Is Sosma A Detention Without Trial Law




I refer to the Malaysiakini article War on terror: Rule of law is paramount.According to the writer, and like many writing on Sosma since the LTTE arrests, Sosma is a law that allows for detention without trial. This is one where Sosma has been much maligned
Sosma allows for a person to be detained for security offences for up to 28 days, after the initial 24 hours following the arrest. But this is for the purpose of investigation
This is clearly stated in section 4(5) of Sosma. This makes an arrest and detention under Sosma substantially different from an arrest and detention of a person under section 73(1) of the repealed Internal Securities Act 1960 (ISA)

Such detention under Sosma is generally referred to as detention pending investigation, unlike a detention under ISA
In other jurisdictions, it is called pre-charge detention. It is the period that a person can be detained by the police between being arrested and being either charged with a criminal offence or released
Pre-charge detentions primarily serve to achieve the purpose of an investigation, namely to secure sufficient admissible evidence for use in criminal proceedings
A reading of the Hansard supports the legislative intent of section 4(5) of Sosma. At the second reading of the bill, this was what the then prime minister said:“Fasal 4 rang undang-undang baru ini menyentuh tentang kuasa penangkapan dan penahanan. Di bawah Fasal ini, polis mempunyai kuasa khas untuk menangkap dan menahan mana-mana orang yang polis mempunyai sebab untuk mempercayai bahawa orang itu terlibat dengan kesalahan keselamatan. Perlu ditekankan di sini bahawa kuasa penangkapan dan penahanan ini adalah untuk tujuan penyiasatan semata-mata.”Much that one may wish to malign Sosma, it is what detention under Sosma is all about
Why 28 days? It is twice higher than the total period of 14-day detention allowed under the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC)
It might have been ‘inspired’ by the same period of detention under the UK’s legislation which allows for pre-charge detention of terrorist suspects for up to 28 days without charge
Mind you, in 2008, the UK government even attempted to further extend this period to 42 days but was eventually unsuccessful (the provisions of the bill extending pre-charge detention, which was passed by the House of Commons, were defeated in the House of Lords by a majority of 309 votes to 118)
It is said that terrorism cases require longer periods of pre-charge detention because of the complexity of investigating terrorism cases, the difficulty in obtaining admissible evidence and the importance of protecting the public from terrorist attacks
The complexity of terrorism cases includes the use of encrypted data; voluminous quantities of material; data from cellular telephones; multiple false identities; forensic science delays; difficulties when large numbers of suspects are held together; and the cumulative impact of all the above issues
But whether it is 14 days or 28 days, much debate has, in fact, gone into this period of detention
It is one that governments across the world have had to grapple with. It is about achieving “the appropriate balance between the measures necessary to deal with the very real threat to national security posed by terrorism and the need to avoid diminishing the civil and human rights of the population.” It is a continuing struggle that any government will have to strike between its “primary responsibility to ensure the safety of its citizens, which must include looking at what powers the law enforcement agencies may need in future instead of waiting until current powers have been proved inadequate” and “the scale and nature of the terrorist threat and the increasing complexity of cases.”And sadly perhaps, there is no clear solution
Human rights groups and non-governmental persons are rightly concerned with the rule of law. But again, much that one may wish to disagree, investigations into security and terrorism offences call for a separate power of arrest and detention from the normal procedural law, which in Malaysia is contained in the CPC
This special power has been described as one of the most important powers that should be made available to the police. The exercise of such power can “have both a disruptive and preventative impact on any terrorist plans that may be in process.”Having said this, it does not mean that the arrest and detention under Sosma are not objectionable
The main objection is that Sosma, unlike the UK legislation and the CPC, does not provide for a judicial authority – like a magistrate – to be satisfied that an extension to the period of detention is necessary
In 1988, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that a detention is a breach of Article 5(3) of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) unless the detention was judicially authorised
As such, this is one of many areas where reform to Sosma is necessary. Like the UK legislation, a judicial authority should be satisfied that an extended detention is necessary to:• obtain or preserve relevant evidence;• permit the completion of an examination or analysis of any relevant matter with a view to obtaining evidence; and• the investigation connected with the detention is being conducted diligently and expeditiously
Be that as it may, Sosma is not a law that allows for detention without trial. Ask any prosecutor or criminal lawyer - can a trial be held within 28 days of arrest and detention
No way
Can the police extend the detention beyond the 28 days? I would say no way as well, despite some views that the detention can be renewed indefinitely
Again, the legislative intent of Sosma can be seen in the Hansard, where the then prime minister said:“[D]alam jangka masa yang tidak lebih daripada tamatnya tempoh tahanan [28 hari], pegawai polis yang menjalankan siasatan itu perlu menghantar kertas siasatan kepada pendakwa raya di mana beliau hendaklah membuat keputusan sama ada mendakwa tertuduh di mahkamah atau membebaskannya. Ini bererti tidak akan ada tahanan selepas tempoh 28 hari.”What is feared is not the renewed detention under Sosma but another detention under different legislation, namely the Preventive of Terrorism Act 2015 (Pota) or the Prevention of Crime Act 1959 (Poca) which allows for detention for up to 60 days
A detention after Sosma under Pota or Poca is what lawyers have referred to as “chain remand”
Chain remand in "New Malaysia"? It shouldn’t happen. - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2019/10/is-sosma-detention-without-trial-law.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Mus

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Abolish Detention Without Trial Respect Right To Fair Trial

Abolish Detention Without Trial Respect Right To Fair Trial

papar berkaitan - pada 28/10/2019 - jumlah : 104 hits
On the occasion of Oct 27 the anniversary of Operation Lallang in 1987 when about 106 persons were arrested and detained under a draconian detention without trial law we the 16 undersigned organisations and groups call on Malaysia to abolis...
Five Arrested Over Alleged Ltte Links To Challenge Sosma Detention

