Guan Eng S Perkasa Suit Broke The Law Says Dissenting Judge


 
Federal Court judge Abdul Rahman Sebli dissented in the court’s 2-1 verdict to allow Lim Guan Eng’s appeal against Malay rights group Perkasa for labelling him a traitor.PUTRAJAYA: A Federal Court judge has held that a defamation suit brought by former Penang chief minister Lim Guan Eng had breached the law and was doomed to fail.
Judge Abdul Rahman Sebli, in a dissenting judgement against the court’s majority verdict, said the suit should have been dismissed.
He said Lim’s writ and statement of claim, including all cause papers were illegal and ought to be disregarded as Lim had not used a government lawyer or sought sanction to engage a private lawyer.
“This court being the apex court, cannot turn a blind eye on the breach of the law by the appellant (Lim). It is a serious transgression of the law that has the effect of nullifying the whole action filed by the appellant,” he said in his dissenting judgment.
However, Lim’s suit was upheld by two other judges on the bench, who said Lim had brought the suit in his private capacity and he was not bound by the provisions of the Government Proceedings Act.
Judges Nallini Pathmanathan and Harmindar Singh Dhalial upheld a High Court judgement to award damages of RM150,000. Lim had sued the Malay rights group Perkasa and two newspaper publishers over a statement describing Lim as a traitor for exposing national secrets to Singapore.
Judge Abdul Rahman, dissenting, said the Court of Appeal had held that Lim had sued in his official capacity and not in his personal capacity but Lim did not appeal to the Federal Court on this finding.
Rahman said the Government Proceedings Act required Lim to be represented by a government legal officer and not by a private law practitioner of his choice.
“This is the point of law raised by learned counsel for the respondents which I think has merit and must be decided in their favour.”
He said the Act also gave the option to Lim to engage a private lawyer to represent him, subject to the state legal adviser issuing a licence to the counsel, but no explanation was given as to why this was not done.
“It would have been easy for the appellant (Lim) to obtain the fiat from the state legal adviser of Penang, given his position as the chief minister of the state,” he said.
Harmindar, who delivered the majority verdict, said in practice, it would be beneficial for the public officer (Lim) to be represented by legal officers as all expenses would be settled by the government.
He said it was not open to Perkasa and the publishers to challenge the arrangement and decide for Lim as to who should represent him.
Yesterday’s ruling restored the findings of the High Court which had ordered Perkasa and its president, Ibrahim Ali, to pay RM150,000 in damages to Lim.
The New Straits Times and Utusan Melayu were also found liable by the High Court and each paid RM200,000. They did not appeal.
All the defendants were sued after the statement was published on Perkasa’s website which implied that Lim was endangering national security by exposing the country’s secrets to Singapore. - FMT


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2021/02/guan-engs-perkasa-suit-broke-law-says.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Mu

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Why The Peculiar Facts In Guan Eng S Case Entitled Him To Sue Perkasa

Why The Peculiar Facts In Guan Eng S Case Entitled Him To Sue Perkasa

papar berkaitan - pada 4/3/2021 - jumlah : 96 hits
I refer to the commentary in Malaysiakini dated March 1 2021 titled Why Guan Eng shouldn t have been allowed to sue Perkasa and feel various issues raised therein necessitate a response which I shall attempt here The authors of the said art...
Hearing To Assess Damages For Guan Eng Over Defamation Suit Against Blogger Raja Petra On April 14

Hearing To Assess Damages For Guan Eng Over Defamation Suit Against Blogger Raja Petra On April 14

papar berkaitan - pada 22/2/2021 - jumlah : 74 hits
14th April 2021 will be Raja Petra Kamarudin s 48th wedding anniversary The High Court has set April 14 for hearing to assess the quantum of damages for former Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng in his defamation suit against blogger Raja Petra ...
Lim Guan Eng Wins Appeal To Reinstate Award For Damages For Defamation By Perkasa

Lim Guan Eng Wins Appeal To Reinstate Award For Damages For Defamation By Perkasa

papar berkaitan - pada 26/2/2021 - jumlah : 56 hits
PUTRAJAYA The Federal Court has reinstated the High Court s decision ordering Pertubuhan Pribumi Perkasa Malaysia and its president Datuk Ibrahim Ali to pay RM150 000 in damages to former Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng for defamation In...
Mahathir 4 Others Allowed Into Suit Over Agong S Previous Emergency Decision

