Wage Subsidies For Employers Better Than Indiscriminate Cash Handouts


The devil is in the details as the saying goes. Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin announced a whopping RM250 billion stimulus package on March 26. This is 17% of Malaysia’s 2019 GDP
The direct fiscal injection, i.e. the government dipping into its till and handing out the funds, is RM25 billion, or 1.7% of its GDP. While this amount is much smaller and manageable, former minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Abdul Wahid Omar said it would push the budget deficit to 6.5% of GDP, from its present 3.5%. Others think the fiscal injection is inadequate
The questions I will ask are how will it be spent, and is that the best way to spend it
Firstly, I fully support the need to take a proactive stand to meet and overcome the health crisis that has morphed into an economic crisis and possibly a financial crisis
Secondly, the priority is to minimise the loss of lives, protect our health and frontline workers, who are risking their lives to save others
Thirdly, the government should minimise the impact of economic dislocation and economic suffering of the vulnerable segments of society
Fourthly, the government should not worry about how the stock market reacts. Let the market sort itself out
Fifthly, because of the size of the budget and the questionable legitimacy of the present Cabinet and government, it is all the more imperative that the proposed budget be openly debated in Parliament as is done in most countries, and for as much transparency as possible to be made to the public. For a start, the government should provide a simple breakdown, by categories, of how the money will be spent
A huge chunk of the fiscal injection is used to directly give cash handouts to the B40 (households earning less than RM4,000) and M40 (households earning between RM4,001-RM8,000)
Every B40 household will get RM1,600 and every M40 household gets RM1,000. Singles earning less than RM2,000 will get RM800 and those earning between RM2,001 and RM4,000 will get RM500. Students from tertiary education will get RM200. Pensioners and civil servants of Grade 56 (whose total remuneration is about RM15,000 per month) and below will get RM500 each
It is not clear how much this adds up to. My rough calculation is this could cost around RM10 billion. We are not sure if this is on top of the national Caring Aid of RM10 billion to farmers, fishermen, etc
Meanwhile, small businesses, from hoteliers to food and beverage operators and retailers, are all crying for more help. The government has allocated RM600 wage subsidy to each employee for up to three months, provided they are kept on the payroll. But most of them say it is inadequate, especially as they face severe cash flow problems
The way the government has crafted the package raises a host of questions. Does it help those in greatest need? Is it the most effective way to help the needy and keep the economy intact? Is the principle of sharing pain, i.e. the well to do should do their part to sacrifice a bit of their income for the needy, adhered to? Are some groups getting more at the expense of others
It seems the biggest component of the fiscal stimulus is the direct cash handout to individuals and households. I support that workers on the frontline such as health and security personnel should receive extra income for the risks they undertake
Assistance should go to those directly affected, i.e. who could lose their job or wages due to the movement control order (MCO). Cash handouts should also be given to the self-employed, such as hawkers, taxi drivers, fishermen, farmers and gig workers in the informal sector, not forgetting foreign workers
But why are the over one million civil servants of Grade 56 (whose salary reaches RM15,000 per month) and below, and pensioners receiving RM500
They are not affected as they continue to draw salaries even though most, except for essential staff, are not working during this period? Is this a carrot to win their political support for a government that was not voted in by the people as the prime minister himself admitted
Contrast this with real leadership shown by the Pahang state secretary who announced that 10,000 civil servants are ready to donate part of their salaries to Tabung Covid-19 Pahang
Also, such cash handouts are inferior to the wage subsidies to employers for economic and administrative reasons
Firstly, administratively, it is definitely more efficient and easier to pay directly to the hundreds of thousands of firms or through their EPF account, than to the millions of households and individuals
Secondly, this scheme helps both the firms to stay afloat and also the employees to tide through hard times. The association of small-medium enterprises (SMEs) has said that without adequate assistance, 50% could fold up. According to the Statistics Department, this sector accounts for 98% of total establishments, 65% of employment, and 38% of GDP in Malaysia
In contrast, cash handouts to individuals help individuals directly and firms only benefit indirectly through the demand channel. However, if half of SMEs fold up, supply of goods and services would be severely disrupted while the demand increases. This would result in inflation, something we don’t want at this time
Countries do not give a 100% wage subsidy, which makes sense. Given the MCO, the paramount objective is to make sure everyone has access to food and essentials. This is not a time to receive money to spend on discretionary items like new clothes and fancy stuff
The wage subsidy given to companies for their employees can be calibrated on a sliding scale, with a higher percentage for those with a lower income and a lower percentage for those with a higher income, as part of the principle of pain sharing
In short, this package should be better scrutinised and fine-tuned. It should be debated and passed in Parliament. It should not be used as a tool to win political support
Lim Mah Hui is from Penang Forum. - FMT

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2020/04/wage-subsidies-for-employers-better.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Must

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Stimulus Plan Economists Laud Household And Wage Subsidies Hope For Prudent Rollout

Stimulus Plan Economists Laud Household And Wage Subsidies Hope For Prudent Rollout

papar berkaitan - pada 28/3/2020 - jumlah : 156 hits
Economists have lauded Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin s economic stimulus package for its measures for households and jobs most affected by the Covid 19 pandemic They specifically praised the handouts for B40 and M40 families The experts a...
Muhyiddin Receives Cash Donations Totalling Rm4 25m For Covid 19 Fund

