Statutory Rape Experts Push For Reform Warn Not To Criminalise Teens


 


The suggestion for girls in statutory rape cases to be charged alongside the adult male perpetrator has sparked calls by experts for a holistic approach when close-in-age teens are involved.
Child welfare and legal experts who spoke to Malaysiakini believed the law should distinguish the act of rape by a predatory adult male from a non-exploitative romantic relationship between underage children.
According to child welfare activist Hartini Zainudin, teenagers under 16 do not have the capacity to give legal consent regardless of gender and treating them as criminals can cause trauma and create stigma that can affect their future.
“Rather than punishing the teenagers under criminal laws, it would be better for the country to invest in comprehensive sexual education, counselling, and psychosocial support, and in-community prevention programmes.
“With comprehensive sexual education, teenagers can understand their rights, consent, and risks of pregnancy and contracting diseases.
“Counselling and psychosocial support can be provided for the teenagers and their parents, while through prevention programmes, there would be engagement between parents, schools, NGOs, and religious authorities,” she said.
Child welfare activist Hartini ZainudinHartini, who is Yayasan Chow Kit co-founder, also expressed her agreement with suggestions mooted by several lawyers for Malaysia to have a “Romeo and Juliet” law.
She said many countries have allowed a “close-in-age exemption” where minors having sex with other minors within a small age difference, like a two to three year gap, are not treated as criminals.
However, she stressed that such a law should not allow exploitation by adult males.
“For example, a man aged 19 who has sex with a 15-year-old girl. While their age gap is not too much, there is a risk of power imbalance, manipulation, or subtle coercion.
“The law must be clear about the age limit and maximum age gap to prevent abuse,” Hartini said.
Considering mental age and maturity
Lawyer Puvarasan Balaiyah pointed out that while Section 375(g) of the Penal Code - which criminalises sex with girls under 16 regardless of consent - is designed to be “purely protective”, a rigid approach has often led to outcomes that “defy common sense”.
This happened particularly in cases involving close-in-age teenagers where the relationship may be genuinely consensual, he said.
“We must introduce a mechanism that gives due weight to the right mental age and maturity of the victim,” he said.
Puvarasan suggested that a holistic legal review must consider three factors: actual maturity, power dynamic, and proportionality and justice.
“Chronological age doesn’t equate to cognitive or emotional development. We must integrate insights from child development experts to assess a minor’s capacity for informed consent.
“The law must differentiate sharply between predatory adult exploitation (where the strict liability rule is absolutely essential) and non-exploitative relationships between two adolescents with a small age gap.”
According to Puvarasan, the law must also ensure that the punishment fits the true nature of the act.
The blanket imposition of a rape charge on a teenage boy for a non-exploitative, consensual relationship with a slightly younger partner, he said, “is often a failure of justice”.
Differentiating boys and men
Veteran criminal lawyer N Sivananthan said it is fairer to amend the law, which recognises only a man as being able to commit rape.
According to him, the law should state that if an offender is also under age 16, and the sex was consensual, he or she would be entitled to probation or rehabilitation punishment.
“For those above 16, the current law suffices as it may amount to using undue influence on a girl who may be gullible and easily influenced.
“That would be a step in the right direction as it doesn’t unfairly prejudice a boy under 16 who may also lack the maturity to appreciate his actions fully,” Sivananthan said.
Veteran criminal lawyer N SivananthanLast week, Kelantan police chief Yusoff Mamat sparked controversy after he suggested that girls involved in statutory rape cases should be charged alongside the adult male perpetrator.
He argued for the consideration of his proposal by saying nearly 90 percent of statutory rape cases are consensual, based on investigations.
While his remarks attracted criticism, several lawyers suggested the introduction of a “sweetheart defence”, also known as a “Romeo and Juliet law”, instead of charging underage girls for “consenting” to statutory rape. - Mkini


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2025/09/statutory-rape-experts-push-for-reform.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Amid Statutory Rape Debate Children S Commissioner Points To Diversion As Option For Boys

Amid Statutory Rape Debate Children S Commissioner Points To Diversion As Option For Boys

papar berkaitan - pada 24/9/2025 - jumlah : 450 hits
Suhakam Children s Commissioner Dr Farah Nini Dusuki speaks during a press conference in Kuala Lumpur on March 13 2024 Yusof Mat IsaKUALA LUMPUR Sept 24 The Office of the Children s Commissioner has called for greater awareness of rehabilit...
Charging Victims Discourages Reports Not Curb Statutory Rape

