What Is The Real Reason For The Ltte Arrests



If the police do indeed have extremely credible and compelling evidence as they claim, why were these individuals detained under Sosma and not under existing laws such as the Penal Code? After all, there are more than enough laws under which you can prosecute people for planning violent terrorist acts – assuming the police do indeed have the credible evidence they say they do.
Nathaniel Tan, The Star
PERHAPS the introductory caveat of this article should be: objectively speaking, we must be open to the possibility that the statements by some of the police could be absolutely true.
It could be true that there are people in Malaysia who are closely aligned to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) and who have been planning to execute extremely violent terrorist attacks.
In the spirit of objectivity and openness, we must admit this possibility.
Now that we have done so, however, let us – as non-speculatively as possible – try to examine some of the context surrounding this controversy and its contingent probabilities.
The headline-grabber of course were two DAP elected representatives, Seremban Jaya assemblyman P. Gunasekaran and Gadek assemblyman G. Saminathan.
Even without these two arrests, a crackdown on alleged LTTE-related terrorism would still raise eyebrows.
The chief reason for this of course is that the Sri Lankan civil war involving the LTTE, also known as the Tamil Tigers, ended no less than 10 years ago.
Not one, two or five years ago; 10 years ago!
The obvious questions that arise are these: What would an overseas LTTE-related attack be trying to achieve then? Could it possibly have any bearing to the essentially abandoned endeavour to create an independent Tamil state in Sri Lanka?
A cursory Google search suggests that terrorist attacks outside Sri Lanka related to the LTTE are rare events – one would imagine especially so in the last decade.
None of this should be reason to underestimate the emotive connection many Tamils around the world have to the LTTE.
I’m sure even 10 years on, it is an emotional hot-button issue for many people – perhaps one that even could spur a few individuals into doing something stupid.
Over a year ago, I wrote elsewhere about how conflicts in places like Sri Lanka and Palestine served as “proxy wars”, and how this has affected inter-communal relations here in Malaysia.
All that said, the available evidence suggests that here and now in Malaysia, there is no logical impetus or motivation for any group to be planning some sort of violent terrorist act in support of an organisation that has been defunct for a decade, in a country thousands of kilometres away.
Simply put, what would it achieve?
Supporting the LTTE has likely long been popular among local Tamils, but perpetrating an act of violence in their name? That would only make you a “hero” to a negligibly small number of people here. In the eyes of most Malaysians, Tamil or otherwise, “evil” is what it would make you.
I’m certain most people – certainly people who want to win elections – are aware of this.
Speaking of evidence, we should perhaps take a critical eye to the claim by the police that they have massive evidence to support these arrests, a claim the Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad himself has (worrisomely) said he found “satisfactory”.
This claim raises one pivotal contradiction: If there is so much overwhelming evidence, why were these individuals detained under Sosma?
Detention without trial has a long history in Malaysia. We all know of the Internal Security Act (ISA), which Dr Mahathir famously used against his political opponents (now turned political allies). There is also the Emergency Ordinance and the Dangerous Drugs Act.
All of these laws are essentially designed to circumvent the normal legal process, which has reasonably stringent requirements surrounding the detention of individuals.
In essence, under Malaysia’s legal system, credible and compelling evidence that holds up in a court of law is required to detain an individual for any significant period of time.
Laws like the ISA circumvented this requirement, and basically gave power to the authorities to arrest whoever they want, for however long they want, with no judicial review.
This led some to call the ISA the “Ikut Suka Aku” (do whatever I want) law, because it literally gave the government absolute power to lock anyone up, for any “reason” it deemed fit.
The “justification” was that sometimes it was necessary to lock people up, even when there was not enough credible evidence.
Civil society and political parties campaigned long and hard against the ISA, and with good reason. Achieving this goal was bittersweet – when the ISA was finally repealed, it was replaced with Sosma, which still allowed for detention without trial, ostensibly as relates to terrorism and “national security” (vaguely defined, as always).
So the contradiction is this: if the police do indeed have extremely credible and compelling evidence as they claim, why were these individuals detained under Sosma and not under existing laws such as the Penal Code?
After all, there are more than enough laws under which you can prosecute people for planning violent terrorist acts – assuming the police do indeed have the credible evidence they say they do.
This entire episode is indeed perplexing if viewed from the lens of the dormancy of the LTTE, and the use of Sosma despite having “overwhelming credible evidence”.
It is less perplexing if viewed in the context of how oppressive laws have historically been used in Malaysia to detain people without trial.
For a long time, the ISA was marketed openly by some politicians as a “tool of Malay power” – a way to come down hard on non-Malays who acted “impertinently”.
As issues surrounding race relations are once again heating up, one cannot help but wonder whether this is the backdrop against which some rather dubious arrests are being made.
Is this the powers-that-be trying to flex their muscles (especially ahead of the Tanjung Piai by-election), and demonstrate that they are still a “strong” government which looks out for certain ethnic interests at the expense of others?
Is this perhaps an attempt to force even further polarisation of race relations?
The latter seems particularly likely if we examine the fallout from these arrests. Almost instantly on cue, we see the political fallout being organised along the same old ethnic fault lines that dominated “Old Malaysia”. The same old narratives (which can sometimes be summarised as: DAP is the devil!) from decades past are fast being recreated.
Perhaps this is all part of the larger reactionary response towards the changes brought about in the wake of the 14th General Election (GE14). Perhaps it is made possible because the government today has failed to provide the new narrative necessary to make a genuinely “New Malaysia”.
Once again, if the police do eventually (sooner rather than later) provide compelling, credible, and ultimately convincing evidence that the people they arrested were indeed plotting violent terrorism in the name of the LTTE or anyone else for that matter, then they should get a well deserved pat on the back (though not for using Sosma).
Until such a time however, given the available facts, I think many a Malaysian can be forgiven for remaining somewhat sceptical.
NATHANIEL TAN is a communications consultant specialising in identifying the right goals, and using the right tools for the right job. He can be reached at [email protected] The writer’s views are his own.
 


