Dap Should Give Us A List Of People It Will Not Work With


Like nothing I've ever known
But the more that I hear
Forget about long-range plans
'Cause this man's got his own
– Never say never again (James Bond soundtrack)
When Lim Guan Eng says that the DAP would not work with Umno and Bersatu president Muhyiddin Yassin because “we can’t accept them using race and religion to divide the people”, it is the kind of craven political rhetoric that furthers toxic partisan discourse.
The DAP should just draw up a list of people they are not willing to work with. This way we can keep track of all the backtracking they will eventually do, to “Save Malaysia”. 
The reality is that the DAP has never had a problem working with hegemons which use race and religion to further political agendas.
Keep in mind that Bersatu, a creation of Dr Mahathir Mohamad, said that the Malay polity needed a“Malay” only party to fight for their “rights”, and the various mandarins of DAPS supported this idea that the rural Malay heartland needed a Malay only party like Bersatu to get on the “ubah” bandwagon.
Lim Kit Siang admitted that there was no Malay leader in Harapan who could get the rural Malay vote. He said Pakatan Harapan lacks any personality capable of convincing rural Malay voters to support the pact, aside from Mahathir. 
“If Mahathir cannot help create a wave of change among the rural Malay voters for the 14GE in the remaining 100 days, then no other political leader could accomplish this ‘Mission Impossible'," Kit Siang had said before that general election. 

This, of course, must have been hard for Anwar Ibrahim to hear, considering that the reason why there was a viable opposition which controlled two major economic states (among others) was because of the moves he made, post-Umno.
As late as June of this year, when the fracas about succession came into play (again), the old maverick once again took advantage of the optics of the agitation among DAP, Amanah and PKR to profit politically from the question of succession – “Mereka sudah lama menjadi parti pembangkang. Mereka cuba menang pada 2008 dan 2013 sebelum saya menyertai mereka, tetapi mereka kalah dan tidak boleh menang. Jadi, pada PRU14 saya sertai mereka.
“Mereka tahu mereka perlukan undi Melayu untuk menang, dan mereka fikir saya boleh bawa undi Melayu kerana parti utama ialah parti Melayu dan yang lain parti  pelbagai kaum. Melayu tidak akan sokong parti majmuk.” 
In November of last year, DAP strategist and then deputy defence minister, Liew Chin Tong, said this: “Do we realise that, in reality, DAP needs Bersatu and Bersatu needs DAP to keep Pakatan Harapan together and succeed in rebuilding Malaysia? Harapan is a coalition of four parties — that is DAP, Bersatu, PKR and Amanah. Only through unity and cooperation of all component parties can we represent all layers of society.” 
So, since race and religion by definition divide the people, there is absolutely no logic in Guan Eng claiming that DAP cannot work with Umno and Bersatu because of race and religion. Hence, the only reason why they cannot work with these parties is the personalities involved.

Guan Eng said the DAP can never work with "… an Umno that is under the leadership of (Umno president) Ahmad Zahid Hamidi and (Pekan MP) Najib Abdul Razak. Absolutely not.” So is the DAP head honcho saying that it would work with Umno if those personalities were not involved with Umno?
This would make the rationale of not working with Umno because it uses race and religion to divide the people, moot, right? This would also mean that working with Umno personalities that are not “tainted” would be acceptable to the DAP?
Indeed personality politics is what political operatives use to deflect from the real issue. It is not that the DAP cannot work with political hegemons who use race and religion, [it has ] but because the DAP would rather focus on personalities which it thinks would galvanise its base.
Racial and religious issues that divide the country are systemic. The same goes for corruption. It is pointless targeting individuals, although it has political advantages. The opposition, at least the non-Malay opposition, has claimed that the issues are systemic and the major part of the problem is race-based political hegemons that seek to sustain such systems. 
Since the opposition has demonstrated that it really does not want to ubah the system, it makes sense to focus on personalities.
Remember Liew’s analysis of Muhyiddin in his essays "The strange case of Muhyiddin Yassin" and "DAP never failed you each time you asked for help, Muhyiddin".
Please refer to them again. In those essays, you will understand the realpolitik of race and religion and understand how the current prime minister wanted to get to know the DAP better, since the race-based political party and the multi-racial DAP would now be working together.
Read those articles and you will discover that, ultimately, the problem was not with the DAP but rather the power struggle within the Malay political establishment. 

From Liew’s analysis, what we see was a dejected Malay leader who believed he was passed over by the Malay establishment after years of faithful service.
He was then co-opted by other Malay political opportunists to be the figurehead of a coup that would give him the premiership he believed was owed to him. And what does the Malay political establishment do when they need a scapegoat? They always go back to the reliable whipping boy the DAP.
The fact is that Bersatu has always had to view the DAP with a certain amount of contempt because, for years, successive Mahathir-led governments had to paint the DAP as the bogeyman of Malay politics.
How many times have I pointed out that the far-right and most voters of race-based politics have no problems with the dissonance in the narratives they are peddling and consuming? This means that the DAP can be the running dogs of Malay power structures and, at the same time, the power behind the throne.
Why? Because they know the DAP, for whatever reasons - pragmatism, power hungriness or just good old fashion masochism - will always try to link up with Malay power structures because, for decades, it did not build a Malay base of its own using Umno as means of distraction while consolidating power in the non-Malay community and demonising the MCA.
From gathering in mosques and propping up religious operatives like Mujahid Yusof Rawa, the DAP has exhausted resources and political capital by attempting to court the Malay vote in the most craven of ways. 
The DAP chose the quick way of pandering, instead of coming up with a plan to tackle Malay B40 issues, which could be formed into a greater multi-racial needs-based narrative, all the while supported by a base that elevated leaders to a cult-like status. Things, of course, are slowly changing now.
The DAP still has not figured out that folks who vote for them want them to be honest brokers of middle-ground politics and, to the best of their ability, be the voice for secularism and egalitarianism in an ethnotheocracy for as long as possible.

