The Numerical Dilemma Posed By The Ipcmc Bill




It has been reported that Liew Vui Keong, the de facto law minister, said the first round of briefings and consultations with stakeholders about the Independent Police Complaints of Misconduct (IPCMC) Bill, tabled in Parliament on 18 July, had been concluded
I know of two such meetings which included members of civil society. I attended one of them. I’ve spoken with friends who attended the other. Someone asked me how I feel about all of this. I said “exasperated.” Here I’ll explain why
As I’ve written before, in recent history, minister Liew is the first to conduct such meetings and he should be congratulated for doing so. But we must ask how effective the meetings have been. Can the meeting attendees explain, with numbers, how the IPCMC era will be better than the present era
The answer is a resounding 'NO'. I will explain why using data for three models I’ve discussed in previous articles. The models I’ve chosen have data associated with them. I’ve chosen two “extreme” models – one where the police do all complaint investigations and another where the police do no complaint investigations. These choices allow me to show starkly my numerical dilemma

I begin with definitions commonly used in industry
A “complaint” is an expression of dissatisfaction, reported within one document (or record). Complaints can be trivial, for example, “PDRM officers have bad breath.” Complaints can be vexatious, for example, “The police colour blue should be changed because blue signals kleptocracy.”“Registering” a complaint is a must if the complainant expects it to be registered. Every complaint process begins with registering
“Rejecting” a complaint is acceptable if it’s silly, vexatious or similarly unworthy of serious consideration. However, rejections must be recorded
“Referring” a complaint is acceptable if its subject matter concerns another institution, for example, the MACC
An “allegation” is a component of a complaint. For instance, one complaint may include three allegations - discrimination, using coarse language, failing to investigate
“Classifying” an allegation enables right decision-making about who should investigate a complaint – and much else
“Disposing” of a complaint means drawing a conclusion about the complaint, for example, “no further action” or reducing the rank of an officer. Every complaint process ends with disposition
“Investigating” a complaint means gathering enough information to determine the disposition of the complaint
“Handling” a complaint means the whole process, from registering to disposition, of every allegation in a complaint
Now let’s consider the three models
In Hong Kong, the Hong Kong Police Force (HKPF) must use their own resources to do handle every complaint. The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) must vet the investigation papers and approve the disposition. The IPCC may and very often does choose to observe interviews conducted during investigations
In 2017, the HKPF registered 3,014 allegations and fully-investigated 1,025 of them
In Northern Ireland, the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) must refer every complaint to the Northern Ireland Office of the Ombudsman. The Ombudsman must use its own resources for the entire complaint handling process. In addition, the PSNI must hand over to the Ombudsman any case which involves the discharge of police firearms, death or serious injury possibly caused by police officers and traffic collisions involving officers
In 2017, the Ombudsman registered 2,504 complaints about PSNI and fully-investigated about 835 of them
In Malaysia, the Enforcement Agency Integrity Commission (EAIC) is one of two institutions which handle complaints about the police. The other is the police’s Department for Integrity and Compliance to Standards (Jips, for “Jabatan Integriti dan Pematuhan Standard”)
In 2017, the EAIC registered 440 complaints about the police, opened investigation papers for 108 of them and “solved” (which I take to mean “fully-investigated”) 32 of them
Jips appears not to publish any data. In EAIC reports I’ve reviewed, I’ve found no mention of handling of complaints by Jips. Perhaps the EAIC sought data from Jips and Jips refused to provide it. I don’t know. It appears the EAIC has not reviewed Jips complaint handling procedures
The IPCMC proposed in the bill before Parliament has elements of both the IPCC and the Ombudsman. Neither the home minister (who is responsible for the police) nor the law minister has revealed the expected number of complaints per year
The ministers haven’t revealed how many investigations are expected to be handled by the police (Jips) and how many by the IPCMC. The ministers haven’t revealed what investigation resources the EAIC now has, neither have they said what resources the IPCMC will have
Those who attended the briefings (“consultations”) cannot answer this basic question: In relation to (1) volume of complaints and investigations and (2) lack of transparency of the police, how is the IPCMC different from the EAIC and why it is expected to be better
How can anyone not be exasperated?  - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2019/08/the-numerical-dilemma-posed-by-ipcmc.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Mus

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Will The Ipcmc Bill Bring About Much Needed Reforms

Will The Ipcmc Bill Bring About Much Needed Reforms

papar berkaitan - pada 20/8/2019 - jumlah : 160 hits
The Independent Police Complaints of Misconduct Bill 2019 had its first reading in Parliament on July 18 The bill is touted by some as a major piece of legislation tabled by the Pakatan Harapan government The bill was one of the promises in...
The Ipcmc Must Be A Black Maria Not A Kancil

The Ipcmc Must Be A Black Maria Not A Kancil

papar berkaitan - pada 10/8/2019 - jumlah : 235 hits
In an article on Wednesday titled Citizens Against Enforced Disappearances Caged mentioned Green Papers Here I will respond to several requests I have received to expand on Green Papers First a little background The Governance Integrity and...
Criticise But Do So Constructively Bar Council Man Says On Ipcmc Bill

