Guest Editorial Entrenched Malay Elites Are The Problem



Salleh Kamil
In the evolving tapestry of Malay society, the old two-class system—with rulers at the top and peasants at the bottom—has been reshaped by the rise of a vibrant middle class. Yet, class divisions remain, deeply woven into the social fabric. Status consciousness prevails, with one’s position either ascribed by birth, as seen in royalty and nobility, or achieved through social mobility.
Nevertheless despite the broad emergence of a bigger Malay middle class, Malay society continues to be divided along class lines. Hence they are very status conscious.
Royalty and nobility are marked by titles like Tuanku, Tengku, and Raja. In contrast, members of the public or the commoner may obtain social status mainly through education or their economic achievements. Depending on the level of these achievements they will either form the elite or middle class of Malay society. Public service awards are also conferred by either the Federal or State Government to people who have contributed to society through charitable or social services. These awards include the conferment of honorific titles such as Datuk, Dato’, Dato’ Seri, Tan Sri or Tun from the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong (the King) or from the Sultans. These titles would usually raise the social status of those conferred in their particular community and contribute to a further class stratification within the elite and middle class. Due to the high respect given to people with honorific titles, there have been allegations that some wealthy people make monetary contributions to obtain these titles for themselves. At the lowest level of the Malay social hierarchy is the “poor” who would include menial workers, labourers and beggars.
In essence, a person’s status in Malay society is either determined through “ascribed status” as in the case of royalty and the nobility classes which form the upper segment of the society or through “social mobility”.
The essence of status consciousness and the culture of social inequality within the Malay society and how the society is divided along class lines is best illustrated by many of P.Ramlee’s films such as “Penarik Beca” or the Trishaw Man, “Antara Dua Darjat” or Between Two Social Classes and ‘Ibu Mertuaku” or My Mother-in-law. In the first and the third films the social status portrayed is that of economic superiority, whereas in the second film the status portrayed is that of the privileged aristocratic class. The plot of the films revolves around the forbidden love affairs between the rich and the poor (the first and third films) and between the aristocratic and the commoner (the second film). It is also noteworthy from the point of view of Malay society that in all of the three films, the rich were associated with negative values such as arrogance, selfishness, spendthrift and callousness. In contrast the poor or the commoner is imbued with positive values such as kind-heartedness, honesty, generosity and inevitably sympathy. The rich were also associated with western culture whereas the poor with the traditional.
For those not familiar with contemporary Malay Culture, P.Ramlee was a famous Malay film director, actor, singer and songwriter. Since his demise in 1973, many of his films remain popular.
The Malay cultural concept of “malu,” or shyness, plays a crucial role in social interactions, discouraging open expression and creating hesitancy in social mobility. This introspective nature, seen by some as a barrier to progress, often results in passivity and a reluctance to embrace new ventures or quick actions.
Understanding these cultural nuances offers insight into the complexities of Malay society, where status and humility intricately shape personal and collective identities.
Contemporary Malaysia
All of this becomes glaringly clear when one takes a look at the current state of Malaysian Intellectual Frontier. Malaysia’s progressive Ethnic Chinese community are in the leadership role of the Malaysian Economic Association (MEA). The Malaysian Chinese Chambers of Commerce have their own Think Tank, the Socioeconomic Research Centre (SERC). Meanwhile Universiti Turku Abdul Rahman (UTAR) set up by a Malaysian Chinese Political Party have developed a formidable intellectual prowess through their collaboration with The Institute of Strategic Analysis and Policy Research (INSAP).
They are well organised and act in unison. Meanwhile the Ethnic Malays are in such state of disarray with no clear direction. In recent years, 2 of Malaysia’s premier Think Tanks, have entered a state of limbo.
Long overstaying their welcome, Tan Sri Datuk Salimun Mahbubani & his inner circle add little value to any organisation while they use the Malay Political Apparatus to ensure their continuous re-appointment.
As such constant non-performance are among the hallmark signs to look out for.
At the same time Tan Sri Datuk Salimun & his associates have set up the anachronistic Institut Masa Depan Malaysia (Institut MASA), whose primary goal is to preserve Malay superiority, preferring this goal above that of Islamic Universalism.
At best Salimun and Associates are like village gangsters (gangster kampung). You can’t take the village out of Salimun and associates, though they may not be running around in sarongs but they continue to organise Durian Festivals in ThinkTanks!
It’s disheartening to see that those who rise through the Malay social hierarchy often forget their origins. These commoners, who attain high status, sometimes become incredibly arrogant and belligerent. They may hinder others who aspire to achieve success, often acting as obstacles rather than mentors. This behavior contrasts sharply with the expectations of humility and community support that are valued in Malay culture. This shift in behavior underscores a broader societal concern about maintaining cultural values amidst personal advancement.
Thankfully, Malay royalty and nobility remain respectable and are not petty. They remain as the pillars of our society.
*Salleh Kamil is an observer of Southeast Asian Affairs.*
The post Guest Editorial: Entrenched Malay Elites Are The Problem appeared first on Malaysia Today.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

https://www.malaysia-today.net/2024/07/30/guest-editorial-entrenched-malay-elites-are-the-problem/