S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy. A retired barrister-at-law, he hopes young people will assume the mantle of leadership – if there is to be any hope for this country. - Mkini

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :


Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Dap Will Work With Umno But Not If Led By Zahid Or Najib

Dap Will Work With Umno But Not If Led By Zahid Or Najib

papar berkaitan - pada 26/9/2020 - jumlah : 145 hits
DAP secretary general Lim Guan Eng said the party will not work with Umno as long as it remains under the leadership of current president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi and his predecessor former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak While a...
18 Elegant Mediterranean Home Office Designs That Will Give You Comfort As You Work

18 Elegant Mediterranean Home Office Designs That Will Give You Comfort As You Work

papar berkaitan - pada 3/10/2020 - jumlah : 197 hits
Having a home office has never been as important as it is during these trying times With the surge of a global pandemic a lot of people have been forced or have been given the The post appeared first on
Bn And Gps Failed The People Not Us Says Dap Rep

Bn And Gps Failed The People Not Us Says Dap Rep

papar berkaitan - pada 19/9/2020 - jumlah : 119 hits
Bukit Assek politicians Irene Chang and Joseph Chieng have crossed swords KUCHING A Sarawak DAP assemblyman has urged the SUPP to look at all the mess created by BN or GPS before accusing Pakatan Harapan of failing the people Irene Chang th...
What Will Happen If Acid Reflux Is Not Treated

What Will Happen If Acid Reflux Is Not Treated

papar berkaitan - pada 25/9/2020 - jumlah : 139 hits
It is said to normally result once you bend over or lift a whopping object If youre willing to try taking a little advice making a couple changes then you can definitely cure heartburn or acid reflux but merely understand that there is not ...
Rci On Judicial Misconduct Should Also Cover Ph S Time Says Ex Dap Man

Rci On Judicial Misconduct Should Also Cover Ph S Time Says Ex Dap Man

papar berkaitan - pada 17/9/2020 - jumlah : 110 hits
Tunku Abdul Aziz Ibrahim says retired chief justice Richard Malanjum s open support for Warisan raised serious doubts about the judiciary s independence PETALING JAYA Tunku Abdul Aziz Ibrahim a former vice chairman of Transparency Internati...
Gps Firmly With Muhyiddin Pas Not Siding Anwar

Gps Firmly With Muhyiddin Pas Not Siding Anwar

papar berkaitan - pada 23/9/2020 - jumlah : 70 hits
Gabungan Parti Sarawak is very firm in its support for Muhyiddin Yassin to remain as prime minister said Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu secretary general Alexander Nanta Linggi Nanta told Malaysiakini that he had conferred with GPS and PBB...
Zahid Umno Will Not Stop Its Mps From Supporting Anwar For Pm

Zahid Umno Will Not Stop Its Mps From Supporting Anwar For Pm

papar berkaitan - pada 24/9/2020 - jumlah : 137 hits
Umno will not stop its MPs from backing PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim as prime minister says Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi The Umno president said he was informed that some Umno and Barisan Nasional MPs had expressed their support ...
Warisan Won T Work With Umno Says Darell Leiking

Warisan Won T Work With Umno Says Darell Leiking

papar berkaitan - pada 25/9/2020 - jumlah : 93 hits
Darell Leiking said Warisan will never join forces with Umno following a claim that many of the peninsula based party s MPs and those from Barisan Nasional were backing Anwar Ibrahim to form a new government There is a possibility of Umno l...
Annuar Musa Believes Sabah People Will Vote For Change

Annuar Musa Believes Sabah People Will Vote For Change

papar berkaitan - pada 18/9/2020 - jumlah : 128 hits
SABAH POLLS BN secretary general Annuar Musa is confident that the people of Sabah would vote for a change of state government for the sake of a better economic future We can see the Sabah economy is in a worrying state while at the nationa...
Cara Mohon I Sinar Kwsp Secara Online

Injil Berusia 1500th Ditemukan Isinya Mengemparkan Dunia

Apa Rahsia Panjang Umur Sampai 100 Tahun Atok Ini Jawab Dia Merokok Setiap Hari

Syekh Ali Jaber Ditikam

Dalam Iklan Nampak Macam Mata Dewi Bila Pakai Sendiri Mata Nampak Juling

Beban Kerajaan Membantu Rakyat Berkurangan Apabila Rakyat Pilih Guna Duit Sendiri Kwsp Termakan Cakap Najib

Kanak Kanak 7 Tahun Putus Kepala Gara Gara Pemandu Mabuk

Ogah Ditemani Ambil Buah Nangka Halim Fauzan Tewas Usai Jatuh Terpeleset

Resepi Kerepek Bayam Brazil Paling Rangup dan Tahan lama

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Isteri Misteri TV3

Kisah Penyokong Flat Earth Cari Penghujung Bumi

Mengapa Lelaki Lebih Sukakan Wanita Bermata Besar

Kenapa Babi Sering Dijadikan Bentuk Tabung Duit

15 Fantastic Christmas Banner Ideas You Will Want In Your Home

House At Glenhill Saujana By Seshan Design In Shah Alam Malaysia

1 315 Kes 118 Pesakit Di Icu 457 Kes Di Lembah Klang

Update Covid 19 28 November Tambah 5 418 Kasus Total 527 999 Orang Positif Di Ri

Gubernur Jabar Tanggapi Ott Walkot Cimahi Saya Kenal Baik Sering Interaksi

Pemprov Bengkulu Siapkan Tenaga Medis Untuk Disuntik Vaksin Covid 19