Justice Truth Must Prevail In Inquest Into Firefighter Adib S Demise


Photograph: The Sun DailyThe Malaysian Bar is disconcerted with recent events in the ongoing inquest into the death of the firefighter, the late Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim, in relation to the withdrawal of the advocate and solicitor, Syazlin Mansor, from further representing the Ministry of Housing and Local Government, the Fire and Rescue Department as well as Adib’s family and the reactions arising therefrom
An inquest is a legal proceeding comprising an inquisitorial and investigative process — not a criminal trial — where a coroner inquires into the circumstances surrounding a death and whether any person is criminally concerned in the cause of the death
It has now become apparent that Syazlin was appointed directly by the housing ministry and the Fire Department to represent them when lawfully it is an officer from the Attorney General’s Chambers who should appear for the government and its agencies – unless the attorney general gives an advocate and solicitor a fiat to appear for the government pursuant to the Government Proceedings Act 1956
No such fiat was issued to Syazlin for her appointment, and hence she should not have been appointed as legal counsel by those government agencies
In his media release dated 28 May 2019, the attorney general also raised the point that Syazlin “was in a conflict of interest position when she agreed to act for the housing ministry and the Fire Department as she was also acting for the deceased’s family, who have a direct interest in the Inquest”
Indeed, it is indisputable that advocates and solicitors hold fiduciary and/or contractual duties towards their clients. It is therefore the obligation of every advocate and solicitor to scrupulously guard against, and avoid, situations of conflict of interest — both actual and potential — particularly in representing multiple parties
The seemingly common interest of various parties being represented by a single advocate and solicitor could potentially result in divergent or competing interests, and thus impair the ability of the advocate and solicitor to act in the best interest of the parties concerned
One example is if, in the aftermath of the inquest, Adib’s family files a civil suit against the government. As another example, if the inquest determines that the government was responsible for Adib’s death, the firefighter’s family has the right to commence legal action against the government
In both these situations, the evidence that had been tendered and led by Syazlin during the inquest — ie when she was simultaneously representing the government and the family — could then be used during the subsequent legal proceedings, hence resulting in a clear case of conflict, as the various parties would then have opposing interests
The prohibition against advocates and solicitors acting in a position of conflict is stipulated in the Legal Profession Act 1976, the Legal Profession (Practice & Etiquette) Rules 1978, and the Rules and Rulings of Bar Council Malaysia — for example, where the acceptance of a brief would render it difficult for an advocate and solicitor to “maintain [his/her] professional independence” or if it is “incompatible with the best interest of the administration of justice”
In determining whether there is conflict, the objective test to be applied is not whether there is actual conflict, but whether there is an appearance of conflict
In Teoh Meng Kee v Public Prosecutor [2014], the Court of Appeal held as follows:An inquiry of death is not like a criminal trial. … It is only an inquiry by a magistrate as to the cause of death and the deputy public prosecutor is there not to prosecute anyone but only to assist the court with the examination of witnesses for the purpose of receiving the evidence. … Counsel present is there not to defend anyone but only to look after the interest of those who have appointed him. … [emphasis added]In light of the above, the Malaysian Bar is of the view that Syazlin should have therefore declined to act simultaneously for the housing ministry, the Fire Department and Adib’s family
While an inquest is not a trial and is only inquisitorial in nature, the strong public reaction to this is itself illustrative that, in the public eye, there is an appearance of conflict of interest
It is highly regrettable that no objections were raised at an earlier stage of the inquest proceedings, either by the coroner or the conducting officer, once Syazlin was on record for the parties concerned
The instructions for her to withdraw as counsel at an advanced stage in the inquest may have contributed to a negative perception by the public regarding the turn of events
The unfavourable perception is further exacerbated by the earlier act of the deputy public prosecutor in filing an affidavit that reportedly stated that the death of Adib was not due to beatings by any person, when any findings relating to cause of death are in fact exclusively the prerogative of the coroner in an inquest
All parties concerned should have adopted a more prudent and cautious approach from the outset. The failure to do so has led to unnecessary speculation and adverse perceptions
Be that as it may, once an advocate and solicitor’s position in a matter becomes untenable — at any stage of the proceedings — due to a conflict of interest, he or she must discontinue from acting for parties with divergent or competing interests
As such, the attorney general’s action in revoking Syazlin’s continued representation of the housing ministry and the Fire Department was a step to resolve the conflict of interest and preserve the integrity of the ongoing inquest
As the chief legal adviser to the government, the attorney general is entitled to take this position, which must not be construed as muzzling any particular or opposing view regarding the events leading to Adib’s demise
It is noteworthy that the attorney general in no way precluded Syazlin from continuing to represent Adib’s family in the inquest; she withdrew from doing so, of her own accord
Syazlin’s withdrawal as legal counsel in no way invalidates or diminishes the evidence that has been adduced thus far, as all such evidence will remain on record
Every member of the bar is urged to be vigilant and circumspect and to examine on a case-by-case basis whether he or she would be “embarrassed”, or if his or her professional conduct would be likely to be called into question, if a brief is accepted. This is a duty that all advocates and solicitors must take seriously
It is crucial that these recent developments not be permitted to detract from the ultimate objective of the inquest — to shed light on the circumstances surrounding Adib’s tragic death and to bring those responsible to book
The Malaysian Bar calls on all parties in the case to do their utmost to ensure that not only is justice done, but that it is also seen to be done. Truth and justice must prevail

