To Help The Poor Just Give Them The Money


 

The financial situation faced by the PPR communities in Malaysia is dreadful and a continuing cause of concern.
As someone who grew up in public housing in Liverpool I understand many of the problems, and the potential solutions also appear rather similar.
The data from the recently released Unicef-sponsored “Living on the Edge” report confirms what we already suspected.
But for the data to be of real value we must use it to understand the causes and cures, not just the nature of the problem.
The economic and social impact of poverty on PPR residents is mostly contained within the communities themselves.
They become ring-fenced, isolated and excluded from the wider economy and society partly because they simply cannot afford to be part of it but also because policy choices create this isolation.
This leads to poverty continuing from one generation to the next.
There are many causes of the worsening financial situation, such as the rising cost of living, which affects everyone.
But the main cause of the problems for PPR residents and hardcore poor is ineffective government policy over many decades.
The first issue is the absence of a fully universal social protection policy.
Instead, there is a system of ad hoc welfare policies across dozens or even hundreds of programmes.
There is no philosophy or systemic design in these policies.
The second issue is that assistance is often given in kind, such as food or subsidies.
Often eligibility for assistance is based on social criteria such as whether these people have children or not, or on ethnicity.
Simple cash transfers are often more efficient and which is what people prefer.
The third issue is the huge bureaucratic inefficiency of the welfare-based approach. It is slow, complicated and a major source of wastage, leakages and corruption.
This means people do not get assistance they are eligible for because they are unaware of what is available, it is too difficult to apply or a government officer has to approve their application.
It places people in the hands of others to decide whether they get help or not and takes away their personal choices by disempowering them within a dependency system.
In many cases if they find work they lose all their welfare assistance and are worse off so they stay unemployed, poor and dependent on welfare.
For the economy as a whole, there is the wider problem of low incomes even if they are above the minimum wage, and relative poverty with half of the people in private sector jobs earning less than RM2,600 a month.
This needs to be tackled.
This is not the fault of the current unity government, which has inherited this responsibility from previous administrations. Rather, they have been caused by policy failures over many years.
The unity government actually has a different and better policy. Using the Padu system they can target those in need and give them the assistance they want.
This is almost always best achieved by cash transfers. We need to see whether the targeted subsidies will be in the form of cash transfers or not.
Unicef has suggested that the minimum wage be raised to RM2,102. However, this is still below the poverty and living wage levels and will not solve the problem.
There needs to be a new universal basic income or guaranteed basic income threshold below which no-one should fall.
It can be the minimum wage rate based on the department of statistics’ poverty-level income, Bank Negara Malaysia’s living wage or the EPF Belanjawanku estimates, and updated annually based on inflation.
It can even be the private sector median wage of RM2,600.
Anyone whose income falls below this level should receive a cash payment to top-up their income to this threshold, even those working on minimum or low wages.
This is sometimes called a reverse income tax, negative income tax or cash transfer.
This is well-known and widely accepted in economics as the best solution. The new Padu database can be used to identify individuals below the threshold to target the assistance to them in cash directly.
The basic economics is simple. Subsidies and other “in-kind” welfare assistance only benefits those who use the subsidised products. If you do not use petrol very much you do not benefit very much.
Offering cash transfers directly enables people to spend it as they choose on what they actually need for themselves and their families. They are empowered and treated with dignity like everyone else.
Food parcels for example take away people’s choice of what to eat, cash allows them to eat what they choose. If they need clothes for their children a food parcel does not help them, cash does.
People know best what they need and with cash they get to choose for themselves, not a government officer choosing for them. This is dignified and so of course everyone prefers this. - FMT
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2024/05/to-help-poor-just-give-them-money.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Impending Huge Public Sector Pay Hike Gets Economists Thinking About Where The Money Is Coming From

Impending Huge Public Sector Pay Hike Gets Economists Thinking About Where The Money Is Coming From

papar berkaitan - pada 8/5/2024 - jumlah : 257 hits
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim delivers his keynote address during the National Labour Day celebration at Putrajaya International Convention Centre in Putrajaya May 1 2024 Anwar announced the hike at the celebration where he sugges...
Together Mca And Gerakan Can Give Dap A Run For Its Money Says Razali

