Revisiting The Case Of Nizar V Zambry


 


This week, PKR president Anwar Ibrahim dropped a bombshell. In a press conference, he informed the country that he is seeking an audience with the Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Abdullah Sultan Ahmad Shah to present the support that he has to be appointed the new prime minister.
According to Anwar, the government of Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin has fallen after the majority of MPs no longer supported the Pagoh MP.
One of the earliest legal opinions put forth in this latest development in Malaysian politics was by academic, Professor Shamrahayu Ab Aziz. She was reported to have said that only the prime minister has the right to meet with the Agong on whether he still has majority support.
She also argued that even with statutory declarations, the same cannot be presented to the Agong and that Anwar needed to bring a motion of no confidence in the Dewan Rakyat in order to prove that Muhyiddin no longer commands the majority support.
With respect, this view is not in line with the precedent in the case of former Perak menteri besar Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin vs Umno's Zambry Abdul Kadir which was decided by the Federal Court in 2010.




Zambry Abdul Kadir

The case relates to the political conflict which occurred in 2009 in Perak. At the time, the Pakatan Rakyat state government there fell to BN when three Pakatan Rakyat lawmakers shifted their support from Nizar to BN’s Zambry.
One of the issues to be decided in the case was whether the loss of support to a menteri besar must be shown in the state legislative assembly, or whether it can be decided by other means such as the state ruler (at that time, the late Sultan Azlan Muhibbuddin Shah) outside of the state assembly.
Sultan Azlan had at the time met with the three defecting lawmakers and determined that Nizar lost majority support, despite not losing a no-confidence motion in the state assembly.




Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin
The Federal Court decided that there was no provision in the state constitution that provides for the loss of support can only be determined in the legislative chamber. Evidence of loss of support can be garnered from sources outside of the state assembly if correctly proven.
In order words, the loss of support of a menteri besar need not be proven only through the state assembly and may be ascertained by way of face-to-face meetings or statutory declarations.
Although this case is in relation to the Perak state constitution, the relevant provisions are similar to the constitution in other states, as well as the Federal Constitution itself. As such, the precedent in Perak is binding to other states as well as at the federal level.
That is why similar instances occurred when state governments in Kedah and Malacca fell in the aftermath of the now infamous 'Sheraton Move'. The rulers of those states determined that the menteri besar or chief minister lost majority support without a state assembly sitting in the respective states. It is curious to note that at that time, no academic put forth any view to say that Perikatan Nasional must first prove that the incumbents lost majority support in the state assembly.
Similarly, if indeed Muhyiddin no longer commands majority support of MPs, it can similarly be determined by the Agong without the need for a Dewan Rakyat sitting to test his support.
Some may not agree with the decision of the Federal Court in Nizar v Zambry. Undoubtedly, the best and most transparent way to determine whether the PM continues to enjoy majority support should be by way of a Parliamentary sitting.



But despite what we may feel, the fact of the matter is that there is a precedent in Nizar v Zambry on this issue, and unless in a subsequent decision this precedent is overruled, then it remains valid and binding.

SYAHREDZAN JOHAN is a civil liberties lawyer and political secretary to Iskandar Puteri MP Lim Kit Siang. - Mkini
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2020/09/revisiting-case-of-nizar-v-zambry.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Must+K

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Nizar V Zambry Not Inconsistent With Parliamentary Democracy

Nizar V Zambry Not Inconsistent With Parliamentary Democracy

papar berkaitan - pada 27/9/2020 - jumlah : 116 hits
I refer to Syahredzan Johan s article As the writer said some may not agree with the decision of the Federal Court in Nizar v Zambry that the loss of confidence in the menteri besar of Perak may not only be established through a vote in the...
The Reason Malaysia Is A Corrupt Country

The Reason Malaysia Is A Corrupt Country

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 177 hits
And if you wish to live in a heavenly utopia the perfect country promised by Pakatan Harapan then become a suicide bomber because I was told they all go to heaven where virgins are waiting to greet them NO HOLDS BARRED Raja Petra Kamarudin ...
When Business Drop Find The Right Mentor

