Keeping International Borders Closed Is Pointless





International borders remain mostly closed in Malaysia despite vaccination rates surpassing 90 percent of its adult population.
Yet the same stringency has not been applied to domestic mobility restrictions, which have been trending downwards and culminating with the opening of state borders on Oct 11.
The announcement on the easing of interstate travel by Prime Minister Ismail Sabri Yaakob also noted that overseas travel by Malaysians would be allowed but subject to a 14-day quarantine on return.
This appears inconsistent since the same requirement is not being applied to interstate travel in a country that has had one of the world’s highest infection rates on a population-adjusted basis.
If it is safe to open internal borders despite an ongoing community outbreak, it should be safe to do the same with external borders, at least for returning Malaysians or tourists from countries with high vaccination and low infection rates.
Finance Minister Zafrul Abdul Aziz has indicated that Malaysia might open international borders by year-end to support growth. But why wait until then?


As Delta has become dominant in Malaysia and elsewhere, it has called into question many things, including the usefulness of the current combination of mobility restrictions at and within borders.
The variant’s high transmissibility has eroded the health-protective effects of border closures relative to domestic mobility restrictions, while the economic cost of border closures accelerates.
So far, most of the actions to support the economy in Malaysia and Southeast Asia have focused on easing domestic restrictions. Border restrictions have hardly featured in the calculus.
Because borders must remain mostly closed, the economic imperative has required so much domestic easing that health risks have risen sharply, as evidenced by soaring infection rates in Malaysia and Southeast Asia.
If this lopsided approach was suboptimal before, it is becoming unsustainable with the Delta outbreak.
Border measures carry a premium only while they keep new variants out. Once they fail, as they inevitably have, their value diminishes rapidly.
They fail for two reasons. First, borders are never completely closed, by design, because it would be both impractical and unsustainable to do so.
Domestic safeguards
Even the most vigilant countries, like Australia and New Zealand, have chosen not to close borders despite having the advantage of geographic isolation.
Second, because borders are not completely shut, domestic safeguards need to be close to perfect but they are not.
Domestic protocols can slip, as they have in Australia and New Zealand, leading to breakthrough infections during quarantine.
Travel bans are an attempt at completely closing the border to select countries and have been employed, unsuccessfully, with the emergence of each new variant.
By the time they are instituted against countries where the new variant has been spreading, it is simply too late to stop them.
Travel bans could work if we could reduce the time taken to determine the risks carried by the new variants, say, from the genetic sequencing alone, but this is not yet possible. Until it is, border measures will not protect us from future variants but improved domestic protocols might.
Therefore, keeping borders closed in the hope that it will protect us from the next variant is futile.
Shifting the focus
Now that the Delta variant has taken off in Southeast Asia, imported cases make up just a small fraction of total infections.
It is small not because border measures are working but because they did not, and therefore failed to keep out a highly transmissible variant that then spread rapidly domestically. Once this happens, the value of border measures relative to domestic restrictions falls sharply.
This suggests that shifting the focus from border to domestic restrictions, for any given health-economy trade-off, would be beneficial.
Such a shift would better address economic considerations while providing the best opportunity to contain community spread.
The recalibration should not go too far in restricting domestic mobility or it will deter foreign arrivals.


Now that interstate movement has been allowed, the opening of international borders is likely to be more successful in attracting foreign tourists.
Most countries in Europe and North America have also struck this balance and removed quarantine but have not carried out tests on vaccinated travellers from countries with low infection rates.
With sufficient healthcare capacity, it is time for Malaysia to do the same.
The only countries in Southeast Asia that have started opening their borders to non-essential international travel are Singapore and Thailand.
Singapore has opened up to more than 10 countries with low infection and high vaccination rates, most of which have reciprocated.
The single most important border policy change that Malaysia and Singapore can do to support economic recovery without risking health is to open up to each other.


Thailand has employed the sandbox or ‘micro herd immunity’ approach in the resort islands of Phuket and Koh Samui, opening up unilaterally to a large number of countries.
There have been no community outbreaks linked to international arrivals, although Phuket had to ban domestic arrivals after a surge in domestically imported cases.
The experience from Phuket’s opening highlights the relative risks of domestic versus international travel. It should not be surprising that it is domestic tourism that has been riskier in a country still battling a local outbreak.
There are lessons here for Malaysia, which has opened Langkawi to domestic but not international tourists.
Mutual recognition of vaccination certificates and other administrative protocols to open borders unilaterally or with reciprocity can be done expeditiously.
Now that vaccination rates have reached 90 percent, there is no value in waiting to open borders but only costs.

JAYANT MENON is visiting senior fellow at the ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute, Singapore, and former lead economist of the Asian Development Bank in Manila.


