Is Harapan Falling Into Umno S Trap Again


Perak has a history of being vulnerable to outside excursions. From the 16th century, its rich tin deposits incurred invasions from Acehnese and the Dutch. This created deep animosity between the sultans and the tradespeople, but the invaders were always willing to compromise because the profits were irresistible.
In 2009, the Perak state government power-tussle unleashed one of the most memorable constitutional crises in recent memory. Back then, party-hopping was unusual and unexpected. The Sultan of Perak refused the then-menteri besar’s request for a dissolution of the State Assembly, and when the state assemblypersons were barred from entering the state building, they held the session under a tree – the Democracy tree. The upshot of affirming that the sultan could determine the loss of confidence using “extraneous sources” have ripple effects today.
Earlier this year, the Perak state government was also single-handedly changed by the now-ousted menteri besar Ahmad Faizal Azumu – extending the effects of the federal coup led by the current Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin in February.
Umno's show of strength to Bersatu
The latest coup has its complexities. The undisputed fact is that Umno wants a change in the menteri besar, as they were not satisfied with Faizal’s performance. The culminating event being his appointment of a political secretary without prior consultation with Umno. Thus, they moved an emergency motion to declare that Faizal has lost the confidence of the assembly.
Since then, there have been numerous accounts and suggestions on what this event has symbolised and where it could go.
One popular account was that this was a betrayal by Umno against Bersatu. Its Johor assemblyperson Osman Sapian, also a former menteri besar of Johor, has suggested that his party can now take revenge on Umno’s menteri besar in Johor, Hasni Mohammad.

Osman Sapian
It is plausible that Bersatu leaders are dissatisfied with Umno’s showing of strength – a real insecurity that Bersatu has to live with. Though Bersatu holds the most significant political largesse at the federal level, it remains vulnerable to Umno at every turn due to the latter’s elder statesmen stature.
Umno’s plan was straightforward. It wants to replace Bersatu MB Faizal, with its own. The only challenge is that it still requires the support of Bersatu to retain the old government coalition of Perikatan Nasional. But of course, it is harder to obtain support from the party they have just betrayed. A series of retaliations ensued.
That is why Umno is experimenting on a partnership with Harapan.
There are only two outcomes, and my argument is that both outcomes are disadvantageous to Harapan.
First outcome: Umno does not eventually form a government with Harapan
The first outcome is more likely of the two. When most people hear about Umno’s
suggestion to pair up with Harapan parties, the reaction is one of shock and dismay. The more observant analysts surmise that Umno was simply using Harapan as bait to strengthen their bargaining position with Bersatu and PAS.

In other words, by showing that Umno could partner with Harapan – a greater possibility than Bersatu and PAS pairing with Harapan at this juncture – Bersatu and PAS would become more desperate and run back to Umno. The similar scenario was seen at the federal level, where Najib Razak-Zahid Hamidi’s Umno showed that it was open to working with Anwar as prime minister. And this subsequently compelled Muhyiddin to make more concessions to Umno’s demands.
This strategy is effective for two reasons. One, Umno is more flexible in partnerships than Bersatu and PAS are. While all parties have huge dissonance with Harapan’s stated principles, Bersatu and PAS have greater animosity and incoherence with the personalities of Harapan than Umno. It is also true that it would be far more costly for Bersatu and PAS to be sent back to the opposition than for Umno to form a government with Harapan.
Two, Harapan’s leaders would most likely jump on the opportunity of being back to power. The traditional assumption is that any leader who has tasted the sweet chorus of power would dream of getting their fix again – like an addiction. Almost without an interlude, Harapan leaders of Perak jumped on even a slither of this opportunity. Umno president Zahid Hamidi simply said that he would consider working with any party, and Harapan leaders immediately said yes.
In the event Umno does not form a government with Harapan, it would have already revealed Harapan leaders’ hunger for power – not dissimilar to that of Perikatan Nasional. The proclamation that this effort was to prevent government instability or to create a multiracial government rings hollow once we truly appreciate a politician’s obsession with power.
Second outcome: Umno eventually forms government with Harapan
Even under the less-likely outcome of Umno taking the risk of forming the Perak government with Harapan, it would still be disadvantageous to Harapan.
If Umno chooses this option, it would be less out of desperation and more out of strategy. Umno’s current plan is to stay at Bersatu’s toes so that they could maximally extract concessions from Bersatu to the point of destroying them. Forming a government with their sworn enemy at the state level would be useful to show Muhyiddin that Umno could leave anytime, and Bersatu is at Umno’s mercy.

