Seizure Of Smartphones Without Warrant An Abuse Of Power


 

In England, as in most civilised countries that value privacy and human rights, police and investigative agencies do not have carte blanche to seize mobile phones, computers and personal items without a court order, commonly referred to as a warrant.
English courts, in particular, are very protective of public rights and will not allow investigative agencies to abuse their powers, even in cases involving serious crimes.
This prohibition also encompasses the right to inspect the contents of devices and obtain passwords except in compliance with strict protocols or directions issued by the court.
Any breach will result in disciplinary action. An action for damages may also lie for breach of constitutional, statutory or human rights.
Countries higher up on the corruption index, however, have less regard for human rights and the right to privacy. They are ruled by law, rather than governed according to the rule of law.
It is my observation that the laws of these countries would provide investigative agencies with greater rights when it comes to searching the body or entry into any premises to search for and seize material evidence, especially in relation to serious offences.
Such evidence is usually admissible in court even if the search and seizure is unlawful or breaches protocol.
In my view, even suspicions that a serious offence may have been committed cannot justify the violation of protected rights such as the freedoms of speech and assembly, and many others.
Any encroachment into constitutionally protected rights without strict observation of protocol would, in my view, be tantamount to an abuse of power.
In countries where such protocols are not in place, it falls on the relevant members of the legal industry and public-minded organisations to move the court for direction and guidance. This is what currently takes place in India.
It is important for the public as well as the executive, legislature, judiciary and related agencies to appreciate that in the current era, smartphones are likely to contain confidential and personal information. In fact, it is likely to also contain private information belonging to third parties. The unwarranted exposure of such information may destroy the fabric of society.
A mobile phone these days also contains the financial information of its owner, and if access passwords are obtained by investigative officers without judicial supervision, there is a grave risk of monies being misappropriated. A victim may be left helpless and unable to report such crimes, especially if threatened by those cloaked with authority over them.
There is also a risk that solicitor and client privilege will be violated since modern day phones regularly contain texts and emails exchanged between them.
All readers own smartphones and will immediately know the implications if their device is seized unlawfully by the police.
It would not be an exaggeration for me to say that the handing over of mobile phones and computers, with password access, and without judicial supervision represents the most serious threat to privacy and individual liberty in this century.
The public, with the support of the legal fraternity, must rise to safeguard the liberty of all persons, either through legislation or the courts.
For example, even a miscreant can lodge a complaint for alleged criminal defamation.
The law on defamation is straightforward and prosecutorial agencies can already charge a person purely based on allegedly defamatory comments published and a statement and evidence furnished by the complainant.
It is then for the court to decide whether the posting is defamatory and malicious and whether it satisfies all the elements of the crime as stipulated in the Penal Code.
In such cases, there is no justification or necessity for investigation agencies to seize mobile phones, computers or other documents to obtain evidence for prosecution of the charge. Under our constitutional jurisprudence, such excessive actions would be tantamount to abuse of power.
The irony in Malaysia is that despite the robust oaths of office imposed on constitutional functionaries by the drafters of the Federal Constitution, the legal industry has yet to develop any jurisprudence to govern such abuses.
In PP v. Aluma Mark Chinonso & another appeal (2020), I explained that the oath of office vests judges with judicial power and gives them a “constitutional soul” to act judiciously.
The parameters of judicial power are also spelt out in the oath. While in England, judicial power is subservient to parliament, in Malaysia, it is subservient only to the constitution.
In my view, what that means is that the rule of law in Malaysia is not the same as the one which applies in England or India. This is because the oaths of office taken by functionaries within the three pillars of the governments in these two countries are not same as those prescribed by our supreme law.
In Malaysia, these oaths impose a constitutional obligation to “preserve, protect and defend” the constitution.
That means the courts are obliged to strike down, either wholly or in part, laws which enable such abuses of power. Courts are also empowered to issue proper directions to the other pillars of government calling for the repeal or amendment of such laws.
In addition, our constitution is framed in such a manner that the final say on the rule of law rests with the rulers. This is evidenced by the army being placed under their control.
Thus, unlike in England, it is important to engage the rulers whenever any of the three pillars do not perform its functions according to the rule of law, for instance if clean and corrupt-free government machinery is not in place.
Regrettably, Malaysia has over the last four decades suffered the indignity of various financial vices, which have contributed significantly to the decline in value of our ringgit as compared to the Singapore currency. Indeed, we are fast moving towards becoming a failed state.
The legal industry must bear its share of the blame for this.
Its wilful blindness in the face of abusive laws and practices has allowed corruption and misconduct in office to fester and has compromised the public’s rights and its legitimate expectation of social justice as given by the constitution.
The time has come to hold our leaders accountable under the robust oaths of office set out in the Federal Constitution and apply the judicial power of the court to arrest the perpetrators of all forms of constitutional violations by office holders.
The academia and the legal industry must equip itself with knowledge of this jurisprudence and debate it vigorously both among themselves and in public. - FMT
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2023/11/seizure-of-smartphones-without-warrant.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Dpc Pdip Solo Didatangi Polisi Hasto Intimidasi Dan Abuse Of Power

