Rm120b Glic Investments Need Serious Rethink





Directives to six government-linked investment companies (GLICs) managing RM1.8 trillion to invest RM120 billion over five years in potentially risky high-growth ventures are dangerous and misplaced.
Such investments should be through direct government funding via cutbacks and new revenue sources, and channelled into one professional, government-owned investing company rather than a number of them with different objectives.
This is especially so since the six - the Employees Provident Fund (EPF), Retirement Fund Inc (Kwap), Permodalan Nasional Berhad (PNB), Khazanah Nasional Berhad, Tabung Haji, and Armed Forces Fund Board (LTAT) - have different obligations to their different stakeholders.
Importantly, the RM1.8 trillion invested by these GLICs is not liquid. Most of it is not available because they are already invested, much of them in long-term stable, solid investments. To say that they are liquid is incorrect.
The second thing to note is that retirement funds EPF (RM1.14 trillion under management) and Kwap (RM170 billion) account for over 70 percent of total funds managed by the six (see table), with the EPF alone accounting for 62 percent.
They are obliged to preserve capital with stable longer-term investments such as quality bonds and stocks.
They should not risk them in potentially high-risk new investments which are the preserve of entrepreneurs and companies who know the business. We have not come to a stage where we really know these businesses in which the funds are supposed to be invested.
Catalysing growth in key economic sectors is not, repeat, not, the aim of retirement funds. It’s to provide safe, stable returns to protect old-age savings.
In the case of Kwap, it is government-funded but it is to fill potential gaps in government pension obligations. Prudence dictates it must have similar criteria to pension funds.
PNB, which has over RM300 billion invested, was set up to increase the participation of bumiputera in key businesses. It too has to preserve the quality and safety of its investments as a repository of savings of mainly bumiputera.
Similarly, both Tabung Haji (savings for pilgrims to go to Mecca) and LTAT (supplementary retirement savings for armed forces personnel) have particular obligations to their stakeholders to provide safe, steady returns.
Both have recently been embroiled in questions over the previous management’s capability and professionalism in recent years. Therefore they are hardly candidates to entrust with difficult, troublesome investments.
Asking for trouble…
The type of investments these funds are required to make are given in a Finance Ministry press release.
I quote verbatim: “These investments are primarily directed towards high-growth, high-value industries such as the energy transition sector; advanced manufacturing especially in the semiconductor space; investments across all life cycles of firms from start-ups, venture capital to mid-tier companies; and finally to support listing of such companies.”
That’s a rather ambitious and scary undertaking which will carry tremendous risk, akin to a private equity firm which takes high risk for high returns but in areas where they have expertise to contribute.
The only one among the six qualified to do this and has a clear mandate to do so by the government is Khazanah (RM126 billion in management), which over the years has built up expertise in investing.
Note that they do not usually engage in start-ups in these fields though, which is much more complex. Even they don’t have the expertise to start these up from scratch - we are asking for trouble if we do so.
Remember the wafer fabrication plant, SilTerra, paradoxically under Khazanah, which reportedly lost some RM5.5 billion over nine years to 2017? We cannot move faster than our capabilities.
Has Khazanah applied to amend SilTerra’s local shareholding requirement?
These investments should be put under one government investment authority - Khazanah comes close and has expertise built up since its transformation in the 2000s.
It has the advantage of both local and foreign investment experience.
The government should provide the RM24 billion a year to the fund to make RM120 billion over five years - it must come out of their own pockets from cuts in spending and new revenue sources.
It must ensure that they have reasonable chances for success, otherwise RM120 billion will be so much money down the drain.
It should not be taken out of retirement funds, which is dangerous, and downright irresponsible, something which was used by the previous backdoor government to reflate the economy and promote irresponsible spending.
Learn from the past
An older example is instructive. In the ‘80s, then PM Dr Mahatahir Mohamad started a push into heavy industries such as steel, cement, cars, bikes, trucks and so on when the need and viability for such industries were not established and no feasibility studies were made.
An earlier industrial master plan by experts had recommended a focus on resource-based industries instead such as industries needing rubber, furniture and wood products and palm-based products. Mahathir ignored it and we paid the price and are still paying up.
Ex-PM Dr Mahathir MohamadThat caused the country tens if not hundreds of billions of ringgit, much wasted time and effort, setting us back many years in terms of lost opportunities. Ambition must always be matched with capability and competitive advantages.
⁠We have had a history of less profitable investments and even losses in many government-owned companies. We must not make such mistakes again by pushing for projects we are not capable of undertaking yet.
Think it through, plan properly
In the latest episode, we have put the cart before the horse. You can’t industrialise by edict, which is what Mahathir tried to do and failed miserably and which the Madani government is emulating now.
Hire competent people first to investigate the ground and make a sound assessment of what is possible and a plan of action, budgets and forecasts. Evaluate them and then move if all checks out.
To say we will invest RM120 billion over five years in these areas without even so much as studying how these can be implemented and the benefits they will bring is foolhardy.
You need to do the groundwork before you decide to invest what, where, how, how much and over what period.
These things can’t be done by instructing GLICs to simply go out and invest - that’s a recipe for disaster.
Where is the feasibility study and plan? They need to come first and only then should a decision be made - for or against. - Mkini
P GUNASEGARAM says political grandstanding is a dangerous game, both for the rakyat and those engaging in them.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2024/08/rm120b-glic-investments-need-serious.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
No Need For Dap With Only 35 Chinese Voters In Nenggiri Says Ahmad Maslan

