Should The Isa Be Brought Back


 
From Dave Ananth
The Internal Security Act (ISA) once symbolised both the strength and the frailty of Malaysia’s legal framework.
Introduced to maintain national security, it allowed detention without trial but became infamous for its misuse during events like Operation Lalang in 1987.
Repealed in 2012 due to widespread criticism of its incompatibility with the principles of natural justice and the rule of law, the ISA’s absence is increasingly felt amid the current socio-political climate.
The likes of Bersatu member Badrul Hisham Shaharin, also known as Chegubard and the man believed to be Papagomo, with their inflammatory rhetoric, underscore the urgent need for a legal mechanism to address immediate threats to national harmony.
The principles of natural justice and rule of law
Natural justice and the rule of law form the bedrock of any fair legal system. Detention without trial, as sanctioned under the ISA, bypassed these principles, stripping individuals of the right to a fair hearing. Operation Lalang’s detentions—some politically motivated—revealed how the ISA could be wielded as a tool for political suppression rather than genuine national security.
This misuse eroded public confidence in Malaysia’s justice system, painting the ISA as an authoritarian relic.
The repeal of the ISA was celebrated as a step toward democratic maturity. Laws such as the Sedition Act and Penal Code’s provisions against incitement were deemed sufficient to address inflammatory speech and actions.
However, enforcement of these laws has been marred by inconsistency. Selective prosecution has left provocateurs free to spread venomous rhetoric, while activists, authors, and cartoonists face swift action. This disparity reveals a critical gap in Malaysia’s legal framework.
Malaysia’s delicate social fabric, woven from its multicultural and multireligious populace, is under assault. Individuals exploiting racial and religious sentiments for personal or political gain threaten the unity envisioned by the nation’s founding fathers. History has shown that unchecked provocations can escalate into unrest. Yet, despite existing laws such as the Sedition Act, enforcement remains lethargic and selective.
The Penal Code’s provisions against incitement, defamation, and hate speech are sufficient on paper but falter in execution. The double standard in enforcement—where certain individuals operate with impunity while others are targeted—undermines the rule of law. This selective action emboldens provocateurs, creating a dangerous precedent.
The ISA’s preventive detention provisions, while controversial, addressed an immediate and severe threat to national security.
The law allowed swift action against individuals whose actions posed an imminent danger. Critics argued that these provisions bypassed judicial oversight, but proponents pointed to their effectiveness in averting crises.
Countries often celebrated for their adherence to human rights, such as the United Kingdom and the United States, have implemented similar measures. The UK’s Terrorism Prevention and Investigation Measures (TPIMs) and the US’s Patriot Act both allow restrictions on individuals suspected of planning or inciting violence.
These laws, while subject to oversight, reflect an understanding that certain threats require extraordinary responses. Malaysia’s current legal framework lacks a comparable mechanism, leaving the nation vulnerable.
The repeal of the ISA created a vacuum. Replacement laws like the Security Offences (Special Measures) Act 2012 (Sosma) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act 2015 (Pota) aimed to balance national security with civil liberties. Moreover, these laws lack the comprehensive immediacy the ISA provided.
The role of the home ministry
The home ministry’s failure to act decisively against incendiary figures raises critical questions about its priorities. Resources are disproportionately allocated to silencing cartoonists and authors while provocateurs inciting hatred face little to no consequences. This selective enforcement undermines public trust in the government’s commitment to national unity and the rule of law.
If the current legal framework is inadequate, it is the home ministry’s responsibility to propose amendments or introduce new legislation. However, any new measures must include safeguards against abuse. Judicial oversight, regular reviews of detention cases, and transparency are essential to ensure that preventive measures do not become tools for political suppression.
Reinstating the ISA in its original form is not the solution. Its legacy of misuse cannot be ignored. However, the principles underpinning its preventive detention provisions remain relevant. A balanced approach is required, one that combines the immediacy of preventive measures with robust safeguards for natural justice.
Malaysia stands at a crossroads. The unity and harmony envisioned by the country’s first prime minister Tunku Abdul Rahman are under threat from those exploiting divisions for personal gain. While the ISA’s legacy is fraught with controversy, its preventive detention provisions addressed a need that remains unmet in the current framework.
The path forward requires political will, equitable enforcement of existing laws, and a commitment to upholding the principles of natural justice. The home ministry must rise to the challenge, demonstrating that national security and civil liberties are not mutually exclusive.
Only then can Malaysia hope to silence the voices of hatred and uphold the ideals upon which it was founded. - FMT
Dave Ananth is a former magistrate and an FMT reader.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2025/01/should-isa-be-brought-back.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
What Malaysia Should Know About The Rohingya Crisis