Dpc Pdip Solo Didatangi Polisi Hasto Intimidasi Dan Abuse Of Power

papar berkaitan - pada 9/11/2023 - jumlah : 237 hits
Hasto menyebut petugas bertanya hal hal yang tidak ada kaitannya dengan tugas dan fungsi Polri Seperti agenda rapat dan kehadiran
No Abuse Of Power In 1mdb Bond Issue Probe Says Macc

No Abuse Of Power In 1mdb Bond Issue Probe Says Macc

papar berkaitan - pada 7/11/2023 - jumlah : 389 hits
MACC has applied for a court order compelling two law firms to provide documents in connection with an investigation into a controversial US 6 5 billion bond issue PETALING JAYA The Malaysian Anti Corruption Commission has dismissed an alle...
Unleashing The Power Of Kagi Charts In Your Trading Strategy

Unleashing The Power Of Kagi Charts In Your Trading Strategy

papar berkaitan - pada 14/11/2023 - jumlah : 280 hits
Whether you re a seasoned trader or just starting having various tools in your trading toolbox can maximize your success One such tool that often doesn t get the recognition it deserves is the Kagi chart Below we will delve deep into this u...
Cabaran Menulis Hari 8 The Power Of Music

Cabaran Menulis Hari 8 The Power Of Music

papar berkaitan - pada 15/11/2023 - jumlah : 225 hits
Cabaran Menulis Hari 8 The Power Of Music Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatuh dan Salam Madani Malaysia Dengan Nama Allah Yang Maha Pengasih Lagi Maha Penyayang Segala pujian hanya Allah dan sebelum memulakan bicara artikel yang lebi...
I Am The Kafir Who Put Some Of You In Power

I Am The Kafir Who Put Some Of You In Power

papar berkaitan - pada 7/11/2023 - jumlah : 276 hits
Puncak Borneo MP Willie Mongin said political parties should not come up with statements that could incite the public KUALA LUMPUR Irked by labels such as kafir used by some opposition MPs Sarawak s Willie Mongin has reminded them that he i...
Energy Experts Support Nuclear Power But Activists Push Back

Energy Experts Support Nuclear Power But Activists Push Back

papar berkaitan - pada 30/10/2023 - jumlah : 340 hits
Energy experts have defended their controversial support for nuclear energy as part of an option to move away from fossil fuels to more sustainable sources of power Climate Governance Malaysia member Gary Theseira and Asia School of Busines...
Posting Rules Unleashing The Power Of Communication

Posting Rules Unleashing The Power Of Communication

papar berkaitan - pada 31/10/2023 - jumlah : 246 hits
Have you ever wondered how messages travel from one place to another In the digital era sending messages has become almost instantaneous But have you ever stopped to think about the journey these messages take before reaching their destinat...
Unleash The Power Of Body Shaping Dresses With Shapellx This Black Friday

Unleash The Power Of Body Shaping Dresses With Shapellx This Black Friday

papar berkaitan - pada 2/11/2023 - jumlah : 397 hits
Black Friday the most anticipated holiday shopping season is right around the corner People are getting ready to shop for things they have been wanting to buy for a while during the upcoming big sales Among the many Black Friday events the ...
Heads Up Kl Selangor Asean Summit Means Temporary Home Based Learning For Some Schools

How To Turn Your Child Into A Consistent Learner During The School Year

Lantikan Politik Dr Akmal Bersyukur Pm Anwar Kini Faham Apa Yang Dilakukan Bn

Berbuat Baiklah Kerana Ia Juga Untuk Dirimu Sendiri

Mas Khan Qi Razali Selamat Bergelar Suami Hari Ini

Karina Kot Siapa Taknak Tular Video Peminat Bawa Lari Standee Karina Aespa Di Mid Valley Kl

Peria Sayur Pahit Yang Kaya Dengan Pelbagai Khasiat

Milosuam Dah Kenapa Nepotisme Bukan Salah Kalau Ada Merit Teruk Kena Kecam


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


Mee Rebus Johor

Pkr Ke Mana Hilangnya 60 Peratus Undi Di Persimpangan Jalan Atau Parti Yang Kehilangan Haluan

Usaha Bersama Asean Dalam Membangun Ekosistem Digital Yang Selamat

The Mysterious Yonaguni Monument Japan S Underwater Enigma

Manhunt Launched After 4 Abduct Goldsmith In Tumpat

Heard Of The Giant Pig Island In Malaysia