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

https://www.malaysia-today.net/2019/10/15/what-is-the-real-reason-for-the-ltte-arrests/

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
What S Next For The Organisers Of The Malay Dignity Congress

What S Next For The Organisers Of The Malay Dignity Congress

papar berkaitan - pada 9/10/2019 - jumlah : 75 hits
Zainal Epi MMOThat the organiser of recently concluded Kongres Maruah Melayu known in English as the Malay Dignity Congress brought the disparate Malay based parties together to talk on a common platform is an achievement Even if they faile...
Tamil Nadu Politician Made Many Trips To Malaysia To Revive The Ltte

Tamil Nadu Politician Made Many Trips To Malaysia To Revive The Ltte

papar berkaitan - pada 16/10/2019 - jumlah : 75 hits
It is learnt that Seeman has made trips to Malaysia and held several meetings with local politicians to gather support in a bid to revive the LTTE The spotlight has shifted to a politician in Tamil Nadu who has been in close contact with se...
Ltte Arrests Mic Chief Alarmed Asks If Sympathy Is Terrorism

Ltte Arrests Mic Chief Alarmed Asks If Sympathy Is Terrorism

papar berkaitan - pada 13/10/2019 - jumlah : 63 hits
MIC president SA Vigneswaran has expressed grave concern over the arrests of two DAP assemblyersons over their alleged links to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam Vigneswaran said the LTTE was formed in Sri Lanka in response to the killin...
Children S Commissioner Tells Ag Tommy Thomas To Explain Reason For Dismissing Charges

