What Did We Miss In Syria


 
The downfall of Bashar al-Assad’s regime in Syria surprised even the opposition, led by Abu Mohammad al-Jolani’s Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, offering fertile ground for conspiracy theories.
What roles did Israel, Turkey, Russia, and the US play in this sudden reversal? Did Russia abstain from intervening on Assad’s behalf simply because it cannot afford another military operation outside the Ukrainian theatre, or was there some behind-the-scenes deal?
Did the US again fall into the trap of supporting Islamists against Russia, ignoring the lessons from its support of the mujahideen in Afghanistan in the 1980s? What did Israel do? It is certainly benefitting from the diversion of the world’s attention from Gaza and the West Bank, and it is even seizing new territory in southern Syria for itself.
Like most commentators, I simply don’t know the answers to these questions, which is why I prefer to focus on the bigger picture. A general feature of the story, like in Afghanistan after the US withdrawal and in Iran during the 1979 revolution, is that there was no big, decisive battle. The regime simply collapsed like a house of cards. Victory went to the side that was actually willing to fight and die for its cause.
The fact that the regime was universally despised does not fully explain what happened. Why did the secular resistance to Assad disappear, leaving only Muslim fundamentalists to seize the day?
One could apply the same question to Afghanistan. Why were thousands willing to risk their lives to catch a flight out of Kabul, but not to fight the Taliban? The armed forces of the old Afghan regime were better armed, but they simply were not committed to that fight.
A similar set of facts fascinated the philosopher Michel Foucault when he visited Iran (twice) in 1979. He was struck by what he saw as the revolutionaries’ indifference towards their own survival. Theirs was a “partisan and agonistic form of truth-telling,” Patrick Gamez explains.
They sought a “transformation through struggle and ordeal, as opposed to the pacifying, neutralising, and normalising forms of modern Western power. … Crucial for understanding this point is the conception of truth at work … a conception of truth as partial, as reserved for partisans”.
As Foucault himself put it:
“… if this subject who speaks of right (or rather, rights) is speaking the truth, that truth is no longer the universal truth of the philosopher. … It is interested in the totality only to the extent that it can see it in one-sided terms, distort it and see it from its own point of view. The truth is, in other words, a truth that can be deployed only from its combat position, from the perspective of the sought-for victory and ultimately, so to speak, of the survival of the speaking subject himself.”
Can this perspective be dismissed as evidence of a premodern “primitive” society that has not yet discovered modern individualism? To anyone minimally acquainted with Western Marxism, the answer is clear. As the Hungarian philosopher Georg Lukacs argued, Marxism is “universally true” precisely because it is “partial” to a particular subjective position.
What Foucault was looking for in Iran – the agonistic (“war”) form of truth-telling – was there from the beginning in Marx, who saw that participating in the class struggle is not an obstacle to acquiring “objective” knowledge of history, but rather a precondition for doing so.
The positivist conception of knowledge as an “objective” expression of reality – what Foucault characterised as “the pacifying, neutralising, and normalising forms of modern Western power” – is the ideology of the “end of ideology”.
On one hand, we have supposedly non-ideological expert knowledge; on the other hand, we have dispersed individuals, each of whom is focussed on his or her idiosyncratic “care of the Self” (Foucault’s term) – the small things that bring pleasure to one’s life. From this standpoint of liberal individualism, any universal commitment, especially if it includes risk to life and limb, is suspicious and “irrational”.
Here we encounter an interesting paradox. While traditional Marxism probably cannot provide a convincing account of the Taliban’s success, it does help clarify what Foucault was looking for in Iran (and what should fascinate us in Syria).
At a time when the triumph of global capitalism had repressed the secular spirit of collective engagement in pursuit of a better life, Foucault hoped to find an example of collective engagement that did not rely on religious fundamentalism. He didn’t.
The best explanation of why religion now seems to hold a monopoly on collective commitment and self-sacrifice comes from Boris Buden, who argues that religion as a political force reflects the post-political disintegration of society – the dissolution of traditional mechanisms that guaranteed stable communal links. Fundamentalist religion is not only political; it is politics itself. For its adherents, it is no longer just a social phenomenon, but the very texture of society.
Thus, it is no longer possible to distinguish the purely spiritual aspect of religion from its politicisation. In a post-political universe, religion is the channel through which antagonistic passions return. Recent developments that look like triumphs of religious fundamentalism represent not a return of religion in politics, but simply the return of the political as such.
The question, then, is what ever happened to secular radical politics (the great forgotten achievement of European modernity)? In its absence, Noam Chomsky believes we are approaching the end of organised society – the point of no return beyond which we cannot even adopt common sense measures to “avert cataclysmic destruction of the environment”.
While Chomsky focusses on our indifference towards the environment, I would extend his point to our general unwillingness to engage in political struggles generally. Making collective decisions to avert foreseeable calamities is an eminently political process.
The West’s problem is that it is wholly unwilling to fight for a big, common cause. The “peaceniks” who want to end Russia’s war in Ukraine on any terms, for example, will ultimately defend their comfortable lives, and they are ready to sacrifice Ukraine for that purpose. The Italian philosopher Franco Berardi is right. We are witnessing “the disintegration of the Western world”. - FMT
Slavoj Žižek, professor of philosophy at the European Graduate School, is international director of the Birkbeck Institute for the Humanities at the University of London.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2024/12/a_15.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Berakhirnya Regim Diktator Al Assad Apa Yang Akan Berlaku Di Syria

Berakhirnya Regim Diktator Al Assad Apa Yang Akan Berlaku Di Syria

papar berkaitan - pada 10/12/2024 - jumlah : 96 hits
HarapandailyDATUK SERI DR MUJAHID YUSOF RAWAKejatuhan Bashar adalah petanda jatuhnya sebuah regim diktator yang diasaskan oleh ayahnya Hafez Al Asad sejak 50 tahun yang lalu Pemerintahan keluarga Al Asad selama ini menyaksikan penindasan te...
Oops Syria Has Fallen

