Cutting Through The Khat Kerfuffle




The beauty of Arabic calligraphy that adorns the grand mosques in Dubai and Delhi, in Agra and Surakarta, in Kuching and Kuala Lumpur, fascinates me. But I know little about the history of khat, even though they are emblazoned on our coat of arms and printed on the ringgit notes
Little knowledge does cause confusion – and protests - with sensitive controversies such as the ongoing khat kerfuffle. Hence, I researched the different interpretations of the ‘problem’, starting with KiniGuide’s comprehensive explanation
My premise is simple. The educational benefits of children learning khat, or any new language and script art, far outweigh the imagined fear of the adults in losing their non-Malay heritage, their language, their identity, and so forth
Reactions to the khat issue are unsurprisingly fractious. Because the teaching of khat is seen as a racially driven ideological issue, an Islamic imposition, the reactions are likewise racial, ideological and polarised. We shouldn’t be surprised at the resultant politics given the racialised environment we live in today

However, if teaching khat were perceived as simply teaching a third or fourth language in primary schools, one would look at the principles of multilingual pedagogy and its benefits, and clarification of its learning outcomes
Learning khat or Jawi piecemeal without definitive objectives and learning outcomes simply muddies the rationale and defeats the purpose of introducing khat in the first place
This kerfuffle certainly falls at the feet of the multilingual education minister, MaszleeMalik (above), who is of Hakka-Chinese and Malay descent, who speaks “fluent Arabic and English, moderate French, German, simple Mandarin and Hokkien”
The 44-year-old minister’s execution of the khat idea may simply be what falls within his sphere of internal coherence. Indeed, “we are a sum total of what we have learned from all who have taught us, both great and small.”According to Wikipedia, Maszlee had taught at the International Islamic University Malaysia, studied Islam and the Middle East. His doctoral thesis at Durham University is titled "Constructing the Architectonics and Formulating the Articulation of Islamic Governance: A Discursive Attempt in Islamic Epistemology”
Some analysts attribute the ‘khat’ kerfuffle to the perceivably unpopular minister’s lack of clarity in explaining the rationale for including khat as part of the Malay language syllabus
Non-Malay educationists interpret the proposal as an extension of Islamic ideology which, according to one of the academics that drafted the curriculum, is grossly mistaken
Another article attributes the ‘fuss’ to the intrusion of ethnicity, religion and ideology into the Malaysian education system
In questioning the proposal, the author cautions that "schools have to be safeguarded from political and religious influence, be it Jawi (regarded as a language) or khat. It is still closely associated with the glory of Islam and is a scripture closely related to Islamic teaching and the Quran.”A well-researched article, however, dispels the public ignorance about Jawi with reference to the evolution of great languages and scripts to what they are today, for instance, the Romanisation of old Chinese characters to pinyin for easier articulation and usage
The Chinese author sums up the thinking of Malaysians who value the wisdom of learning a new language: “Islam, as a religion, has been around for 1,400 years, yet there are still Christians among Arabs (who) are still using the same Arabic script as their Muslim peers to write their language … claiming that learning Jawi would make a non-Muslim convert to Islam is as ridiculous as claiming that using Latin script would make one convert to Christianity.”A former ambassador who calls for the khat proposal to be reconsidered and the education system reformed to be more inclusive (and progressive), notes: “When will our policymakers learn to respect Malaysia’s minorities enough to consult with them and seek consensus, instead of simply foisting controversial policies on an already sullen and suspicious population? Is it ignorance or arrogance?”A fellow columnist makes similar arguments about giving parents and their children the option of deciding whether appreciating khat and writing Jawi is relevant to their learning needs in the cyber age
Which brings me to a related critical issue – the issue of implementing practical measures to improve the standards of education and language teaching at all levels
Ultimately, it is less about the medium of instruction – nor learning khat or wearing black shoes - but more about explaining to parents the rationale of multilingual pedagogy and affirming the nobility of the teaching profession
Developing cognitive and emotional intelligence in primary school children is only possible if we have teachers who are well trained in innovative pedagogy and critical or computational thinking. Entrance requirements for teaching programmes should be raised to ensure that applicants possess numeracy and literacy skills, and certainly high proficiency in the English language
Retain the talented teachers who are demonstrably innovative in their teaching methods to mentor junior teachers. This means higher investments in teachers are needed to raise the prestige of the teaching profession
While every Malaysian should master the national language, it should not diminish the importance of English as the medium of learning for the simple reason that English is the main language used online, in spite of Google translate, to access the world’s literature, philosophies and research across all fields
English was the medium of instruction during my time. I remember the government abolished English for Malay as the teaching language in the 70s to unite the rakyat. Inter-racial mistrust, however, lingers to this day
A national language or learning khat is less a ‘Malaysianising’ factor than the rule of law, good governance, fair access to economic opportunities, shared life goals, sincere inter-racial engagement, and, as the humanist would say, our duty to do right by each other
ERIC LOO is a Senior Fellow (Journalism) at the School of the Arts, English & Media, Faculty of Law, Humanities & Arts, University of Wollongong. He is also the founding editor of Asia Pacific Media Educator. - Mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2019/08/cutting-through-khat-kerfuffle.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+Must+Know

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Employing The Trust But Verify Policy For Khat Lessons

Employing The Trust But Verify Policy For Khat Lessons

papar berkaitan - pada 16/8/2019 - jumlah : 231 hits
I must admit I thoroughly enjoy watching DAP getting roasted by the anti khat crowd that acted out of fear and hatred DAP is having its comeuppance Having ridden on the beast of such negative sentiments to ballot success it now finds it ris...
Moving Forward From The Khat Debate

Moving Forward From The Khat Debate

papar berkaitan - pada 15/8/2019 - jumlah : 264 hits
A friend and fellow activist asked for my views regarding the khat issue I will try and articulate it in the best way possible In the first place just like the Selangor unilateral conversion bill I am unclear as to how the proposal to imple...
Khat What S The Big Fuss

Khat What S The Big Fuss

papar berkaitan - pada 13/8/2019 - jumlah : 245 hits
The fuss is not about learning Jawi writing The central issue is that education has opened the gateway for politicians religious political parties including the ulama and the so called Malay nationalists to advance their political and relig...
Khat Issue We Do Not Trust The Ministry And Its Transparency

Khat Issue We Do Not Trust The Ministry And Its Transparency

papar berkaitan - pada 25/8/2019 - jumlah : 251 hits
A coalition of 30 national NGOs and parties from the peninsula Sabah and Sarawak has urged the government to put the implementation of Jawi script on hold until a transparent and proper discussion with all relevant parties is held Coalition...
Khat After The Dust Has Settled Down

Khat After The Dust Has Settled Down

papar berkaitan - pada 11/8/2019 - jumlah : 271 hits
MP SPEAKS Good sense should prevail now that the dust has settled on the Jawi khat fuss Both sides should now close rank after the cabinet made its decision based on a general consensus Little did people realise that the Barisan Government ...
Let S Khat To The Chase Dr M Dong Zong Both Blundered

Let S Khat To The Chase Dr M Dong Zong Both Blundered

papar berkaitan - pada 16/8/2019 - jumlah : 243 hits
Introducing khat calligraphy into the primary school syllabus will not be the end of Malaysia Neither will signing a petition that makes your voice known Rather it is the endless and immature bickering between ethnic groups to show who has ...
Non Muslims Are Opposed To Khat Because It Is Religious Intrusion That Runs Contrary To The Country S Constitution

Non Muslims Are Opposed To Khat Because It Is Religious Intrusion That Runs Contrary To The Country S Constitution

papar berkaitan - pada 10/8/2019 - jumlah : 331 hits
Government modifies original proposal but Chinese and Indians still not happy P Ramasamy Malaysiakini Despite opposition the government has refused to backtrack on the introduction of khat or Jawi calligraphy in primary schools both nationa...
Justice Beyond Life Tun Mahathir S Tribute To A Fallen Comrade

Whistleblower Himself May Be Implicated In Assemblymen Bribery Case Says Source

Perempuan Terkejut Bila Bayar Rm8 40 Untuk Secawan Milo Panas

Poll Finds Malaysians Divided Over Blanket Ban On 3r Discussions

Minta 2 Dapat 1 Lagi Pendedahan Video Pemberi Maklumat

Dua Lelaki Tular Curi Motosikal Diburu

Celebrate A Peranakan Christmas In Kuala Lumpur With Santa Grand Signature S Exclusive Buffet

Time To Engage China In Its Terms


echo '';
Senarai Lagu Separuh Akhir Muzik Muzik 39 Semi Final Muzik Muzik SFMM 2024 Persaingan Merebut Tiket Ke AJL Anugerah Juara Lagu

Biodata Terkini Fairuz Selamat Q Face Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Penyanyi Lagu Izinkanlah

Biodata Terkini Arrora Salwa Salwa Razak Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Penyanyi Lagu Ahmad

Biodata Terkini Penyanyi Liza Aziz Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Adik Beradik Kepada Azlina Aziz

Senarai Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11 Tonton Konsert Minggu 1 Pada 24 November Live Di Astro Ria Sooka Online


Resepi Rojak Tauhu

Akhirnya Dato Sri Hajah Siti Nurhaliza Binti Tarudin Dinobatkan Sebagai Buduanita Negara

Pembungkusan Yang Berfungsi Menjaga Kesegaran Minyak Esensial

Makan Kerepek Pisang Tanduk Kawan Bagi

Family Mart Dan Gz Baiyun Airport Mehood Liz Hotel Guangzhou

Beg Tangan Jenis Mana Jadi Pilihan Wanita Moden