Together Mca And Gerakan Can Give Dap A Run For Its Money Says Razali

papar berkaitan - pada 9/5/2024 - jumlah : 299 hits
Bersatu information chief Razali Idris said MCA and Gerakan should consider merging to avoid fighting for the same seats PETALING JAYA Bersatu and PAS leaders are open to having MCA join Perikatan Nasional to give DAP a run for its money in...
What Can We Learn When They Dont Perform Just Vote Them Out

What Can We Learn When They Dont Perform Just Vote Them Out

papar berkaitan - pada 4/5/2024 - jumlah : 185 hits
The local council elections in Britain are over As was expected by many Brits the ruling Conservative Party has been badly routed The full results are not all in yet but they certainly show a defeat for the Conservatives Will there be a cha...
Hurting The Poor Lawyers Petition Against Scrapping E Jamin

Hurting The Poor Lawyers Petition Against Scrapping E Jamin

papar berkaitan - pada 18/5/2024 - jumlah : 155 hits
Some 50 lawyers have signed a memorandum petitioning the Prime Minister s Department against the court s sudden decision to cancel the e Jamin electronic bail management system This is after the Malaysian Bar in its circular this week annou...
Unity Debate Can Help Bridge The Social Deficit Say Experts

Unity Debate Can Help Bridge The Social Deficit Say Experts

papar berkaitan - pada 3/5/2024 - jumlah : 307 hits
Experts say building unity in a country of diverse races cultures and religions has its challenges especially social interactions which are essential aspects of social relationships Picture by Firdaus LatifKUALA LUMPUR May 3 Building unity ...
A Glimpse Into Malaysia S High Profile Graft Cases And Macc S Success Rate In Netting The Sharks

A Glimpse Into Malaysia S High Profile Graft Cases And Macc S Success Rate In Netting The Sharks

papar berkaitan - pada 7/5/2024 - jumlah : 369 hits
ONCE accused of only going after the ikan bilis the Malaysian Anti Corruption Commission is now receiving plaudits for taking on the big fish perhaps the biggest fish During the premiership of Tun Hussein Onn former Selangor menteri besar D...
Iforte Gandeng Bca Gelar Pagelaran Sabang Merauke The Indonesian Broadway

Iforte Gandeng Bca Gelar Pagelaran Sabang Merauke The Indonesian Broadway

papar berkaitan - pada 6/5/2024 - jumlah : 132 hits
Acara dilaksanakan pada 17 18 Agustus 2024 di JIEXPO Convention Center Theatre
Contact Lens Trial Experience The Difference Risk Free

Contact Lens Trial Experience The Difference Risk Free

papar berkaitan - pada 6/5/2024 - jumlah : 288 hits
Are you looking forward to an amazing clarity and the freedom of glasses Expert contact lens suppliers will help you unlock the full potential of your vision by providing personalized solutions designed to fit your specific needs and lifest...
Home Gym Revolution The Perfect Exercise Bike For Every Rider

Home Gym Revolution The Perfect Exercise Bike For Every Rider

papar berkaitan - pada 6/5/2024 - jumlah : 271 hits
Cycling is a pastime that has many appeals The breeze in your hair and the breathtaking scenery as being a thrill in challenging yourself to the limit are all tempting What if you could be able to feel the excitement of a fantastic cycle wi...
Anwar Convenes Urgent Cabinet Meeting To Tackle Us Tariff Fallout

Tragedi Letupan Challenger Milik Nasa

Kebakaran Putra Heights Polis Sahkan Terdapat Aktiviti Korek Tanah

Mesyuarat Khas Menteri Ekonomi Asean Bincang Implikasi Tarif As

Kes Culik Polis Lepas Tembakan Untuk Selamatkan Mangsa

Lagoon Villa Abidjan By Saota Where Modernism Embraces Nature

Berpesak Berkekek

Putrajaya Nafikan Tuduhan Tarif 47 Ke Atas Import Dari As


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


Open House Raya 2025

Buruh Mengaku Salah Culik Kanak Kanak Lelaki Curi Kereta Bapa Mangsa

Tarian Penguin Dari Finland Ke Seluruh Dunia

Sambal Udang Padu Bahan Bahan 700g Udang Segar 3 Biji Bawang Besar

Hiburan Terkini Jofliam Amp Dewi Sah Bergelar Suami Isteri

Rahsia Kari Ayam Kuah Roti Jala Yang Sedap