No Money No Religion Tabligh Berpecah Dua Tiga Sheikul Perang Dengan Ak47 Tikam Dengan Pisau
This post may be of note for Muslim readers.
For the non Muslim readers if at all, you might find this interesting to note how religion always (always times 10) divides and breaks up the human race. This is applicable to all religions. However since the Tabligh has a sizeable presence here in Malaysia, this may be relevant to knowing your neighbours.
Each year or every two years there are THREE great congregations of Muslims at the THREE MAIN Tabligh centers in Nizamuddin (Delhi), at Tongi in Bangladesh and in Raiwind in Pakistan. Sometimes TWO MILLION Tablighis may congregate at Tongi, making it the largest "pilgrimage site" after Mecca in Saudi Arabia.
Do read my conclusion. It is all about how to operate a "franchise" and too much decentralisation.
Here is some news about the Tabligh Jamaat or TJ. This is a religious 'cult' that started in India in the 1900s and has spread all over the world (except the Arab countries and Iran).
Despite having over 80 million followers around the world there is hardly any Arab or Iranian / Persian in this cult group. Most of the members are of Indo-Pak-Bangla ethnicity, with a smattering of Malays, Indonesians, Mindanaos and the odd Mat Salleh.
The founding philosophy of the Tabligh was to eschew the worldy life and they were also apolitical. (There is a theory - click here - that the British colonial power "fostered" the Tabligh in India in the early 1900s to subdue rising militant and anti British sentiment among the Muslims in north India). Well not anymore. By 2018 the TJ was quite irreconcilably split up into two or maybe three factions. The reason has been mundane worldly issues like money and power.
Here are some main Press clips.
2011 - many Tablighis not aware of seven day coup at Raiwind Pakistan Qutbuddin, Haji Abdul Wahhab’s adopted son attempted coup to install himself as Ameerarmed with AK47 assault rifles on armoured vehiclestormed the grounds and took control for a weekJune 2016 Nizamuddin Delhi, extremely serious rift, one group attacked their opponents with lethal weapons following an argument over a prayer mat. 15 people were reportedly injured, police had to calm things down
In London - several incidents of brawling
elders assaulted each other in London Markaz in Masjid Ilyas and Abbey Mills Mosquepolice were called 13 times four people were arrested on different occasions
News item no 1. Tabligh splits into two or three, from Dawn newspaper, Pakistan (Feb 2018).
Tablighi Jamaat (TJ), worldwide movement attracts hundreds of thousands to Nizamuddin (Delhi), Tongi (Bangla), Raiwind (P'stan)
TJ observes Deobandi school bitter verbal clashes with rival Deobandi organisations sheltered extremists in aftermath of 9/11
emerging internal struggle
THE BIG DIVIDE
conflict out into open in UK where TJ has significant baseDec 2017 police called in repeatedly to separate brawling adherents two camps claimed Masjid-i-Ilyas schism has grown and taken on international dimensions.
One side of conflict originates from Nizamuddin — Delhifollowers of Maulana Saad Kandhalvi, Ameer of TJ shura (advisory council)Saad Kandhalvi great-grandson of Maulana Muhammad Ilyas founder of TJSaad revered by many in Tablighi circles
other camp in Raiwind, Pakistan rebel campHaji Abdul Wahab set up 13-member advisory councilWahab is ameer of Raiwind, key figure in intn'l advisory councilRaiwind was largest gathering but overtaken by Tongi in Bangla
Differences between two camps simmering for long time Currently two TJs operating in London and UK
One adheres to Maulana Saad Kandhalvi in Delhithe other follows Wahab's Aalami Shura in Raiwind
Maulana Saad accused of “unacceptable” new interpretations of Sunnah preference for Muntakhab Ahadith by Muhammad Yusuf — his grandfatheragainst Fazail-e-Amaal by Maulana Zakariya as core reading material introduced new mannerism to greet newcomers daawa, taaleem, istaqbal these issues grew ever-more contentious over time
Nov 2015 senior members decided to reconstitute world shura councilnamed 13 members to shura council including Maulana Saad, Haji Abdul Wahab, ameer of Raiwind resolved to continue shura system only - negated ameer or leader Maulana Saad rejected these resolutions
Maulana Saad heard saying : “I am ameer ... if you do not agree, go to hell.”due to these utterances opponents consider Saad unfit for ameer
[Maulana] Saad is ameer since 20 years agoThis new Shura is bogus, not a reality, no basis Tabligh Markaz has always been Markaz Nizamuddin, New DelhiNow Tabligh is divided into two camps
June 2016 in Nizamuddin, rift took extremely serious turn when one group of supporters attacked their opponents with lethal weapons following an argument over a prayer mat. Some 15 people were reportedly injured, and the police had to be brought in to calm things down.
