Free Breakfast Programme Targeting Social Status And Social Stigma




As technology progresses with information becoming richer and more accessible, it becomes easier and easier to do targeted policy
Governments, especially those with conservative economic leanings compromising with democratic pressures, love targeting because in theory, it is cheaper and it avoids wastage. In fact, going back to basic microeconomics, it might even eliminate deadweight loss. I also love targeting, up to a point. Just because we are able to do targeted policy does not mean we should do it. There are other considerations to be taken into account
Targeting can create social stigma and that can be damaging in other ways. It does so through signaling, which means it lets other people know that a person is being targeted for some policy. This is something policymakers need to be mindful of, beyond the dollars and cents

In a society where social status matters, assistance could lower a person's social status
This is why a government cash assistance programme via automatic bank transfer is good. It keeps transactions private, and therefore gives no signaling to other people. So, it has minimal or no effect on social status
But not all assistance policy can be private. Many do necessarily give out signaling affecting social status. The Free Breakfast Programme (FBP) for students to be introduced by the Ministry of Education in 2020 is one such 'un-private' assistance policy
As a result, a programme like FBP, with its current mechanism, cannot be targeted. This is especially so when it comes to kids who may take target signaling wrongly, leading to bullying and social estrangement. Giving free breakfast for certain groups, which are the neediest, send signals to better-off students that the beneficiaries are of a certain social class
Schools at the elementary level are grounds for inculcating values. One of the values we should inculcate is egalitarianism. This makes signaling something to be thought of in designing policy relevant to the education system
Our country is already divided in so many dimensions. We probably do not want to impress on the younglings of social divisions through yet another dimension. Targeting at this cost is not worth it
In our specific FBP case, a blanket policy is better than a targeted policy. It muzzles the signalling, and fights the creation of social stigma that is the seed for future division in our society
HAFIZ NOOR SHAMS is an economist currently working in the public sector. - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth/~3/mvCIzHDoN-g/free-breakfast-programme-targeting.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
10 Things You Need To Know About The Free Breakfast Programme

10 Things You Need To Know About The Free Breakfast Programme

papar berkaitan - pada 28/8/2019 - jumlah : 220 hits
Yesterday the Ministry of Education Malaysia announced that starting January 2020 free breakfast will be available for all children in primary school all over the country The Free Breakfast Programme is called the Programme Sarapan Percuma ...
Food For Thought On Free School Breakfast

Food For Thought On Free School Breakfast

papar berkaitan - pada 28/8/2019 - jumlah : 100 hits
I refer to the education ministry s programme to provide free breakfast to all primary school children beginning next January This is a good programme and should be supported However there are a number of points that the ministry must take ...
Wee Questions Value Of Free Breakfast In Schools Plan

Wee Questions Value Of Free Breakfast In Schools Plan

papar berkaitan - pada 28/8/2019 - jumlah : 70 hits
MCA president Wee Ka Siong has challenged the wisdom of the planned introduction of free breakfast for children in primary schools nationwide Wee said based on his calculations the government would spend RM1 6 billion to feed some 2 7 milli...
Parents Group Warns Of Bumps In Free Breakfast Plan

Parents Group Warns Of Bumps In Free Breakfast Plan

papar berkaitan - pada 28/8/2019 - jumlah : 77 hits
Some 2 7 million students are expected to benefit from the government s free breakfast programme PETALING JAYA The Melaka Action Group for Parents has questioned the wisdom of serving free breakfast to every child in primary school saying i...
5 Orang Yang Menyandang Status Miliuner Di Usia Tua

5 Orang Yang Menyandang Status Miliuner Di Usia Tua

papar berkaitan - pada 29/8/2019 - jumlah : 63 hits
Menjadi kaya tentu merupakan cita cita setiap manusia Jika beruntung mereka bisa menyandang status orang terkaya di usia muda Namun tak semua orang punya kesempatan untuk bisa kaya raya di usia matang Ada yang harus menunggu hingga dirinya ...
Cara Kepoin Status Mantan Tanpa Ketahuan Via Whatsapp

Cara Kepoin Status Mantan Tanpa Ketahuan Via Whatsapp

papar berkaitan - pada 30/8/2019 - jumlah : 182 hits
Mau kepoin status mantan tanpa ketahuan Caranya gimana Ya tidak bisa dipungkiri setiap orang pasti suka kepo dengan status mantan termasuk aku hahaha Guys coba deh ingat kembali kapan terakhir kamu kepoin status mantan via Whatsapp Alasan k...
Cara Trace Tracking Number Dan Maksud Disebalik 12 Status Poslaju Parcel Hub

Cara Trace Tracking Number Dan Maksud Disebalik 12 Status Poslaju Parcel Hub

papar berkaitan - pada 29/8/2019 - jumlah : 433 hits
Cara Trace Tracking Number Dan Maksud Disebalik 12 Status Poslaju Parcel Hub Pos Laju is the leading courier company in Malaysia okay bab ini memang tak boleh dinafikan kerana Pos Malaysia sememangnya antara pihak pengeposan terawal di Mala...
Ditegur Pakai Tudung Tapi Muatnaik Status Lu Cah Shaheizy Sam Akhirnya Buka Mulut Tentang Isterinya

Ditegur Pakai Tudung Tapi Muatnaik Status Lu Cah Shaheizy Sam Akhirnya Buka Mulut Tentang Isterinya

papar berkaitan - pada 28/8/2019 - jumlah : 108 hits
Beberapa bulan lalu sebuah perkongsian gambar pelakon cantik Syatilla Melvin di Instagram beliau telah mendapat maklum balas neg4tif di kalangan netizen Ditegur Pakai Tudung Tapi Muatnaik Status Lu cah Shaheizy Sam Akhirnya Buka Mulut Tenta...
Supiyandi Bunuh Istri Karena Kesal Pasang Status Janda Di Facebook

Supiyandi Bunuh Istri Karena Kesal Pasang Status Janda Di Facebook

papar berkaitan - pada 30/8/2019 - jumlah : 73 hits
Selain cemburu S membunuh istrinya karena kesal istrinya memasang status janda pada akun Facebook Bahkan istrinya pun memblokir akun Facebook milik tersangka
Mungkinkah Calon Bebas Akan Hilang Wang Pertaruhan Prk Slim

King Of Bahrain Arrives In Dubai With Robot Bodyguard

A Few Small Decorating Ideas For Small Bedrooms

15 Imaginative Diy Beads Projects You Will Love Crafting

Kenapa Selalu Ada Ulser Di Mulut

Resipi Puding Roti Tawar Cantik Mudah Buat Sedap

Bukan Bilis Lagi Yang Ditangkap Kali Ni Pengarah Penguatkuasa Mbsa Pula Ditahan Sprm

Dulu Kini Dan Selamanya Bangsa Dap Adalah Musuh Kita



5 Pengurus Bola Sepak Terkenal Tak Pernah Main Tahap Pro

Bagaimana TikToker Menjana Pendapatan

Asal Usul Nama Matawang Negara Asia

Biodata Malek Mccrone Pelakon Drama Kebaya Kasut Kanvas

5 Kereta Keluaran Malaysia Yang Gagal Teruk di Pasaran Tempatan


Baby Carrie Produk Baru Yang Diformulasi Dengan 100 Bahan Organik Khas Untuk Bayi

Cara Mencegah Anak Anda Daripada Pembesaran Terbantut

Taman Rimba Bukit Mertajam Bukit Cherok Tokun

Suami Tega Jual Istri Rp 700 000 Sekali Kencan Tawarkan Kamar Kos Jadi Tempat Prostitusi

Warga Tak Mau Pinjamkan Cangkul Petugas Kubur Jenazah Covid 19 Dengan Tangan

Pengakuan Pengemudi Ojol Setelah Disuntik Vaksin Covid 19 Ngantuk Lapar Dan Ada Pantangannya