkiti Covid 19 Selepas Penganjur Tak Wajibkan Pakai Topeng Muka

Viral Suami Positif Cov1d 19 Kerana Makan Di Restoran Sivagangga Isteri Tampil Tepis Dakw4an P4lsu

Muafakat Nasional Muafakat Untuk Semua Ahmad Zahid

Berwajah Tampan Lelaki Ini Di Usir Dari Negara Sendiri

Ini Rupanya Asal Usul Nama Kluster Sivaganga

Resepi Sambal Daging Cili Api Kacang Panjang Sekali Cuba Pasti Nak Lagi

Resepi Aiskrim Durian Paling Lemak Manis

Bagaimana Seorang Warga Singapura Menjadi Ejen Risikan Kerajaan China

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Jalan Sesat Ke Syurga Slot Tiara

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Pink Smile Slot Lestary TV3

Resepi Kek Durian Paling Gebu dan Lembut

Sambal Sotong Pujaan Hati Shein

Kaedah Fikih Kata Yang Memberikan Makna Umum

Perkongsian Pagi Hati

Daging Bergerak Gerak Sendiri Lalu Muncul Lafaz Allah

Termometer Infrared Tidak Pancar Radiasi Dr Noor Hisham Abdullah

Sb Satay Bakar Shah Alam Resipi Temurun Sate Terkenal Sungai Besar