Mahb S Sacking Of Staff With High Medical Bill Unlawful Court Rules


 
Velarie Lesley Harry was awarded RM83,957 in back wages and compensation after her dismissal by MAHB was held to be without just cause or excuse. (Pexel pic)PETALING JAYA: The Industrial Court in Sabah has ruled that the dismissal of an airport security assistant in Kota Kinabalu for racking up a medical bill of RM25,374 over 17 months four years ago was unlawful.
Sabah Industrial Court chairman Indra Ayub ordered Malaysian Airports Holdings Bhd (MAHB) to pay Velarie Lesley Harry RM83,957 in back wages and compensation in lieu of reinstatement.
The award represents back wages of 24 months amounting to RM64,999 and compensation of one month’s salary for each of the seven years of her service totalling RM18,958.
“At the material time, the company did not have any guidelines, rules or policy for unreasonable usage of medical benefits and/or limitations in the number of visits to panel clinics.
“Furthermore, the claimant has been utilising the medical benefits as provided for in the employment offer letter and collective agreements,” Indra said in an award dated April 8.
The court also agreed with the claimant’s contention that the domestic inquiry convened by MAHB had been done arbitrarily and without regard for the rules of natural justice.
The chairman also noted that MAHB had failed to call any representative from the medical clinics visited by Velarie to verify whether she had obtained non-medical items as alleged by the company.
“It is trite law that the company bears the burden to prove that the claimant had committed the alleged misconduct and the conduct warrants the claimant’s dismissal. The company must prove the claimant guilty and it is not the Claimant who must prove herself not guilty,” said Indra.
MAHB had alleged that the claimant was among several employees who had abused the company’s medical benefits.
The company claimed that it had conducted an analysis of medical claims made by employees in 2019 and found “rampant medical claim abuses” by those working at the Kota Kinabalu International Airport (KKIA).
It said the claims made by these employees were the highest in the country despite the airport having only 480 employees.
“Claims of 24 employees of the company, including the claimant, for the 17-month period from Jan 1, 2019 were unreasonable in nature.
“Their total claims amounted to RM977,914. All of them were dismissed,” it said.
MAHB had contended that Velarie and her dependents had made “unreasonable visits” to clinics “as the dates were very close to one another, were for the same medical reasons and they had obtained the same medication in subsequent visits”.
Several employees had obtained non-medical items such as milk powder, diapers, vitamins, jamu, wet tissues and toiletries from panel clinics which are not covered under their medical benefits, the company added.
MAHB also said the claimant had refused to authorise the clinics she attended to hand over details of her visits to enable the company to verify her claims.
In response, Velarie said the clinic visits she and her dependents made were justified as they suffered from a variety of illnesses such as fits, gastritis, sore throat, skin problems, earaches and breathing difficulties.
Indra said it was “obvious that the claimant and her dependents needed constant medical care”.
“This Court is satisfied with the claimant’s explanation on why she and her dependents needed to visit the clinics often.
“It is of the view that the company had failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the dismissal was with just cause or excuse,” he said.
Ansari Abdullah and Jason Daniel Balakrishnan Christopher appeared for the claimant, while KH Chung and Kate Ngu Khet Ying defended MAHB. - FMT


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2024/04/mahbs-sacking-of-staff-with-high.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Tengku Zafrul Writes To High Court Seeking Leave To File Affidavit In Najib S Legal Bid For House Arrest

Tengku Zafrul Writes To High Court Seeking Leave To File Affidavit In Najib S Legal Bid For House Arrest

papar berkaitan - pada 23/4/2024 - jumlah : 127 hits
Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz has written to the High Court seeking its permission to file an affidavit to correct factual errors in another affidavit which claimed that the former Yang di Pertuan Agong had in an addendum order grante...
Federal Court Rules Residents Association Can Impose Conditions On Non Paying Members

Federal Court Rules Residents Association Can Impose Conditions On Non Paying Members

papar berkaitan - pada 19/4/2024 - jumlah : 77 hits
The Federal Court today dismissed an appeal by the Petaling Jaya City Council seeking to overturn a Court of Appeal decision allowing the Parkville Residents Association to require non paying members to operate boom gates themselves without...
High Court Fixes 3 Additional Trial Dates To Complete 1mdb Case