What Malaysia Should Know About The Rohingya Crisis

papar berkaitan - pada 9/1/2025 - jumlah : 339 hits
From Pacifist FarooqEmbarking on the journey of 2025 Malaysia takes on the pivotal role of Asean chair under the theme of Inclusivity and Sustainability It will host a myriad of regional meetings dialogues and programmes throughout the year...
Restaurants Should Treat The Public With Dignity

Restaurants Should Treat The Public With Dignity

papar berkaitan - pada 27/12/2024 - jumlah : 180 hits
I WISH to offer my two cents on the report Table for none Manager removes table after tourist won t order and the of the incident Recently a foreign woman occupied a table at a food and beverage outlet inside the Penang International Airpor...
The Women Suffer

The Women Suffer

papar berkaitan - pada 31/12/2024 - jumlah : 114 hits
Previously had everything they could wish forgo for walks every day wedding partiesgo to parks malls everything we wantedWomen lost their being and everything in this warNow everything is destroyed DEIR AL BALAH Gaza City For Gaza s women t...
Is Tourism Booming In The Four Northern States Of Peninsula Malaysia

Is Tourism Booming In The Four Northern States Of Peninsula Malaysia

papar berkaitan - pada 31/12/2024 - jumlah : 219 hits
TOURISM is about expenditures not the number of visitors and organising events in the open that everyone can watch or promoting natural spots are not tourism but recreational activities that generate little or no revenue for organisers or p...
The Minimal Downtime Revolution Laser Skin Rejuvenation Benefits In Tallahassee

The Minimal Downtime Revolution Laser Skin Rejuvenation Benefits In Tallahassee

papar berkaitan - pada 31/12/2024 - jumlah : 126 hits
Tallahassee residents are recognizing the transformative capabilities of laser technology for dealing with various skin concerns and achieving long lasting cosmetic results treatments and laser hair removal services offer non invasive effec...
Goodbye 2024 Wrapping Up The Year With Gratitude And Hope

Goodbye 2024 Wrapping Up The Year With Gratitude And Hope

papar berkaitan - pada 31/12/2024 - jumlah : 295 hits
I can t believe we re saying goodbye to 2024 already This year has been such a mix of emotions some great moments some tough ones and a lot of reflection in between As a wife and a blogger I wanted to share my thoughts as we close this chap...
Netizen Claims That Teachers Earn Big Money But The Truth

Netizen Claims That Teachers Earn Big Money But The Truth

papar berkaitan - pada 1/1/2025 - jumlah : 221 hits
TEACHERS play an exceedingly huge role towards nation building and that involves cultivating the next generation of leaders But despite their oversized responsibility do they enjoy a paycheck that reflects their contribution to us According...
Kafe Ke 200 The Coffee Bean Tea Leaf Malaysia Dengan Pandu Masuk Pertama Di Pulau Pinang

Kafe Ke 200 The Coffee Bean Tea Leaf Malaysia Dengan Pandu Masuk Pertama Di Pulau Pinang

papar berkaitan - pada 31/12/2024 - jumlah : 359 hits
The Coffee Bean Tea Leaf Malaysia dengan bangganya meraikan pembukaan kafenya yang ke 200 berlokasi strategik di Caltex Batu Maung Pulau Pinang memperkukuhkan reputasi jenama ini sebagai peneraju dalam arena kopi dan teh bertaraf premium Lo...
A Parent S Confessional Upkk Just Kafa Or The Real Deal

A Parent S Confessional Upkk Just Kafa Or The Real Deal

papar berkaitan - pada 31/12/2024 - jumlah : 213 hits
Alright let s talk UPKK Some might say Ala KAFA je Relax lah But if you re a parent like me staring at your firstborn and this so called exam besar you know it s a whole different ball game Dah level macam nak apply universiti siap ada syar...
Menteri Besar Pahang Kalau Abang Belon Nak Berniaga Di Kuantan Dia Boleh Cuba Buat Permohonan

Ibu Terjun Ke Laut Bersama 2 Anak Di Sabah Anak Lelaki 5 Tahun Tenggelam Anak Perempuan 6 Tahun Masih Hilang

Benteng Melayu Terakhir Dengan Menara Kl Sejak Bila Menara Kl Mahu Bertukar P

Monoloque Rindu Dendam Hari Raya Chord

Zafrul As Bam President Filling Big Shoes Or A Risky Gamble

Berdentum Gegaran Disangka Pesawat Terhempas Mangsa Kebakaran

Hiburan Mangsa Terjejas Akibat Kebakaran Di Putra Height Akan Terima Bantuan Rm2500 Hingga Rm5000 Pmx

What We Know So Far About The Putra Heights Inferno


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


Raja Muda Selangor Titah Mangsa Kebakaran Ditempat Di Lokasi Lebih Selesa

Common For Gas Pipelines To Pass Through Residential Areas Says Ex Engineer

Cidb Retracts Statement On Putra Heights Blast Findings

48 Years Of Tenacious Struggle Aliran Refuses To Surrender Hope

Joker123th 100

Dior188