The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2021/10/keeping-international-borders-closed-is.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Putrajaya To Discuss Reopening Of Borders To Foreign Travellers

Putrajaya To Discuss Reopening Of Borders To Foreign Travellers

papar berkaitan - pada 15/10/2021 - jumlah : 186 hits
Putrajaya will discuss the reopening of the country s borders to fully vaccinated foreign travellers through the mutual recognition of vaccine certificates by today said National Recovery Council chairperson Muhyiddin Yassin The meeting tod...
Sabah Tourism On The Mend After Opening Of District Borders

Sabah Tourism On The Mend After Opening Of District Borders

papar berkaitan - pada 22/10/2021 - jumlah : 339 hits
Visitors taking a dip in the river at Minurod Campsite KOTA KINABALU The quiet atmosphere at Minurod Campsite in Kiulu is lively again with people starting to visit rural tourist destinations since the inter district travel ban was lifted i...
Sarawak Agrees To Reopening Borders After Pm S Announcement But Travellers Need To Apply For Entry

Sarawak Agrees To Reopening Borders After Pm S Announcement But Travellers Need To Apply For Entry

papar berkaitan - pada 11/10/2021 - jumlah : 323 hits
SDMC said only fully vaccinated individuals are allowed to travel to the state Picture by Shafwan ZaidonKUCHING Oct 10 Sarawak will open its border for Malaysians from other states without any need for a police permit from tomorrow agreeing...
Interstate Borders To Reopen From Tomorrow Malaysians Free To Go Overseas

Interstate Borders To Reopen From Tomorrow Malaysians Free To Go Overseas

papar berkaitan - pada 10/10/2021 - jumlah : 493 hits
Prime Minister Ismail Sabri Yaakob said the government had also abolished the MyTravelPass programme for Malaysians who wish to travel overseas from tomorrow but they will be subjected to quarantine on their return PETALING JAYA Interstate ...
Pas Ulama Council Calls For Timah Liquor Factory To Be Closed

Pas Ulama Council Calls For Timah Liquor Factory To Be Closed

papar berkaitan - pada 19/10/2021 - jumlah : 296 hits
Following the controversy involving the production of Timah brand liquor PAS Ulama Council has submitted four proposals to the federal government to address the issue which includes closing down the manufacturing company to prevent the emer...
Business Groups Perturbed Nightclubs Pubs Still Closed Under Phase 4 Of Nrp

Business Groups Perturbed Nightclubs Pubs Still Closed Under Phase 4 Of Nrp

papar berkaitan - pada 22/10/2021 - jumlah : 357 hits
A coalition of business groups is concerned that nightclubs and pubs are still not allowed to reopen under Phase 4 of the National Recovery Plan even though all other sectors have been allowed to resume operations We are extremely perturbed...
Pm Malaysia Ready To Return As Regional International Investment Hub

Pm Malaysia Ready To Return As Regional International Investment Hub

papar berkaitan - pada 14/10/2021 - jumlah : 189 hits
Malaysia is now ready to be back on track as an investment hub for both regional and international investors driven by creative and innovative methods in encouraging investments implemented by the government Prime Minister Ismail Sabri Yaak...
Jadi Salah Satu Pemain Asal Indonesia Pertama Di The International Kenny Xepher Mama Aku Di Ti

Jadi Salah Satu Pemain Asal Indonesia Pertama Di The International Kenny Xepher Mama Aku Di Ti

papar berkaitan - pada 16/10/2021 - jumlah : 290 hits
Bikin orang tua bangga karena berlaga di turnamen DOTA 2 tingkat dunia pernyataan Xepher dengan Bahasa Indonesia itu pun jadi perbincangan warganet
Justice Beyond Life Tun Mahathir S Tribute To A Fallen Comrade

Whistleblower Himself May Be Implicated In Assemblymen Bribery Case Says Source

Perempuan Terkejut Bila Bayar Rm8 40 Untuk Secawan Milo Panas

Poll Finds Malaysians Divided Over Blanket Ban On 3r Discussions

Minta 2 Dapat 1 Lagi Pendedahan Video Pemberi Maklumat

Dua Lelaki Tular Curi Motosikal Diburu

Celebrate A Peranakan Christmas In Kuala Lumpur With Santa Grand Signature S Exclusive Buffet

Time To Engage China In Its Terms


echo '';
Senarai Lagu Separuh Akhir Muzik Muzik 39 Semi Final Muzik Muzik SFMM 2024 Persaingan Merebut Tiket Ke AJL Anugerah Juara Lagu

Biodata Terkini Fairuz Selamat Q Face Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Penyanyi Lagu Izinkanlah

Biodata Terkini Arrora Salwa Salwa Razak Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Penyanyi Lagu Ahmad

Biodata Terkini Penyanyi Liza Aziz Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Adik Beradik Kepada Azlina Aziz

Senarai Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Tonton Konsert Minggu 1 Pada 24 November Live Di Astro Ria Sooka Online


Pembungkusan Yang Berfungsi Menjaga Kesegaran Minyak Esensial

Makan Kerepek Pisang Tanduk Kawan Bagi

Family Mart Dan Gz Baiyun Airport Mehood Liz Hotel Guangzhou

Beg Tangan Jenis Mana Jadi Pilihan Wanita Moden

Business Website Boosts Credibility

Yang Lama Tidak Pernah Dilupakan