Five Arrested Over Alleged Ltte Links To Challenge Sosma Detention

papar berkaitan - pada 20/10/2019 - jumlah : 123 hits
KUALA LUMPUR Lawyers will be filing habeas corpus applications on behalf of five men who were detained under the Security Offences Act over alleged links to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam Lawyer Ramkarpal Singh confirmed that they wou...
Ltte Linked Suspects File Challenge Against Sosma Detention

Ltte Linked Suspects File Challenge Against Sosma Detention

papar berkaitan - pada 22/10/2019 - jumlah : 164 hits
Five of 12 suspects recently arrested over alleged involvement in activities linked to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam terror group have filed habeas corpus applications today to secure their immediate release DAP Legal Bureau chairper...
Lawyers For Liberty Calls On Gov T To Abolish Sosma Without Delay

Lawyers For Liberty Calls On Gov T To Abolish Sosma Without Delay

papar berkaitan - pada 17/10/2019 - jumlah : 109 hits
Lawyers for Liberty has raised its concern over the government s announcement that the controversial Security Offences Act 2012 will not be abolished but instead amended Its director Melissa Sasidaran said the government needed no reminder ...
Najib 1mdb Trial Day 23 Ex Ceo Agrees Pm S Far Reaching Powers In 1mdb Not Uncommon

Najib 1mdb Trial Day 23 Ex Ceo Agrees Pm S Far Reaching Powers In 1mdb Not Uncommon

papar berkaitan - pada 17/10/2019 - jumlah : 152 hits
The criminal trial of former prime minister Najib Abdul Razak involving the alleged abuse of power and money laundering of 1MDB funds enters its 23rd day today at the High Court in Kuala Lumpur Malaysiakini brings you live reports of the pr...
Najib 1mdb Trial Day 24 Shahrol S Testimony Continues With 45pct Of Questions Left

Najib 1mdb Trial Day 24 Shahrol S Testimony Continues With 45pct Of Questions Left

papar berkaitan - pada 21/10/2019 - jumlah : 140 hits
The criminal trial of former prime minister Najib Abdul Razak involving the alleged abuse of power and money laundering of 1MDB funds enters its 24th day today at the High Court in Kuala Lumpur Malaysiakini brings you live reports of the pr...
Najib 1mdb Trial Day 24 Proceedings Adjourn Early For Shafee S Eye Check Up

Najib 1mdb Trial Day 24 Proceedings Adjourn Early For Shafee S Eye Check Up

papar berkaitan - pada 22/10/2019 - jumlah : 149 hits
The criminal trial of former prime minister Najib Abdul Razak involving the alleged abuse of power and money laundering of 1MDB funds enters its 24th day today at the High Court in Kuala Lumpur Malaysiakini brings you live reports of the pr...
Najib 1mdb Trial Day 22 Jho Low A Master Manipulator Shahrol Concurs With Najib S Ex Aide

Najib 1mdb Trial Day 22 Jho Low A Master Manipulator Shahrol Concurs With Najib S Ex Aide

papar berkaitan - pada 17/10/2019 - jumlah : 132 hits
The criminal trial of former prime minister Najib Abdul Razak involving the alleged abuse of power and money laundering of 1MDB funds enters its 22nd day today at the High Court in Kuala Lumpur Malaysiakini brings you live reports of the pr...
Forced To Defer Najib S 1mdb Trial For Parliament Judge Says This Is Last Time

Forced To Defer Najib S 1mdb Trial For Parliament Judge Says This Is Last Time

papar berkaitan - pada 16/10/2019 - jumlah : 156 hits
Provided by Malay Mail Sdn Bhd Datuk Seri Najib Razak is pictured at the Parliament lobby October 15 2019 Picture by Ahmad ZamzahuriKUALA LUMPUR Oct 15 The hearing for Datuk Seri Najib Razak s 1Malaysia Development Berhad corruption trial s...
Video Kereta Jep Sepahtu Kena Tarik Ini Alasan Paling Kelakar Abad Ini

Untung Jangka Pendek Sakit Jangka Panjang Jika Umno Terima Jawatan Tpm Kata Penganalisis

Expert Advice How To Improve Remote Education Collaboration

Netflix Bets Big On Aspirational And Diverse Anime Adding Five Major Projects

Suami Isteri Bergaduh Tinggalkan Bayi Bersendirian Di Rumah Sehingga Mati Kelaparan

8 Benefits Of Bigpay Card Better Banking Alternative

The Agong S Emergency Declaration Powers A Look At Discretion Advice And History From A Legal Perspective

Tak Lama Lagi Jatuh Lah



Biodata Dolla Kumpulan Ala Blackpink Penyanyi Dolla Make You Wanna

Kisah Sistem Kasta India Yang Kenakan Cukai Tutup Dada

Apa Yang Diajarkan Dalam Sistem Sekolah Kebangsaan Korea Utara

7 Telefon Mudah Alih Terawal Di Dunia

Biodata Penyanyi Noraniza Idris Peserta Gegar Vaganza Musim 7 GV7 2020


Drama 5ji Kara 9ji Made

Fresh Order

Maulid Nabi Bagi Pemilik Nama Muhammad Dan Ahmad Boleh Makan Soto Gratis Di Warung Ini Buruan

Raja Tega Kakek Ini Ditelantarkan Anaknya Dan Tak Makan Selama 4 Hari

Wajar Pemimpin Ambil Yang Jernih

Apa Salahnya Kalau Mahyuddin Pm Pertama Kerajaan Perpaduan