Mahathir 4 Others Allowed Into Suit Over Agong S Previous Emergency Decision

papar berkaitan - pada 18/2/2021 - jumlah : 192 hits
Former prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad and four other Pejuang members succeeded in being added as parties in legal action over the Yang di Pertuan Agong s earlier decision to refuse the emergency proclamation last year Several lawyers as...
Perkasa Dan Ibrahim Diarah Bayar Ganti Rugi Rm150 000 Kepada Guan Eng

Perkasa Dan Ibrahim Diarah Bayar Ganti Rugi Rm150 000 Kepada Guan Eng

papar berkaitan - pada 26/2/2021 - jumlah : 42 hits
February 26 2021 Mahkamah Persekutuan mengarahkan Pertubuhan Pribumi Perkasa Malaysia dan Presidennya Datuk Ibrahim Ali untuk membayar ganti rugi RM150 000 kepada bekas ketua menteri Pulau Pinang Lim Guan Eng berhubung kenyataan fitnah kump...
Banks Are The Worst During A Crisis Says Airasia Boss

Banks Are The Worst During A Crisis Says Airasia Boss

papar berkaitan - pada 6/3/2021 - jumlah : 89 hits
AirAsia boss Tony Fernandes said under the old style banking relationships were built up to help companies in crisis PETALING JAYA AirAsia boss Tony Fernandes has criticised the banking industry stating banks are the worst to deal with duri...
Stop The Backward Class Label In Schools Says Education Minister

Stop The Backward Class Label In Schools Says Education Minister

papar berkaitan - pada 6/3/2021 - jumlah : 183 hits
Education minister Radzi Jidin says the ministry s plan now is to produce students who grow up being confident in their own strengths PUTRAJAYA The classification of students according to their academic performance will have a psychological...
Didiktv Case Shows Need For Law On Cyberbullying Says Minister

Didiktv Case Shows Need For Law On Cyberbullying Says Minister

papar berkaitan - pada 21/2/2021 - jumlah : 80 hits
Saifuddin Abdullah says both the teacher and the education ministry should not be criticised over the viral video KUANTAN Criticism and mocking of a teacher s televised science lesson in English amounts to cyberbullying communications and m...
Appointing The Public As Protection Officers Among Amendments To Atipsom Says Social Welfare Dept Division Director

Appointing The Public As Protection Officers Among Amendments To Atipsom Says Social Welfare Dept Division Director

papar berkaitan - pada 25/2/2021 - jumlah : 120 hits
Ahmad Hashim Selamat said the amendment would also seek to improve the role of the Women Family and Community Development Minister and the operation of shelters for victims of human trafficking Thomson Reuters Foundation picKUALA LUMPUR Feb...
Polis Buru Pelakon Penerbit Video Judi Sempena Hari Raya

Abang Sanggup Basah Kuyup Redah Hujan Dukung Adik Balik Sekolah

Itu Dbkl You Jangan Risaulah Saya Sudah Settle Sama Dbkl

Warisan Bakal Bergabung Dengan Pakatan Harapan

Lirik Thank You Allah Alyah Feat Cat Farish Ustaz Haris

Kisah Urban Legend Misteri Dan Asal Usul Orang Minyak

Mee Kari Chinese Style Memang Power Sambalnya Yang Buat Makan Bertambah

Lirik Beriku Waktu Azmi Saat



Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Ayat Dari Langit Astro Citra

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Ayat Dari Langit Astro Citra

Ini Sebab Mengapa Kereta F1 Tidak Menggunakan Kokpit Tertutup

Mengapakah Orang Miskin Sukar Keluar dari Perangkap Kemiskinan

5 Jalan Raya Paling Banyak Lorong Di Dunia


5 Tantangan Buka Toko Baru Di Marketplace Kalau Bisa Taklukkan Untung Pun Berdatangan

Selamat Nagita Slavina Hamil Anak Kedua Doa Rafathar Ingin Punya Adik Akhirnya Terkabul

Kisah Saya 2017 Sehingga 2019

India Bakal Jadi Negara Asia Pertama Menghantar Angkasawan Ke Marikh

Legasi Zack Snyder Dalam Zack Snyder S Army Of The Dead

I Wanna Travel Again