Charging Victims Discourages Reports Not Curb Statutory Rape

papar berkaitan - pada 23/9/2025 - jumlah : 169 hits
YOURSAY An underaged person s consent is not valid Hassan means the girl is underage that is under the age of consent If she is under the age of consent how can she give consent and have it be valid In Kelantan these rapes happen to girls a...
Lawyers Moot Romeo And Juliet Law Not Charging Girls In Rape Cases

Lawyers Moot Romeo And Juliet Law Not Charging Girls In Rape Cases

papar berkaitan - pada 23/9/2025 - jumlah : 454 hits
Lawyers have suggested the introduction of a sweetheart defence also known as a Romeo and Juliet law instead of charging underage girls for consenting to statutory rape Kokila Vaani Vadiveloo explained that such a legal provision aims to pr...
Rafizi Pas Push For Blind Obedience Could Be Detrimental

Rafizi Pas Push For Blind Obedience Could Be Detrimental

papar berkaitan - pada 21/9/2025 - jumlah : 1135 hits
PKR deputy president Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli has warned that PAS growing insistence on wala from its members could become a liability for the party as it eyes federal power as blind obedience could be detrimental Rafizi said while PAS leade...
Push For Meeting With Trump Urimai Urges Pas

Push For Meeting With Trump Urimai Urges Pas

papar berkaitan - pada 30/9/2025 - jumlah : 430 hits
After Abdul Hadi Awang pans Putrajaya for inviting the great devil for the Asean Summit David Marshel urges PAS to demonstrate political maturity Earlier today PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang questioned Malaysia s justification for inviting ...
Fam Must Answer For Fifa Sanctions Not Just Appeal Pn

Fam Must Answer For Fifa Sanctions Not Just Appeal Pn

papar berkaitan - pada 28/9/2025 - jumlah : 1397 hits
It is not enough for the Football Association of Malaysia to merely appeal the fine by the International Federation of Association Football over doctored documentation said Perikatan Nasional chief whip Takiyuddin Hassan FAM must take respo...
Kelantan Top Cop Stands By Personal Opinion On Statutory Rape Cases

Kelantan Top Cop Stands By Personal Opinion On Statutory Rape Cases

papar berkaitan - pada 30/9/2025 - jumlah : 692 hits
This comes after his proposal to punish underage girls involved in statutory rape cases draws fire Kelantan police chief Yusoff Mamat today expressed regret if any party had been upset by his proposal PETALING JAYA Why should I apologise or...
Kelantan Cops Want Girls In Consensual Statutory Rape Cases Charged Too

Kelantan Cops Want Girls In Consensual Statutory Rape Cases Charged Too

papar berkaitan - pada 22/9/2025 - jumlah : 1315 hits
Kelantan police chief Yusoff Mamat suggested that girls involved in statutory rape cases should be charged alongside the adult male perpetrator ADSHe argued for the consideration of his proposal by saying nearly 90 percent of statutory rape...
Macc Arrests Former Agency Staff Suspected Of Misusing Zakat Funds Meant For 28 Recipients

Umno Pkr Leaders Mock New Ipr Coalition As Symbol Of Pn S Disunity

Quit Cabinet Post If Agc Files Appeal On Sabah Revenue Ruling Ewon Told

Dap Faces Uphill Battle To Hold Sabah S Chinese Vote Amid Growing Sabah For Sabahan Sentiment

Pengantin Baru Lepas Potong Kek Kahwin Tiba Tiba Parcel Sampai

Pas Leaves It To Police To Probe Viral Audio Resembling Perlis Mb

Mongol Dan Islam Sejarah Yang Ramai Tak Tahu

Mic Ready To Move Forward With Or Without Bn


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Dendam Seorang Madu Slot Tiara Astro Prima

10 Fakta Biodata Amira Othman Yang Digosip Dengan Fattah Amin Penyanyi Lagu Bila Nak Kahwin

5 Tips Macam Mana Nak Ajak Orang Kita Suka Dating Dengan Kita

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Keluarga Itu Slot Lestary TV3

Bolehkah Manusia Transgender Mencapai Klimaks Selepas Bertukar


Baby Shima X Mimpi Pap Pap Chord

Monolog Jiwa Khas Di Puncak Yang Tak Kembali

Hiburan Ibu Didakwa Jadi Punca Perceraian Nubhan Dan Isteri Pelakon Tampil Buat Penafian Gambar Itu Jadi Bahan Fitnah

Moment Empat Beradik Berkumpul Masak Mee Kari Resepi Arwah Mak

Ada Yang Setahun Jagong Memandai Palatao

Berkunjung Ke Pasar Pagi Baling Kedah