Muhyiddin Receives Cash Donations Totalling Rm4 25m For Covid 19 Fund

papar berkaitan - pada 31/3/2020 - jumlah : 234 hits
CORONAVIRUS Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin today received cash donations totalling RM4 25 million and medical equipment worth a whopping RM26 million from six corporate entities for the Covid 19 Fund Among the companies were Naza Corporati...
Online Court Platform Will Make For Better Work Efficiency Says Lawyer

Online Court Platform Will Make For Better Work Efficiency Says Lawyer

papar berkaitan - pada 26/3/2020 - jumlah : 276 hits
Lawyer Muhammad Farhan Muhammad Shafee says they can complete other tasks in the office while waiting for their turns to appear before the judge online KUALA LUMPUR The arrangement made by the Sabah Law Society with the Chief Judge of Sabah...
Covid 19 Come In Early For Treatment For Better Survival Chances Says Health Dg

Covid 19 Come In Early For Treatment For Better Survival Chances Says Health Dg

papar berkaitan - pada 25/3/2020 - jumlah : 236 hits
Those with symptoms of Covid 19 including difficulty in breathing should visit a hospital early for better chances of survival said director general Noor Hisham Abdullah He told a press conference in Putrajaya today that one of the main rea...
Sarawak Mtuc Criticises Employers Body For Prioritising Profits

Sarawak Mtuc Criticises Employers Body For Prioritising Profits

papar berkaitan - pada 27/3/2020 - jumlah : 211 hits
The Sarawak MTUC has criticised the Malaysian Employers Federation for stating that companies are not legally obliged to pay salaries throughout the MCO KUCHING The Sarawak Malaysian Trades Union Congress has criticised the Malaysian Employ...
Wong Chen Pr Disaster For Muhyiddin To Extend Mco Without Pledging Cash

Wong Chen Pr Disaster For Muhyiddin To Extend Mco Without Pledging Cash

papar berkaitan - pada 26/3/2020 - jumlah : 187 hits
CORONAVIRUS Subang MP Wong Chen has blasted Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin for announcing the of the movement control order to April 14 without offering the people any goodies to address their economic fears It is an absolute PR disaster T...
Exempt Employers From Contributing To Epf Socso For 6 Months Ngos

Exempt Employers From Contributing To Epf Socso For 6 Months Ngos

papar berkaitan - pada 24/3/2020 - jumlah : 220 hits
CORONAVIRUS The government has been told to exempt the employers from contributing to the Employees Provident Fund and Social Security Organisation for six months These were among the proposals suggested by the Malay Chambers of Commerce Ma...
Better Aid Packages In Store For Smes Says Minister

Better Aid Packages In Store For Smes Says Minister

papar berkaitan - pada 2/4/2020 - jumlah : 178 hits
Entrepreneur and Cooperative Development Minister Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar KUALA LUMPUR Entrepreneur and Cooperative Development Minister Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar says the government will improve on existing aid packages for small to medi...
Govt Offers Salary Subsidies Up To Rm1 200 For Sme Staff In Additional Prihatin Package

Govt Offers Salary Subsidies Up To Rm1 200 For Sme Staff In Additional Prihatin Package

papar berkaitan - pada 7/4/2020 - jumlah : 229 hits
The government has allocated an additional RM10 billion for SMEs small Cover image via New Straits Times small Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin revealed new incentives in a special stimulus package for small and medium sized enterpri...
Ph Must Safeguard Its Voter Base To Land Second Term For Anwar Says Analyst

Fungi Wechat Yang Ramai Tak Tahu

My Duty Role As Src Director Only Existed In Name Shahrol Tells Court

Ziana Zain Duta Rasmi Csa Academy

Taman Tema Genting Highland

Di Masjid Muhammadiyah Nurul Yakin Paus Quran Dan Sains By Dr Hm Raki

Tuah Adzmi Zack Zakwan Adikkk Muna Shahirah Wani Syaz Nurul Iman Ya Raya Chord

Neoclassical Apartments Interior Decor Inspirations



Koleksi 15 Lagu Hari Raya Terbaru Yang Meriahkan Aidilfitri 2024 Bakal Evergreen Bak Lagu Lama

6 Pantang Larang Penting Kalau Nak Selamat di Sekolah Asrama

Info Dan Sinopsis Filem 19 Puasa Playboys Of Plastik Hitam Astro First

Casimir Zeglen Paderi Yang Mencipta Jaket Kalis Peluru

Biodata Mohammad Rifdean Masdor Atlet Muay Thai Malaysia Yang Gegarkan One Championship Seangkatan Johan Ghazali Jojo


Tadabbur Surah Surah Lazim Qarin Persiapan Mencari Lailatulqadar

Singo Pear Manfaat Pada Kesihatan Dan Petua Redakan Batuk

10 Malam Akhir Ramadan 2024 Kelebihan Tarikh Amalan Sunat

Cara Daftar Lalamove Online Driver Motor Dan Kereta

Hablun Minallah By Dr Hm Rakib S H M Ag Nurul Ikhlas Pekanbaru

Doa Agar Amalan Diiterima Allah Sepanjang Bulan Ramadan