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
There Are Still Some Amazing Music Festivals Left For 2024 Even Though It S Already Halfway Through The Year

There Are Still Some Amazing Music Festivals Left For 2024 Even Though It S Already Halfway Through The Year

papar berkaitan - pada 25/7/2024 - jumlah : 325 hits
Are you ready to groove dance and immerse yourself in the electrifying atmosphere of Malaysia s top music festivals this year These festivals offer an incredible lineup of local and international artists across diverse genres Whether you re...
What Are The Chances That Malaysia Will Go The Same Way As Bangladesh And Kenya

What Are The Chances That Malaysia Will Go The Same Way As Bangladesh And Kenya

papar berkaitan - pada 27/7/2024 - jumlah : 377 hits
The government and leaders of a nation tend to presume that just because people have taken a lot of abuse while only reacting a little in the past they can continue to heap upon the same amount of abuse on the people and expect people to re...
Employer Reluctance On Training The Crux Of Hrd Corp Problem

Employer Reluctance On Training The Crux Of Hrd Corp Problem

papar berkaitan - pada 27/7/2024 - jumlah : 239 hits
From Walter SandosamFollowing the recent HRD Corp furore with possibly corruption having reared its ugly head one reads of some employers calling for levies to be stopped at least temporarily until matters are sorted out On the other extrem...
Surgeries Around The Clock In Serdang After Heart Centre Problem

Surgeries Around The Clock In Serdang After Heart Centre Problem

papar berkaitan - pada 28/7/2024 - jumlah : 234 hits
A contractor is looking into the cause of the electrical problems at Sultan Idris Shah Hospital s heart centre said Selangor director of health Dr Ummi Kalthom Shamsudin PETALING JAYA Two operating theatres at Serdang hospital are running a...
The Non Proliferation Problem

The Non Proliferation Problem

papar berkaitan - pada 20/7/2024 - jumlah : 390 hits
Avril Haines the US director of National Intelligence recently warned that Russia s need for support in the context of Ukraine has forced it to grant some long sought concessions to China North Korea and Iran with the potential to undermine...
Are You Familiar With The Gen Z Thumbs Up Emoji Controversy

Are You Familiar With The Gen Z Thumbs Up Emoji Controversy

papar berkaitan - pada 28/7/2024 - jumlah : 415 hits
In the ever evolving world of digital communication even the most innocent seeming emojis can spark debate The latest emoji to find itself in the spotlight The humble thumbs up The thumbs up emoji once a universal symbol of approval has fou...
Best Shapewear Swimsuits Are You Ready For The Beach Party

Best Shapewear Swimsuits Are You Ready For The Beach Party

papar berkaitan - pada 23/7/2024 - jumlah : 323 hits
Sunny days arrive requiring the use of comfortable and cool clothes Summer clothes can be adapted to different women s styles You can create a relaxed look with a shapewear swimsuit for any beach party Whether for a day or night event you c...
Malay Unity Is In The Hands Of The Grassroot Not The Leadership

Malay Unity Is In The Hands Of The Grassroot Not The Leadership

papar berkaitan - pada 26/7/2024 - jumlah : 240 hits
Even if they manage to suppress their ego and work together for a while their cooperation will not last long In 17 months or 15 months their suppressed ego will somehow or other find a way to unleash itself and cause double the havoc that i...
15 Reasons Why The Rich Are Getting Richer 2024

15 Reasons Why The Rich Are Getting Richer 2024

papar berkaitan - pada 28/7/2024 - jumlah : 353 hits
15 Reasons Why The Rich Are Getting Richer Follow Follow Follow Subscribe
Cheaper Riskier More Meaningful Why Malaysians Send Their Korban Abroad For Aidiladha

Lima Mangsa Kemalangan Maut Jerantut Feri Telah Dikenalpasti Buat Pusingan U Secara Mengejut Jadi Punca

Scene Dalam Cerita Suzanna Berlaku Secara Real

Malaysians Flock To Thailand For Hari Raya Aidiladha Getaway

Kuah Kacang Istimewa Di Bermondsey

Reagan Airport Is Pausing Flights For Trump S Military Parade What Will It Mean For Travelers

English Uasa Year 3

12 Pernikahan Artis Malaysia Bertemakan Outdoor


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


5 Jenis Pelaburan Patuh Syariah Paling Menguntungkan Di Malaysia

Tak Sanggup Dengar Jeritan Dua Beradik Didera Ibu Amp Teman Lelaki Jiran Prihatin Buat Laporan

Disenarai Hitam Fahmi Reza Dakwa Dihalang Ke Luar Negara Mahu Penjelasan Bukit Aman

Wanita Jumpa Wang Lebih Rm1 Juta Dalam Kotak Di Tempat Buang Sampah

Comment On Plate Gold Tak Sepanas Plate Ff By Tempahan Plate Fg Putrajaya Dibuka 2025 Adzril

Comment On Sewa Motor Di Kota Kinabalu Sabah 3 Jenis Motor By Victor Stanley Joseph