Harapan would suffer in at least two ways. One, Harapan would suffer in the process of working with Umno at the state level. By revealing its intention of wanting to return to power, Harapan has far lesser bargaining strength with Umno now. In the past, Harapan has also shown greater levels of submissions and concessions when they were in power. This is evident when they worked with the veteran Dr Mahathir Mohamad at the federal level.
Any Harapan leader who is fixated on getting the exco position that will secure a higher salary, allowances and perks is less likely to do anything to jeopardise his/her position again. The expected behaviour is submission.
The second way that Harapan will suffer is electorally. Although Umno may seem open to partnering with Harapan to form the state government, this relationship is unlikely to extend to the general election. Umno understands that it is the party that everyone wants to win the election, but getting into a war with DAP as an ally would seem too far a stretch for its supporters.
Of all methods of justifications, the one that will work the best is that DAP is merely a tool for Umno to ride out the wave; and in terms of policies, Umno will always take charge. This would appear more palatable with its voters. Chances are, the voters would buy into this because Umno does command a greater seat number than DAP and it was Umno that opened the door for DAP to enter.
In any case, partnership with a party that is intent on dumping you at the end of the road hardly seems like a trusting partnership.
More importantly, Harapan is likely to suffer more electorally than Umno. A team of DAP-Umno is not a dream team – it is political hypocrisy. The closest thing to sworn enemies in politics is found in these two parties. The modern adage of “one plus one does not equal two” applies similarly here. This means that a Umno-DAP partnership does not necessarily translate to winning all Malay and non-Malay votes because the partnership would drive out supporters who could not stand the partnership of sworn enemies.
And in this partnership, my hunch is that Harapan would suffer more compared to Umno, albeit Umno’s casualty numbers would not be small.
Is Perak worth this high-risk activity? We mustn’t forget, the state was always vulnerable to outside excursions; this time, the wrath of its people.

JAMES CHAI is a legal consultant and researcher working for Invoke, among others. He also blogs at You may reach him at [email protected] - Mkini

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Alliance With Umno A Betrayal Frustrates Harapan Supporters Pkr Rep

Alliance With Umno A Betrayal Frustrates Harapan Supporters Pkr Rep

papar berkaitan - pada 7/12/2020 - jumlah : 88 hits
An alliance between DAP PKR and Umno to form a new Perak government will frustrate Pakatan Harapan supporters said PKR s Machap Jaya assemblyperson Ginie Lim Perplexed by the proposal of the alliance she stressed that the cooperation is not...
Umno Dan Pas Yang Meletakan Harapan Dan Kemudian Mengkhianati

Umno Dan Pas Yang Meletakan Harapan Dan Kemudian Mengkhianati

papar berkaitan - pada 5/12/2020 - jumlah : 179 hits
Terkini UMNO sedang bergelut dan panik apabila tindakan UMNO Perak disokong DAP mendapat tentangan dan belasahan ahli UMNO dan rakyat UMNO dianggap pengkhianat Bukanlah pelik mereka boleh duduk semeja dengan Muhyiddin Sekarang mereka sedang...
Should Umno And Harapan Form Coalition In Perak

Should Umno And Harapan Form Coalition In Perak

papar berkaitan - pada 7/12/2020 - jumlah : 123 hits
What are the options before Umno and Pakatan Harapan The decision that must be made before Wednesday may have far reaching implications beyond Perak Here are the three options Option 1 Umno Bersatu PAS coalitionThis would be the best outcom...
Bagi Pencarum Keluar Rm10 000 Tanpa Syarat Kata Presiden Umno Kepada Kwsp

