Loh Siew Hong Case Federal Court Decision Overrides State Law


 

From Shad Saleem Faruqi
It is always heart-wrenching to hear of a mother pining to see her children, and being prevented from doing so. This is especially so if the mother is granted legal custody.
The person(s) standing in the way of Loh Siew Hong and her three minor children, and why, are questions of fact which require an independent investigation.
I will comment only on the important constitutional questions raised in this case.
Custody order is binding
First, a custody order from the courts is binding on all persons and any defiance of the judicial order may amount to contempt of court. Nobody is immune from this law.
Federal Constitution is supreme
Second, the Federal Constitution is the supreme law of the land and it is superior to all other written laws, including state enactments. Any state law that violates the Constitution can be struck down by the superior civil courts.
Superior courts decide the law
Third, whenever there is a conflict between any laws or ambiguity in any law, as is almost always the case, the superior courts are the ultimate arbiters of what the law says and means.
The Constitution is what the courts say it is. No one can arrogate this power to himself. It is open to us to express our disagreement with judicial views and visions of the law but we all have a duty to obey. In a democracy we can censure, freely but we must obey promptly.
Unilateral conversion is unconstitutional
Fourth, the 2018 M Indira Gandhi Federal Court decision is binding authority for the proposition that unilateral conversion of minors to another religion without the consent of both parents is unconstitutional.
The case is also the authority for the ruling that in Article 12(4) the words “parent or guardian” mean both parents or guardians. This is so because the Constitution in Schedule 11, para 2(95) says that “words in the singular include the plural”. The Indira Gandhi verdict has been affirmed in several later decisions.
State bound by federal court decision
Fifth, if the Perlis state enactment 2016 provides to the contrary, then it needs to be amended and updated to conform to the 2018 apex court decision. Even if there is delay in its amendment, all authorities in Perlis are nevertheless bound by the Federal Court decision with effect from 2018.
Equality under the law
Sixth, in my personal view the Indira Gandhi decision is also supported by Article 8 on equality before the law and equal protection of the law. Article 8(2) says that “except as expressly authorised by this Constitution, there shall be no discrimination against citizens on the ground only of religion … in any law”.
In cases where one parent converts to Islam, the other parent does not automatically lose her or his right to an equal right and duty in relation to the child’s upbringing, education and religion.
Translation not a way out
Seventh, the learned mufti of Perlis has raised the interesting issue about Article 160B which authorises the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to prescribe a national language translation of the Constitution as the authoritative text.
The learned mufti relies on a translation in which the word “parent or guardian” in Article 12 is translated as “ibu atau bapa”. However, there is no proof that this translation was officially prescribed and notified in the government gazette.
Prof Shad Saleem Faruqi.In any case, Article 160B cannot stand alone. If a translation of the supreme Constitution is done totally outside of Parliament and without the consent of the Conference of Rulers and the Governors of Sabah and Sarawak under Articles 159 and 161E, then it will be open to constitutional challenge.
Translation is a work of art, not science. If a translation – even if prescribed under Article 160B – violates fundamental rights or the federal-state division of powers, especially the rights of Sabah and Sarawak, or if it does violence to any of the entrenched topics in Article 159(5), its validity will be questioned.
Article 160B cannot be employed to sweep away in an extra-parliamentary way the delicate compromises that the architects of our Constitution in 1957 and 1963 put into our Basic Law. -FMT
Prof Emeritus Shad Saleem Faruqi is a constitutional law professor at Universiti Malaya.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2022/02/loh-siew-hong-case-federal-court.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Loh Siew Hong Is A Good Mother

Loh Siew Hong Is A Good Mother

papar berkaitan - pada 24/2/2022 - jumlah : 151 hits
Loh Siew Hong knew early on that being a great cook was not enough She needed to be entrepreneurial When she was a waiter at a food stall in Sungai Petani Kedah where she grew up she observed what people wanted most Her boss let her take ov...
Ensure State Laws In Line With Federal Court Ruling Ag Urged

Ensure State Laws In Line With Federal Court Ruling Ag Urged

papar berkaitan - pada 21/2/2022 - jumlah : 145 hits
Klang MP Charles Santiago says Attorney General Idrus Harun should break his silence on the issue of unilateral conversions PETALING JAYA Attorney General Idrus Harun needs to ensure that state laws uphold the Federal Court s ruling against...
Decision Next Year On Formulating New Law To Tackle Beggars