High Court Fixes 3 Additional Trial Dates To Complete 1mdb Case

papar berkaitan - pada 26/4/2024 - jumlah : 191 hits
Najib Razak s lead counsel said the defence wants to recall several witnesses but gives an assurance the re examination will be short KUALA LUMPUR The High Court here has fixed three additional trial dates to enable the prosecution to close...
Will Recent Kl High Court Ruling Open Floodgates For Non Muslims To Have Legal Mistresses

Will Recent Kl High Court Ruling Open Floodgates For Non Muslims To Have Legal Mistresses

papar berkaitan - pada 21/4/2024 - jumlah : 86 hits
Letter to EditorI WAS seated at a caf recently when I overheard a bunch of 20 something co workers seated at the next table chiding their Malay colleague Hah see now we non Muslims can also kahwin empat one exclaimed brandishing his handpho...
Mcmc Ordered By The High Court To Produce Police Instructions To Block Weechookeong Com

Mcmc Ordered By The High Court To Produce Police Instructions To Block Weechookeong Com

papar berkaitan - pada 19/4/2024 - jumlah : 109 hits
Whose interests are the MCMC acting for Murray Hunter The Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission has been ordered by Justice Amarjeet Singh to hand over documented instructions by the police and any other correspondence relating...
Go Back To Drawing Board With Citizenship Bill Saifuddin Told

Go Back To Drawing Board With Citizenship Bill Saifuddin Told

papar berkaitan - pada 12/4/2024 - jumlah : 104 hits
An institutional reforms advocacy group has urged Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail to bring the citizenship amendment bill back to the drawing board Project Stability and Accountability for Malaysia said Saifuddin should seize the wi...
High Court Throws Out Han Chiang School Trustee S Land Dispute Case

High Court Throws Out Han Chiang School Trustee S Land Dispute Case

papar berkaitan - pada 9/4/2024 - jumlah : 114 hits
Lim Boon Lin the grandson of the late philanthropist Lim Lean Teng had sued Han Chiang School s managing body over its plan to set up an education city that includes a university GEORGE TOWN The High Court here has struck out a suit by Lim ...
High Court Upholds Bandar Puteri Klang Home Buyers Rm2 3mil Judgment

High Court Upholds Bandar Puteri Klang Home Buyers Rm2 3mil Judgment

papar berkaitan - pada 17/4/2024 - jumlah : 96 hits
The Klang High Court has maintained a judgment requiring developer Malayapine Estates to pay between RM144 775 and RM173 928 in damages to 15 plaintiffs for defective construction of their homes PETALING JAYA A High Court in Klang has uphel...
15 Coquette Garland Designs That Burst With Springtime Joy

15 Coquette Garland Designs That Burst With Springtime Joy

papar berkaitan - pada 7/4/2024 - jumlah : 95 hits
Spring whispers promises of renewal and what better way to celebrate than with whimsical decorations that burst with joy Enter the world of coquette garlands where delicate beauty meets playful charm Imagine strings adorned with The post ap...
Dive Into Adventure This School Holiday At The Heart Of Johor Bahru

Traders Still Hesitant To Use Local Currencies Despite Benefits

Senarai Biasiswa Lepasan Spm Zakat Bantuan Ipt 2024

Effortless Rewards Samsung Wallet Makes Every Purchase Count On The Affordable Galaxy A15 That Starts From Rm999

Richiamo Coffee Pengganti Zus Terpaksa Beralih Arah

Voices Of Galaxy Meet The Para Sprinter Helping The Next Generation Navigate The Road Ahead

Jagung Mozarella Confirm Tarik

Asia Mobiliti Govt Must Enact Procurement Reforms



5 Kaedah Menulis Mesej Yang Sebenarnya Annoying Untuk Dibaca

Biodata Dan Umur Pelakon Muntazar Ghufran Adik Firdaus Ghufran Yang Bertunang Dengan Saidah Kamarudin

Benarkah Kena Hujan Menyebabkan Kita Jatuh Sakit

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Khilaf Yang Tertulis Slot Samarinda TV3

5 Projek Filem Aneh Hasil Karya Pengarah Filem Terkenal Hollywood


7 New Android Features To Elevate Your Everyday

Brix Klia By Pinetree Kicks Off Artist In Residence Program

Google I O 2024 Diwarnai Pengumuman Beragam Produk Baru

Profil Fahri Amhar Penulis Kronologi Sejarah Palestina

Suplemen Untuk Slipped Disc

Kt043 Mak Abah Menunaikan Haji Ke 2