Children S Commissioner Tells Ag Tommy Thomas To Explain Reason For Dismissing Charges

papar berkaitan - pada 20/10/2019 - jumlah : 73 hits
Children s Commssioner urged AG to explain dismissing sexual assault at tahfiz Datuk Noor Aziah Mohd Awal from the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia reminded the AGC in a statement that the incident was of great public interest and called...
The Reason Malays Are Now More Racist

The Reason Malays Are Now More Racist

papar berkaitan - pada 10/10/2019 - jumlah : 97 hits
But there are limits And once you hit the limit it breaks And you have already breached the limit of Malay tolerance So expect only one direction from now on down And use me as the yardstick if you wish If someone like me can get fed up the...
The Hishammuddin Poser How Real Was It

The Hishammuddin Poser How Real Was It

papar berkaitan - pada 21/10/2019 - jumlah : 62 hits
A Kadir Jasin Views expressed herein are entirely mine I am writing in my personal capacity as a blogger It has nothing to do with whatever position I may hold The good old days Dr Mahathir went on to succeed Tun Hussein in 1981IN the moder...
Comment Of The Week France Bans Palm Oil For Biofuel

Comment Of The Week France Bans Palm Oil For Biofuel

papar berkaitan - pada 13/10/2019 - jumlah : 68 hits
Here is a comment from the previous post Anonymous Saturday October 12 2019 12 27 00 PMPunca pemimpin kita akal macam keldai Kambing Zakir lebih penting daripada ekonomi Negara shithole Pakistan lebih penting daripada peneroka kita This is ...
Isis Is Far From Dead Danger Ahead For The World As New Attacks From Islamic Terror Group Loom

Isis Is Far From Dead Danger Ahead For The World As New Attacks From Islamic Terror Group Loom

papar berkaitan - pada 15/10/2019 - jumlah : 106 hits
Middle East is about to plunge into a new crisis again thanks partly to the United States It seems that whenever the U S enters the region a war will start And now that the U S wants to quit it also creates a new war On Sunday President Don...
The Reason Pakatan Harapan Cannot Deliver Its New Malaysia Promise

The Reason Pakatan Harapan Cannot Deliver Its New Malaysia Promise

papar berkaitan - pada 5/10/2019 - jumlah : 62 hits
Yes Pakatan Harapan has lied to us They told us that Malaysians now live in the New Malaysia They say the New Malaysia is different and far better than the old Malaysia They say in the New Malaysia we have more democracy civil liberties fre...
Tamatkan Zaman Bujang Pada Usia 56 Tahun Gambar Nikah Nenek Ini Viral

Proton Mpv Baru Mengantikan Exora

Kes Da I Farhan Bertambah Rumit Aduan Jais Telah Dibuat

Segala Perancangan Azmin Setakat Ini Telah Gagal

Kenapa Dengan Drama Melayu Zaman Sekarang

Bumper Ujang Apo New Stalgia Malaysian Comics

Pdrm Elak Tampal Kertas Hiasan Pada Peti Ais Undang Kebakaran

Woman Claims To Be Samy Vellu S Common Law Wife Wants Maintenance And Access



Siti Nordiana Pengganti Neelofa Di Meletop Ini Reaksinya

Biodata Dan Latar Belakang Izzah Amzan Ratu Gimnas Negara

Adakah Populasi Manusia Akan Berhenti Bertambah Suatu Hari Nanti

5 Negara Pengeluar Minyak Kelapa Sawit Paling Besar Di Dunia

Kisah Pesakit Kanser yang Kudung Berlari Sejauh 5 000 km Terry Fox


Drama Adellea Sofea Lakonan Mira Filzah Dan Ungku Ismail Aziz

Popbela Sebagai Situs Relationship Terbaik

Beginilah Cara Untuk Mendapatkan Gaya Sofa Abu Abu Di Rumah Anda

Ada Orang Cakap Santan Nasi Lemak Berkolesterol Salah Tu Tapi

Cara Yahudi Menghibur Diri Dari Dosa

Makna Hadis Bukan Bagian Dari Golonganku