Decision Next Year On Formulating New Law To Tackle Beggars

papar berkaitan - pada 19/2/2022 - jumlah : 150 hits
The authorities are finding it difficult to tackle beggars some of whom treat begging as a career in big cities like Kuala Lumpur KUALA LUMPUR A decision on whether to formulate a new law or improve the Destitute Persons Act 1977 to tackle ...
State Govts Must Also Adopt Anti Hopping Law Says Sabah Mp

State Govts Must Also Adopt Anti Hopping Law Says Sabah Mp

papar berkaitan - pada 20/2/2022 - jumlah : 174 hits
Upko president hopes the anti hopping legislation would not be delayed saying the people wanted significant changes to ensure the integrity of the legislature KOTA KINABALU A Sabah MP has urged state governments to take initiatives to intro...
Respect State Legislative Assembly S Decision On Premier Change Says Sarawak Minister

Respect State Legislative Assembly S Decision On Premier Change Says Sarawak Minister

papar berkaitan - pada 23/2/2022 - jumlah : 172 hits
Datuk Seri Abdul Karim Rahman Hamzah speaking during a press conference at Borneo Cultures Museum February 22 2022 Borneo Post Online picKUCHING Feb 22 The decision by the State Legislative Assembly as the highest law making body in Sarawak...
In Landmark Decision Court Allows Tnb To Quash Lhdn S Rm1 8bil Tax Claim

In Landmark Decision Court Allows Tnb To Quash Lhdn S Rm1 8bil Tax Claim

papar berkaitan - pada 9/2/2022 - jumlah : 149 hits
The ruling is expected to have a favourable impact on other ongoing tax appeals lodged by Tenaga Nasional Bhd KUALA LUMPUR The High Court today allowed Tenaga Nasional Bhd s judicial review application to set aside the Inland Revenue Board ...
Court S Decision Expected Says Perlis Mufti

Court S Decision Expected Says Perlis Mufti

papar berkaitan - pada 21/2/2022 - jumlah : 176 hits
Asri Zainul Abidin is not surprised by the High Court s decision to approve Loh Siew Hong s habeas corpus application to regain custody of her three children PETALING JAYA Perlis mufti Asri Zainul Abidin said he was not surprised by the Hig...
Court Allows Loh To Reunite With Her Three Children

Court Allows Loh To Reunite With Her Three Children

papar berkaitan - pada 21/2/2022 - jumlah : 225 hits
Single mother Loh Siew Hong has succeeded in her legal bid to quash the illegal detention of her three children who had been unilaterally converted to Islam The Kuala Lumpur High Court today allowed the habeas corpus application by the woma...
I Have Proof Zahid Asked For Help Over Court Case Says Muhyiddin

I Have Proof Zahid Asked For Help Over Court Case Says Muhyiddin

papar berkaitan - pada 23/2/2022 - jumlah : 184 hits
Bersatu president Muhyiddin Yassin says he has evidence that his Umno counterpart Ahmad Zahid Hamidi had asked him to intervene in his ongoing court case when he was the prime minister The Perikatan Nasional chairman said Zahid had the righ...
Addressing Flaws In Mrt3 S Strategy

Lirik Lagu Rasa Lia Aziz Ft Treehill

Yoursay Will Anything Come Out Of Ayer Keroh Accident Probe

Makan Tengah Hari Di Jeti Nelayan Kesang

Comment On Nasihat Untuk Mereka Yang Ingin Berkunjung Ke Sungai Kedondong Batang Kali Selangor By Zul

Merry Christmas And Happy New Year

Rakyat Digital Cara Daftar Senarai Kursus Percuma

Hiking Gunung Bubu Gerik


echo '';
Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Wanita Milik Kaiden Slot Akasia TV3

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Curang Tanpa Niat Slot Megadrama Astro Ria

5 Insiden Jalan Sesak Yang Berlaku Lebih 24 Jam Durasinya

Senarai Lagu Tugasan Konsert Minggu 6 Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11

Keputusan Markah Peserta Konsert Minggu 5 Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11


Lirik Lagu Suara Hati Repvblik

Lirik Lagu Aiman Tino Wani Kayrie

We Didn T Force Staff To Attend Xmas Do Says Ministry

Criminal Lawyer Defends Public Whipping Of Man Convicted Of Khalwat

No Projects No Kemasukan Rm400k Linked To Kuamut Rep

Cat888 1 2024