In the face of death threats senior members left Nizamuddin, Delhi moved to Bhopal to escape the conflict at Nizamuddin
ethnicity of rival factions and followersGujaratis versus Maharashtris
Dec 2016, Darul Uloom Deoband madrassa issued fatwa
“Due to lack of knowledge, [Maulana Saad] has strayed from majority, which is undoubtedly the path of deviation,” the Darul Uloom statement said.
Sept 2017 two reps of Aalmi Shura went to UK to gather signatures for Aalmi ShuraThis visit divided Tabligh UK on basis of nationalities / countries of origin
Gujaratis and Pakistanis sided with RaiwindBangladeshis stood behind Maulana Saad
Blackburn, Leicester, Glasgow — loyal to RaiwindBirmingham, Bristol, Dewsbury — solidly behind DelhiDec 2017 disturbances in shura meeting at Masjid-i-Ilyas, London
physical brawl between rival factions inside Masjid Ilyas
News item no. 2
LONDON: Tablighi Jamaat split into two one faction following Raiwind Markaz other faction following Moulana Saad of Nizam-ud-Din in Indiadifferences started in 2015 with new committee for intnl congregations
several incidents of brawling occurred
elders assaulted each other in London Markaz
in Masjid Ilyas and Abbey Mills Mosquepolice were called 13 times four people were arrested on different occasions
3. Here is the 3rd news item
TABLIGHI JAMAAT SHAITAANI SPLIT
April 13, 2018
TWO BELLIGERENT FACTIONS, THE DEBACLE, THE SHAITAANIYAT
two mutually hostile Tablighi Jamaat factions
No one knows solution for diseaseculminated in ruinous split of Tabligh Jamaat
prelude for demise of Tabligh split will not be healedchasm will incrementally widen
real causes for humiliating crisis of Tabligh are:
Belief that Tabligh sole repository of SalvationColossal waste of wealthshamelessly waste millions of dollars on Ijtimas which have assumed carnival proportionsthey squander so much wealth like shaitaan
Ijtimas are commercialised
Ijtima transformed into mall by hundreds of stalls
monetary objective of primary importance
shenanigans behind commercial facade of Tabligh Jamaat
Raiwand, Pakistan became mini-stateTablighis not aware of seven day coup in 2011 at Raiwind markaz Qutbuddin, Haji Abdul Wahhab’s adopted son attempted a coup to install himself as Ameerarmed with AK47 assault rifles on armoured vehiclestormed the grounds and took control for a week
Tablighis speak ill of those who do not participate in their programmesWithout slightest fear for Allah Ta’ala speak ill of Heirs of Rasul like Maulana Ashraf Thanvi, Maulana Masihullah
Tablighis employ goondagerry (thuggery) to prevent deeni projects
ulema in a village in India planned to build non tabligh Masjid
Tablighi goondas (thugs) threatened to kill him
People complaining about goonda (thugs) tactics of Tabligh
goonda thug violence at Nizaamuddin markaz
also in Bangladesh markaz
Jamaat not hesitated to use vulgar abuse, violence
reports from all over the world of this shaitaaniyat of Tablighi Jamaat
My conclusion :
The Catholic Church is the world expert at operating a religious franchise. Few non Catholics know that the Vatican in Rome determines the topic for the Sunday sermon THROUGHT the tens of thousands of Catholic Churches all over the world. It is centralised control.
The original Tabligh ijtima or world congregation was held at its Markaz Nizamuddin in Delhi. Then the Tabligh allowed ijtema to be held in Bangladesh, Pakistan, the United Kingdom and other places around the world including in Malaysia (at the Sri Petaling Mosque near Bukit Jalil).
Due to the huge population of Muslims in Pakistan and Bangladesh, the markaz in these places began to have a life of their own which required local management expertise. Hence in Raiwind in Pakistan and Tongi in Bangladesh their local shura councils became very powerful.
Soon they were able to question and criticise the HQ in Delhi. This is exactly what has happened. The Pakistan guys disagreed with the Delhi guys about some rituals and practises.
There were actually other reasons - money.
As the news report suggests huge amounts of money became involved, from donors, from businesses that operate at these markaz locations (to take advantage of the crowds) etc. Their vision became 'hazed over' by money.
The rift blew up and then spread to the Tabligh in the UK which is now split in its "doctrinal loyalty" to either Pakistan or Delhi.
Bangladesh is reported to be loyal to Delhi but late last year (2018) the Bangladeshi guys refused to allow the Maulana Saad Khandlavi from Delhi (the present ameer and grandson of the founder of Tabligh) from entering their markaz or centre in Bangladesh. That is very serious.
Folks, religion is not based on science, evidence or logic. All religions. It is just blind faith. Either you believe or you dont believe. Hence they cannot prove their positions. When you cannot prove your position how on Allah's good earth can you offer solutions for the human race?
As opposed to the Quran. The Quran requires logic and evidence. You must prove your position.
Haatu burhanukum inkuntum sadiqeen :
Posted by Syed Akbar Ali
Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :