Fear And Loathing In New Malaysia

“The optimist proclaims that we live in the best of all possible worlds; and the pessimist fears this is true.”- James Branch Cabell, 'The Silver Stallion'I suppose, once you leave Malaysia, you are “Malaysian”. In Malaysia you remain a racial demographic and all that entails. The prime minister’s comment about how “Malaysians” overseas are valued for their professional “skill set” is indicative of how, once you leave our country, you truly become a citizen, or at least politicians talk as if you are a citizen and not belonging to a racial group
The fallout from the “Malay Dignity” forum has brought upon some soul searching in people who viewed a change of government as the beginnings of a new Malaysia, or a repudiation of the failed policies of the former Barisan Nasional (BN) regime

The reality that Harapan is morphing into a neo-BN has reinvigorated the discourse surrounding the idea that non-Malays do not really have a place under the Malaysian sun
There are three interesting comments - 'A deep sense of despair' by Michel Chng, 'Totally hopeless now' by Ho Lee Peing and 'The Chinese dilemma' by Kuik Cheng Kang, an attempt to frame the non-Malay discourse surrounding the Harapan win as one of failed expectations
Chng’s reportage of the Malay dignity forum produced an emotional reaction: “I really thought we would finally see a New Malaysia following a change of guard in Putrajaya. I suddenly found myself choking back tears as I talked.”Ho wonders if we should we leave this land out of sheer despair and concludes: “The nonsense uttered by our politicians and happily echoed by the black sheep in the academia serves to remind us that as co-authors of the Malaysian destiny, we cannot afford to become pessimistic, less so despair."Kuik’s 'The Chinese dilemma' is an answer to the Malay dignity forum: “To put things forthright, the dilemma of the Malays today has been a result of their own work. Unfortunately, the Chinese community is made to take the blame.”The problem I have with all these pieces is that they fail to address the reality that non-Malays, for decades, were complicit in supporting a regime that eventually morphed into a kleptocratic state, the apogee of which was the Najib regime
Failed Malay policies were not only the result of Malay stewardship, but also the enabling of non-Malay political power structures. This idea that a New Malaysia could be created by replacing the former kleptocrat with one of the chief architects of the old order is ludicrous
I am not saying this with any schadenfreude. How could I, when I was one of those people who were advocating for Harapan to name the current prime minister as a seat warmer because overthrowing the Najib regime was of utmost importance
To be fair, I was always clear-eyed about this strategy and leading up to the elections, I always attempted to point out how the Harapan coalition was slipping into Umno/BN mode. Close associates and partisans with rancour accused me, among other things, of being an Umno saboteur
Even now, non-Malay politicians who, before the election claimed that MCA and MIC were "running dogs” for their Malay counterparts, are realising how difficult it is to manoeuvre in the racial and religious terrain that they inherited. Keep in mind that we are not talking about novice politicians, but seasoned veterans of decades-long political conflicts who should understand how the system works because they were in control of a few states
Even now we have partisans who make excuses for Harapan, claiming they need more time, when before the election, politicians were telling their base that there was no time. Some folks thought that the old maverick had changed, but the reality is that there are many people who view his reign as a success, and that Old Malaysia under Prime Minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad (above) is the best we could hope for
Meanwhile, Mahathir's supporters, who are a legion, get frustrated with Harapan partisans who blame Bersatu for attempting to carry out the role Umno did. And this is not some sub rosa agenda of Bersatu. Harapan politicians, before the elections, told us that Bersatu was needed to shore up Malay support, which it did not manage to do
Even now, some Harapan partisans are telling us that there is no one else to vote for. This was the official BN narrative for years. People think that we finally got the change we wanted, but for many people the country, its policies and racial dynamics were fine, and the only thing that was wrong with the country was Najib Abdul Razak
There are people who are advocating leaving this country and there are people who say that we should stay and fight. My answer has always been the same. If you want people to stay and fight for their rights, you must be able to demonstrate that staying and fighting is something that is worthwhile
We are not yet at the stage where you can point to incremental changes (elsewhere) and say that this is progress. We are a developed country with narratives that are evidence that religious and racial plurality is something we had, but lost, like many Islamic state narratives in countries all over the Middle East
Either you refrain from voting until you have political coalitions that will fight for the Malaysia you want, or vote for coalitions that want to maintain the status quo
At this point, either option is not a value judgment for me
S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy. A retired barrister-at-law, he is one of the founding members of Persatuan Patriot Kebangsaan. - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :


Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
In Malaysia There S A New Storm Coming

In Malaysia There S A New Storm Coming

papar berkaitan - pada 29/10/2019 - jumlah : 43 hits
PMiw8 You want to fight I will give you war H20 Bring it on I m readyPMiw8 Good luck deputy prime minister The above is a recent exchange at the lobby of our Parliament between Anwar Ibrahim still the 8th Prime Minister in waiting and Umno ...
Natugee Health Event Mrs Malaysia World Healthy Is The New Happy

Natugee Health Event Mrs Malaysia World Healthy Is The New Happy

papar berkaitan - pada 23/10/2019 - jumlah : 101 hits
Assalamualaikum Seperti yang ramai sedia maklum bulan Oktober adalah bulan kesedaran mengenai kanser payudara Untuk itu Fiza berpeluang untuk menghadiri satu majlis yang berlangsung dengan gilang gemilang yang dianjurkan oleh Natugee Mrs Ma...
Messy Is The New Order Succession Time In Malaysia

Messy Is The New Order Succession Time In Malaysia

papar berkaitan - pada 29/10/2019 - jumlah : 74 hits
Given the fluid nature of coalition making and weak party discipline the question of who will become PM is now no longer simply a coalition decision but a parliamentary one Ooi Kok Hin The Interpreter Rather than a personality rivalry betwe...
Honouring Promises Is Paramount To New Malaysia

Honouring Promises Is Paramount To New Malaysia

papar berkaitan - pada 30/10/2019 - jumlah : 41 hits
We are well into the second year of Malaysia Baru and it has been everything but impressive The supposedly done deal in the transition of power to Anwar Ibrahim is now constantly made hazy and unclear by unscrupulous politicians when it sho...
Event The New Happy Is Healthy Natugee X Mrs Malaysia

Event The New Happy Is Healthy Natugee X Mrs Malaysia

papar berkaitan - pada 30/10/2019 - jumlah : 146 hits
Hi Korang Assalammualaikum Harini aku nak throwback sikit Event aku sempat pergi 20 10 2019 haritu di Hotel Furama Bukit Bintang Masa mula mula tu aku asyik dok ingat 20 hb tu hari Sabtu nasib baik tak cancel semua appointmet hari Sabtu rup...
Program Healthy Is The New Happy Anjuran Bersama Natugee Mrs Malaysia World 2019

Program Healthy Is The New Happy Anjuran Bersama Natugee Mrs Malaysia World 2019

papar berkaitan - pada 30/10/2019 - jumlah : 74 hits
Happy and terasa teruja bila dapat hadir Program Healthy Is The New Happy A Better You Today adalah anjuran bersama antara Natugee International Organic Skincare dengan Mrs Malaysia World 2019 yang diadakan di Furama Bukit Bintang Kuala Lum...
New Twist To Malaysia India Palm Oil Issue

New Twist To Malaysia India Palm Oil Issue

papar berkaitan - pada 23/10/2019 - jumlah : 56 hits
Any reduction of palm oil imports from Malaysia by India will hit hard the migrant workers from the southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu currently employed in Malaysia says a political body in India File Photo KUALA LUMPUR The Malaysia India...
Mcdonald S Malaysia Eyes 450 New Restaurants By 2025

Mcdonald S Malaysia Eyes 450 New Restaurants By 2025

papar berkaitan - pada 25/10/2019 - jumlah : 53 hits
McDonald s Malaysia aims to open 450 new restaurants nationwide by 2025 which are expected to create 10 000 jobs Managing director and local operating partner said to date the fast food chain operator has more than 290 restaurants throughou...
No Profits From Malaysia And Papua New Guinea But Vast Assets In Nz

No Profits From Malaysia And Papua New Guinea But Vast Assets In Nz

papar berkaitan - pada 19/10/2019 - jumlah : 50 hits
The saintly Sibu logging companies have made clear that their development activities stripping out billions of dollars worth of timber from Sarawak Papua and other South East Asian jewels of natural heritage has been done for decades at a l...
Panas Diana Isteri Baru Sultan Kelantan

Penjelasan Sebenar Replika Keris Gergasi Di Pintu Utama Uiam Diturunkan

Wow Shuib Pernah Putus Asa Tiga Perniagaan Gagal Kurma Sampai Berulat Kopi Pun Tak Jual

Aliff Aziz Dah Bebas Ibu Berterima Kasih Kepada Yang Mendoakannya

Mary Kay Pulak

Seperti Dijangka Hakim Mengarahkan Najib Bela Diri Dalam Kes Src International Atas Alasan Wujud Kes Prima Facie

Doa Meminta Aafiyah Di Dunia Dan Akhirat

Raikan Cinta Amy Syafiq

GV6 Giliran Sabhi Saddi One Nation Emcees Terkena Sakit Misteri

7 Undang Undang Berkait Islam di Malaysia Mahu Dipadam Pengkritik Dunia

Berbaloikah Pakai Helmet Full Face Untuk Pandu Motorsikal Kapcai

Siapa Lebih Kurang Ajar Alyah Jawab Dakwaan Biadab Pulang Awal Sewaktu Konsert GV6

7 Makanan Harian Yang Boleh Merosakkan Buah Pinggang Sekiranya Berlebihan

Bila Ada Kes Prima Facie Najib Kena Bela Diri

Mendaki Bukit Kutu Kuala Kubu Baru

Amalkan Diet Air Putih Dengan 11 Cara Ini Kalau Nak Berat Badan Mudah Turun

Tabiat Pemakanan Kanak Kanak Malaysia Mungkin Kurang Nutrisi Menurut Kajian Seanuts I

5 Tempat Awesome Wajib Lawat Sekitar Bandaraya Shah Alam

6 Tempat Menarik Di Balik Pulau Bagi Pencinta Alam Semula Jadi