Bagi Pencarum Keluar Rm10 000 Tanpa Syarat Kata Presiden Umno Kepada Kwsp

papar berkaitan - pada 5/12/2020 - jumlah : 98 hits
December 4 2020 Presiden Umno Ahmad Zahid Hamidi berkata Ahli Parlimen Barisan Nasional sejak awal berpendirian tegas memperjuangankan isu tuntutan pengeluaran wang Akaun 1 KWSP yang dibangkitkan rakyat KUALA LUMPUR Presiden Umno Ahmad Zahi...
Umno Buat Hal Lagi Pecat Mb Perak Apa Korang Nak Sebenarnya

Umno Buat Hal Lagi Pecat Mb Perak Apa Korang Nak Sebenarnya

papar berkaitan - pada 5/12/2020 - jumlah : 148 hits
Haritu korang duk suruh anwar sabar tunggu PRU biar rakyat tentukan Kemudian korang buat kecoh di sabah Pie naik angin dibubarnya dun Melukuk habis satu semenanjung kena serang covid19 Majoriti kerusi sabah tetap warisan Walaupun tak dapat ...
Umno Mula Rasa Tersepit Kerajaan Baru Perak Masih Teka Teki

Umno Mula Rasa Tersepit Kerajaan Baru Perak Masih Teka Teki

papar berkaitan - pada 5/12/2020 - jumlah : 88 hits
Jatuhnya Ahmad Faizal Azumu atau Peja sebagai Menteri Besar Perak berikutan gagal dalam undi percaya di Dun Perak semalam adalah agenda yang memang dirancang oleh UMNO Secara mudahnya tindakan itu ialah kerana UMNO dengan jumlah kerusi terb...
Penganalisis Beri 3 Sebab Pas Lebih Selesa Dengan Ppbm Berbanding Umno

Penganalisis Beri 3 Sebab Pas Lebih Selesa Dengan Ppbm Berbanding Umno

papar berkaitan - pada 5/12/2020 - jumlah : 309 hits
December 5 2020 Penganalisis berkata PAS hanya mahu kekal sebagai sebahagian daripada kerajaan PETALING JAYA Walaupun ia bermula dengan kerjasama dengan Umno dalam Muakafat Nasional PAS dilihat lebih selesa bekerja dalam Perikatan Nasional ...
Aziz Bari Tidak Tolak Kemungkinan Gabungan Kerjasama Antara Dap Dan Umno

Aziz Bari Tidak Tolak Kemungkinan Gabungan Kerjasama Antara Dap Dan Umno

papar berkaitan - pada 5/12/2020 - jumlah : 147 hits
KUALA LUMPUR Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri Tebing Tinggi Dr Abdul Aziz Bari tidak menolak kemungkinan gabungan kerjasama diantara parti politik di negeri Perak boleh berlaku seperti sebelum ini Menurut beliau dalam gelanggang politik tiada apa...
Gu Hyesun Kongsi Sudah Maafkan Bekas Suami Minta Orang Ramai Maafkan Juga Kesilapan Ahn Jaehyun

Minister Businesses Should Continue During Mco To Prevent Job Losses

6 Brand Makanan Indonesia Yang Sering Dikira Dari Luar Negeri Bukti Kalau Kita Bisa Bersaing

Emco For 3 Villages In Pasir Mas Kelantan From May 9 22

Lirik Senandung Hari Raya Untukmu 2021 Todak Music All Stars

Please End The Sabah College Nightmare Begs Mtuc

Pru 14 Akhirnya Bn Tumbang Di Johor Khalid Nordin Tewas Di Pasir Gudang

Si Kecil Sudah Tidak Perlukan Tidur Siang Mama Kenal Pasti 6 Tanda Ini

Chrislam Agama Baru Yang Menyatukan Ajaran Kristian dan Islam

Kisah Raja Ponteng Kerja Itali 15 Tahun Ponteng Tapi Gaji Jalan

Maxis Tawarkan Subsidi Sehingga RM300 60GB Internet Prihatin Sebulan Menerusi Kempen KauBoleh

5 Faedah Utama Beli Belah Dalam Talian Yang Jarang Diperkatakan

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Cukup Derita Itu Slot Samarinda TV3

Malam 27 Likur

Oppo K9 5g Launches Comes With Snapdragon 768g

Bank Rakyat Tampilkan Filem Pendek Raya Dari Mamat Khalid

Jarak Yang Tepat Untuk Qasar

Melayu Luar Bandar Pilih Perikatan Nasional Survey

Musafir Ke