When Business Drop Find The Right Mentor

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 213 hits
If the biz decreases then we needs another person as an advisor The habit of biz is there is a time to go up and there is a time to go down His father s secret to staying with this biz is that we do not lose touch with sincere biz advisors ...
Sarawak Should Reject The Rm2 95 Billion From Petronas

Sarawak Should Reject The Rm2 95 Billion From Petronas

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 172 hits
Chong Chieng Jen DAP Sarawak KUCHING State Democratic Action Party chairman Chong Chieng Jen has regarded the RM2 95 billion payment of State Sales Tax from Petroliam Nasional Berhad to the Sarawak government as a trade off for the state s ...
Pigs And Frogs The Tale Of Malaysian Politics

Pigs And Frogs The Tale Of Malaysian Politics

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 126 hits
So decide Are you a babi or katak You can choose only one But whatever it is do not become a kuda or lembu Kuda and lembu are used by the babi and end up in the pot while the babi get fat At least the katak can jump and not get cheated like...
Living Room Shelves Advantages How To Choose The Perfect One

Living Room Shelves Advantages How To Choose The Perfect One

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 140 hits
The living room shelf is that piece of furniture that never leaves the scene even after the rack and TV panels Multifunctional the bookcase has reinvented itself and today it manages to be even more The post appeared first on
Bn And Gps Failed The People Not Us Says Dap Rep

Bn And Gps Failed The People Not Us Says Dap Rep

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 119 hits
Bukit Assek politicians Irene Chang and Joseph Chieng have crossed swords KUCHING A Sarawak DAP assemblyman has urged the SUPP to look at all the mess created by BN or GPS before accusing Pakatan Harapan of failing the people Irene Chang th...
The Bonggoks Belum Kenal Orang Permatang Pauh Kot Ya

The Bonggoks Belum Kenal Orang Permatang Pauh Kot Ya

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 127 hits
Ibrahim Mat Isa Tak mudah untuk aku bersangka baik kalau kalau begini sikapnya LALANG dan GEDIK Kalau terus terusan kenyataan seperti ini keluar dari pemimpin peringkat pertengahan Amanah jangan harap aku akan berhenti untuk mengkritik Buka...
Joel Kinnaman Dedah The Suicide Squad R Rated Yang Berat Puji Komedi John Cena

Joel Kinnaman Dedah The Suicide Squad R Rated Yang Berat Puji Komedi John Cena

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 144 hits
Semasa acara DC FanDome bulan lalu The Suicide Squad telah membuat peminat tidak sabar untuk menonton filem terbaru James Gunn dan kini pelakon utamanya Joel Kinnaman menambah lagi keterujaan peminat Ketika bercakap kepada The Hollywood Rep...
Inilah Punca Sebenar Maradona Meninggal Dunia Secara Mengejut Malam Tadi

Polis Terlibat Rasuah Bersedialah Untuk Ditamatkan Perkhidmatan Ketua Polis Negara

Skim I Sinar Cara Mohon Pengeluaran I Sinar Kwsp Rm10 000

As Suhtu Perbuatan Buruk Yahudi Yang Banyak Ditiru Oleh Muslim

Realme C15 Telefon Pintar Pertama Dengan Bateri Pengecasan Terpantas

Tanaman Herba Yang Boleh Hidup Dalam Air

Beberapa Persoalan Bajet Tidak Dijawab Secara Tepat

Some Useful Links For You To Get Started



Kenapa Babi Sering Dijadikan Bentuk Tabung Duit

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Sang Pewaris Slot Lestary TV3

Kesan Pandemik COVID 19 Terhadap Bahasa Inggeris

5 Tabiat Suami Mithali Yang Tak Ditayang Drama dan Filem

Adakah Benar Manusia Boleh Dihidupkan Semula Selepas Dibekukan


Apa Jadi Jika Pembangkang Pilih Tolak Belanjawan 2021 Semalam

Rider Foodpanda Kena Cekik Dengan Pelanggan

Kenapa Tindakan Mp Amanah Semalam Tidak Selari Dengan Mp Pakatan Harapan Di Dewan Rakyat

Teknik Jimat Sabun Cuci Pinggan

Tutorial 6 Langkah Mudah Meletakkan Gambar Dari Instagram Dalam Entri Blog

Maradona Disemadikan Di Perkuburan Bella Vista Buenos Aires