Abdul Fareed Abdul Gafoor is president of the Malaysian Bar.. - ALIRAN

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2019/06/justice-truth-must-prevail-in-inquest.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Mu

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Syazlin Must Be Reinstated As Counsel In Adib Inquest Immediately

Syazlin Must Be Reinstated As Counsel In Adib Inquest Immediately

papar berkaitan - pada 3/6/2019 - jumlah : 101 hits
The Malaysian Alliance of Civil Society Organisations in the UPR Process is extremely concerned with the current turn of events pertaining to the inquest of into the death of firefighter Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim It was reported that the in...
New Dpp To Be Appointed For Adib S Inquest Previous Evidence Stands

New Dpp To Be Appointed For Adib S Inquest Previous Evidence Stands

papar berkaitan - pada 2/6/2019 - jumlah : 124 hits
A new deputy public prosecutor will be appointed to represent the Housing and Local Government Ministry plus the Fire and Rescue Services Department in the ongoing inquest into the death of firefighter Muhammad Adib Mohd KassimHousing and L...
Bar Concurs There Was Conflict Of Interest In Adib Inquest

Bar Concurs There Was Conflict Of Interest In Adib Inquest

papar berkaitan - pada 2/6/2019 - jumlah : 129 hits
Malaysian Bar president Abdul Fareed Abdul Gafoor has concurred with the Attorney General Tommy Thomas position that there was indeed potential conflict of interest when lawyer Syazlin Mansor decided to represent the family of the late fire...
Let The Court Decide On Conflicting Theories In Adib Inquest

Let The Court Decide On Conflicting Theories In Adib Inquest

papar berkaitan - pada 29/5/2019 - jumlah : 130 hits
All interested parties in the inquest into the death of firefighter Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim should let the court deliberate on the conflicting testimonies of expert witnesses says lawyer Salim Bashir Bhaskaran These parties should not be ...
Yoursay Why Did It Take So Long To Remove Lawyer From Adib Inquest

Yoursay Why Did It Take So Long To Remove Lawyer From Adib Inquest

papar berkaitan - pada 29/5/2019 - jumlah : 122 hits
YOURSAY AGC must explain why conflict of interest was not detected and acted upon much earlier Vent Firstly Housing and Local Government Minister Zuraida Kamaruddin erred in appointing lawyer Syazlin Mansor Did she not know earlier as per h...
Minister Lawyer Quit Adib Inquest After Instructed To Withdraw

Minister Lawyer Quit Adib Inquest After Instructed To Withdraw

papar berkaitan - pada 28/5/2019 - jumlah : 226 hits
The counsel for the federal government in the inquest of firefighter Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim s death had quit due to new turn of events Malaysiakini reported Lawyer Syazlin Mansor said Housing and Local Government Minister Zuraida Kamarud...
Ag Told Us To Withdraw Lawyer From Adib S Inquest Says Housing Ministry

Ag Told Us To Withdraw Lawyer From Adib S Inquest Says Housing Ministry

papar berkaitan - pada 29/5/2019 - jumlah : 154 hits
The housing and local government ministry said today it directed Syazlin Mansor who was representing it at the inquest into the death of fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim to withdraw following a request from the Attorney General s Chambers ...
Husband Of Ex Lawyer In Adib Inquest Quits Zuraida S Team

Husband Of Ex Lawyer In Adib Inquest Quits Zuraida S Team

papar berkaitan - pada 12/6/2019 - jumlah : 142 hits
The husband of Syazlin Mansor who withdrew as the lawyer for the family of late fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim in an ongoing inquest into his death has resigned as the press secretary to Housing and Local Government Minister Zuraida Kama...
Redundant For Dpp To Represent Ministry In Adib Inquest Says Lawyer

Redundant For Dpp To Represent Ministry In Adib Inquest Says Lawyer

papar berkaitan - pada 5/6/2019 - jumlah : 187 hits
FMT A lawyer says it would be redundant for two government lawyers to appear in the inquest into the death of fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim as put forth following the controversial withdrawal of Syazlin Mansor as the housing and local g...
Kenali Tanda2 Anda Sudah Tua

Saya Cerita Semua A Sampai Z Chacha Maembong Sudah Beri Keterangan Kerjasama Penuh

Viral Cewek Cewek Pensiunan Fakgirl Punya 300 Mantan Netizen Untung Cantik

Dari Segi Hiraki Umno Tajuddin Layak Tpm

Isharefans Scam Atau Tidak

Peneroka Felda Diwajibkan Sedekah Rm300 Seorang

Pm Tak Setuju Rakyat Keluar Duit Kwsp

Kemaman Kuantan Warung Aziz Satar Ana Ikan Bakar Petai



Info Dan Sinopsis Filem Bikin Filem Astro First

Biodata Daniesh Suffian Pelakon Drama Romantika 4 Hari 3 Malam

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Dia Bidadari Dari Syurga TV Okey

Biodata Luqman Podolski Penyanyi Lagu Kalau Kau Rindu

Kenapa Kemiskinan Membawa Kepada Sikap Pengotor


Isteri Di Sebalik Cermin

3 Sebab Kena Bijak Menguruskan Harta

Coca Cola Lottery Organization

Kuih Piring

Terlalu Aktif Hiking Cara Tak Betul Ibu Aliff Syukri Cedera Buku Lali

Astagfirullah Mobil Berkecepatan Tinggi Tabrak Pintu Masjidil Haram Mekkah Lihat Videonya