No Need For Dap With Only 35 Chinese Voters In Nenggiri Says Ahmad Maslan

papar berkaitan - pada 6/8/2024 - jumlah : 119 hits
Umno Supreme Council member Ahmad Maslan said DAP and MCA were not compelled to campaign but were welcome to do so GUA MUSANG With only 35 Chinese voters in the Nenggiri constituency there is no necessity for DAP to campaign for Barisan Nas...
The Need For More Highly Skilled Workers In Malaysia

The Need For More Highly Skilled Workers In Malaysia

papar berkaitan - pada 2/8/2024 - jumlah : 275 hits
By Suzlin NordinSource Employment Statistics First Quarter 2024 Dept of Statistic Malaysia In recent statistic about Malaysia s workforce a striking statistic stands out less than 30 of Malaysian workers are classified as skilled This raise...
The Therapeutic Benefits Of Delta 8 Cartridges What You Need To Know

The Therapeutic Benefits Of Delta 8 Cartridges What You Need To Know

papar berkaitan - pada 1/8/2024 - jumlah : 168 hits
In recent years Delta 8 THC has emerged as a popular alternative to its more well known counterpart Delta 9 THC While both cannabinoids are found in cannabis Delta 8 offers a unique profile of effects and therapeutic benefits Delta 8 THC ca...
Malaysia S Gop Need A Reality Check

Malaysia S Gop Need A Reality Check

papar berkaitan - pada 1/8/2024 - jumlah : 175 hits
In the early part of this season of annual UMNO Divisional meetings voices have emerged to demand that UMNO break out from the Unity Government It came from groups within UMNO exploiting PH s colossal lost at the Sungai Bakap by election Am...
We Need To Talk About Race And Religion

We Need To Talk About Race And Religion

papar berkaitan - pada 10/8/2024 - jumlah : 163 hits
From Adnan DIn a world where race and ethnicity often dominate discussions it s easy to feel overwhelmed by the sensitivity and potential for conflict these topics bring Yet shying away from these conversations only hinders our intellectual...
Do We Need A Female President

Do We Need A Female President

papar berkaitan - pada 15/8/2024 - jumlah : 136 hits
Dr Ben Carson discusses the possibility of a President Kamala Harris and Nikki Haley speaking at the RNC on The Ingraham Angle One of the most formative experiences of my career was teaching fifth grade I loved teaching biographies because ...
Investments Rising Despite M Sia S Differing Stance On Gaza Says Pm

Investments Rising Despite M Sia S Differing Stance On Gaza Says Pm

papar berkaitan - pada 9/8/2024 - jumlah : 103 hits
Investments in Malaysia continue to rise despite the nation s differing stance on the Gaza issue compared to that of European countries said Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim Anwar pointed out that the increase in investment includes the electri...
Transform Your Investments With Solismarkets State Of The Art Platform

Transform Your Investments With Solismarkets State Of The Art Platform

papar berkaitan - pada 7/8/2024 - jumlah : 121 hits
Finding a reliable and knowledgeable partner in the fast paced financial trading world is essential to your success SolisMarkets is an industry leader by providing investors with state of the art trading platforms SolisMarkets is a regulate...
No Need To Dry Dirty Linen In Public So Umno Better Use Its General Assembly For Proper Soul Searching Of Its Future

No Need To Dry Dirty Linen In Public So Umno Better Use Its General Assembly For Proper Soul Searching Of Its Future

papar berkaitan - pada 16/8/2024 - jumlah : 110 hits
SPECULATIONS are rife as to why UMNO is making its forthcoming General Assembly 2024 at the World Trade Centre Kuala Lumpur from Aug 21 24 a close door affair limited only to party members and representatives from Barisan Nasional component...
Nikmati Kopi Lovns Dengan Cawan Berinsulasi Ais Pertama Dunia

Earth Symphony Green Cirque Fest 2024 A First Of Its Kind Eco Circus Celebrating Sustainability In Southeast Asia

Guangzhou Metro Dan Makan Di Restoran Halal Depan Masjid Huaisheng Guangzhou

Zaman Sekarang Rakam Dulu Baru Tolong

12 Waktu Paling Mustajab Untuk Doa Mudah Dikabulkan

Mpox Vaccination Kicks Off In Drc After 859 Deaths This Year

Auditors And The Bottomless Money Pit Called Taxpayer

Lg Shines At Idea 2024 Two Gold Awards Celebrate Innovative And Inclusive Design


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Mr Hiiragi s Homeroom Yang Diadaptasi Ke Siri Malaysia Kelas Tahanan Cikgu Hiragi

5 Bukti Jelas Bagaimana Teknologi Moden Buat Kita Tak Reti Berfikir

10 Fakta Drama Berepisod Kelas Tahanan Cikgu Hiragi Adaptasi Mr Hiiragi s Homeroom Astro Ria Sooka Fakta Yang Ramai Tak Tahu

5 Isu Utama Pelajar Genius Usia Muda Masuk Universiti Awal

Resepi Sup Ayam Thai Paling Menarik dan Senang Dibuat Rasa Sekali Pasti Terpikat


Jambu Bertih Rosak

Win Big With Toshiba Tv S October Sensation Promo

Vivo Partners With Sunway Lagoon Nights Of Frights 10 For A Spooktacular Celebration

Stop That Dot Homesoy Empowers Malaysian Women To Take Charge Of Breast Cancer Prevention

116 Mangsa Dipindahkan Ke Dua Pps Di Simpang Renggam

15 Stunning Mid Century Sunroom Designs With Contemporary Elegance