Oops Syria Has Fallen

papar berkaitan - pada 10/12/2024 - jumlah : 72 hits
It is a big Oops Until yesterday it was still unclear what exactly what happening on the ground in Syria But the clincher was that ALL Syrian government troops had stood down or laid down their arms most likely after realising that Bashar A...
Perlis Potensi Sumbang Lebih 20 Padi Negara Syria Barat Terkejut

Perlis Potensi Sumbang Lebih 20 Padi Negara Syria Barat Terkejut

papar berkaitan - pada 11/12/2024 - jumlah : 113 hits
1 Perlis potensi sumbang lebih 20 peratus padi negara KANGAR Perlis dijangka mampu menyumbang lebih 20 peratus kepada pengeluaran beras negara sekiranya pesawah di negeri ini mengadaptasi penggunaan teknologi mesin menanam padi atau transpl...
Syria Into Confusion

Syria Into Confusion

papar berkaitan - pada 12/12/2024 - jumlah : 61 hits
Many questions are now arising in Syria and among Iranians The rebel group Hayat Tahrir Shams or HTS has only about 15 000 fighters They have no tanks or armored vehicles No artillery cannons or long range weapons Yet the 250 000 strong Syr...
Ketua Pbb Sangat Bimbang Dengan Serangan Udara Israel Yang Berulang Di Syria

Ketua Pbb Sangat Bimbang Dengan Serangan Udara Israel Yang Berulang Di Syria

papar berkaitan - pada 14/12/2024 - jumlah : 61 hits
BernamaHAMILTON Setiausaha Agung Pertubuhan Bangsa Bangsa Bersatu Antonio Guterres pada Khamis mengecam sekeras kerasnya pelanggaran besar besaran terhadap kedaulatan dan keutuhan wilayah Syria baru baru ini sambil menggesa Israel menghenti...
Sanusi Lwn Guan Eng Kepala Bapak Hang Ini Pemberontak Syria

Sanusi Lwn Guan Eng Kepala Bapak Hang Ini Pemberontak Syria

papar berkaitan - pada 12/12/2024 - jumlah : 130 hits
1 Ucapan MB Sanusi di Sungai Tua Selangor Ucapan Pengerusi Pilihan Raya Perikatan Nasional Datuk Seri Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor bersama penduduk Sungai Tua Video2 Fakta sokong hujah Kedah miliki Pulau Pinang June 1 2023 Isu Pulau Pinang milik ...
Presiden Bashar Al Assad Melarikan Diri Pemerintahan Syria Jatuh Kata Pemantau Peperangan

Presiden Bashar Al Assad Melarikan Diri Pemerintahan Syria Jatuh Kata Pemantau Peperangan

papar berkaitan - pada 9/12/2024 - jumlah : 125 hits
Kerajaan Syria tumbang setelah kumpulan pemberontak mengumumkan mereka telah memasuki ibu kota Damascus Pemantau perang Syrian Observatory for Human Rights yang berpangkalan di Britain melaporkan bahawa Presiden Bashar al Assad telah melari...
Tentera Iran Lari Meninggalkan Bashar Assad Syria Bakal Tumbang Dalam Masa Terdekat

Tentera Iran Lari Meninggalkan Bashar Assad Syria Bakal Tumbang Dalam Masa Terdekat

papar berkaitan - pada 8/12/2024 - jumlah : 77 hits
3 Pegawai Kanan Tentera Iran memberitahu New York Times bahawa mereka memulakan pemindahan keluar Pegawai Kanan dan anggota Tentera Iran dan Kor Pengawal Revolusi Iran IRGC dari SyriaIni susulan Rejim Bashar Assad akan tumbang dalam masa te...
Club Of Doom Syria Bangladesh Pakistan

Club Of Doom Syria Bangladesh Pakistan

papar berkaitan - pada 7/12/2024 - jumlah : 75 hits
PAKISTAN FACES SURGE IN MILITANT ACTIVITY SECTARIAN CLASHES AND CONTINUED POLITICAL CRISISBottom Line Up Front volatile and multifaceted security crisismilitant attacks sectarian clashes and political violence 2024 steep increase in violent...
Pelancaran Omega Ambil Alih Sephora Debut Fila Banyak Lagi Acara Menarik Minggu Ini

Nak Buat Rendang Hijau Ikut Cara Mudah Ni Confirm Terangkat

Capture The Magic Of The Holidays With Gopro Hero

Pengantin Bersanding Di Tanah Kubur

Youshan Meidi Villa A Minimalist Retreat In Harmony With Nature

Flag Blunder On Zii Jia S Jersey A Serious Oversight Minister

Motivasi Restu Ilmu Spm 2024 Tremendous

Benarkah Anwar Melobi Tengku Zafrul Sebagai Mb Selangor Jumiah Jonid


echo '';
Resepi Soft Cookies Sukatan Cawan Paling Rangup dan Chewy Di Dalam

Biodata Sky Iskandar Pelakon Watak Megat Filem Kahar Kapla High Council

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Rahsiamu Selamat Denganku Astro Ria

Senarai Lagu Tugasan Konsert Minggu 4 Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11

Keputusan Markah Peserta Konsert Minggu 3 Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11


Is Tengku Zafrul Playing 4d With Malaysian Politics

Orang Melayu Terancam Hate Speech G Eng

What Did We Miss In Syria

I Ll Bring Voters Back To Bn Tajuddin Vows

Villagers Taken Aback As Floods Bring Crocodile To Padi Field

Fox888