Criticise But Do So Constructively Bar Council Man Says On Ipcmc Bill

papar berkaitan - pada 9/8/2019 - jumlah : 156 hits
Lawyer Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali says there is still time to tweak the bill on the Independent Police Complaints and Misconduct Commission PETALING JAYA A lawyer has called for constructive feedback on the Independent Police Complaints an...
Cina M Sia Tak Bersyukur Rumusan Buku The Chinese Dilemma

Cina M Sia Tak Bersyukur Rumusan Buku The Chinese Dilemma

papar berkaitan - pada 11/8/2019 - jumlah : 249 hits
Rumusan Buku THE CHINESE DILEMMAAPA PENULIS KATA BERKENAAN CINA 1 Pandangan ini adalah dari Ye Lin Sheng yang berasal dari China tetapi seorang ahli perniagaan di Malaysia Hong Kong Australia Thailand Singapura Britain dan Amerika Syarikat ...
How Similar Will The Ipcmc Be To Northern Ireland S Ombudsman

How Similar Will The Ipcmc Be To Northern Ireland S Ombudsman

papar berkaitan - pada 18/8/2019 - jumlah : 174 hits
Previously I discussed the Hong Kong Independent Police Complaints Commission In Hong Kong the police conduct their own investigations of complaints about them The IPCC observes and vets the investigations Half the Hong Kong public do not b...
The Best Healthy Zucchini Recipes

The Best Healthy Zucchini Recipes

papar berkaitan - pada 13/8/2019 - jumlah : 162 hits
The best healthy zucchini recipes that are perfect for any meal of the day From quick breads and brownies to delicious lasagna and meatballs these easy healthy zucchini recipes will be be your new favorites to make year round Wrapping up an...
Khat What S The Big Fuss

Khat What S The Big Fuss

papar berkaitan - pada 13/8/2019 - jumlah : 159 hits
The fuss is not about learning Jawi writing The central issue is that education has opened the gateway for politicians religious political parties including the ulama and the so called Malay nationalists to advance their political and relig...
Bella Hadid Amp The Weeknd Putus Cinta Kali Kedua

Bella Hadid Amp The Weeknd Putus Cinta Kali Kedua

papar berkaitan - pada 13/8/2019 - jumlah : 166 hits
Hiburan Model antarabangsa Bella Hadid dikhabarkan berpisah dengan teman lelakinya penyanyi The Weeknd atau nama sebenarnya Abel Tesfaye buat kali yang kedua Memetik laporan HollywoodLife perpisahan itu dikatakan berpunca dari jadual kerja ...
James Gunn Jelaskan Kemunculan Batman Dalam Filem The Suicide Squad

James Gunn Jelaskan Kemunculan Batman Dalam Filem The Suicide Squad

papar berkaitan - pada 13/8/2019 - jumlah : 252 hits
Jika anda pernah menonton filem Suicide Squad arahan David Ayer pasti anda pernah melihat cameo adiwira Gotham itu dalam filem yang menampilkan watak antagonis DC Walaupun sekadar cameo adiwira tersebut telah memainkan peranan penting dalam...
Hiburan Ratu Buat Kecoh Lagi Terpekik Naik Kuda Sampai Pengunjung Resort Keluar Bilik Tengok Dah Tau Takut Kenapa Naik

Anwar S Cabinet Zzz

Functional Design Moto Borgotaro S Ducati 900 Gts

Satu Malaysia Kena Scam Dengan Anwar Ibrahim

Samsung Wins 46 Ces 2023 Innovation Awards From The Consumer Technology Association

Safawi Rasid Diumumkan Keluar Daripada Johor Darul Takzim

Kenali Issei Sagawa Kanibal Jepun Yang Tidak Pernah Dipenjarakan

Hanya Sebulan Tempoh Perkenalan Hana Ismail Terima Da I Syed Selepas Solat Istikharah Seminggu



5 Pemain Piala Dunia 2022 Dengan Identiti Yang Mengelirukan

Dai Syed Kahwin Ini Biodata Isterinya Pengacara Hana Ismail

Fahami Pandangan Mazhab Islam Yang Mengharamkan Makanan Laut

Apa Sebenarnya Kuasa Timbalan Perdana Menteri Malaysia

Bagaimana Adidas Memasukkan Mikrocip Ke Dalam Sebiji Bola


Lantik Zahid Reformasi Terbesar Dilakukan Anwar Sindir Pemuda

Ph Umno Tak Cakap Soal Rasuah Dan Bangsa Lagi Takut Kena Kawan

Anies Ke Relawan Kirim Pesan Positif Untuk Semua Bahkan Kalau Diejek Berikan Senyum

Video Hasil Piala Dunia Prancis Vs Polandia Mbappe Dan Giroud Cetak Rekor

After Two Years Ummi S Life

Awani Ringkas Tiga Tumpuan Utama Harungi Kelembapan Ekonomi Global Zafrul