Are Malays Really Lagging Far Behind



A possible beneficial outcome of the controversy over the matriculation programme is the opening up of valid and trustworthy data on Malay participation in higher education and professional fields for public scrutiny
This is important and necessary so that stake players and politicians such as Education Minister Maszlee Malik do not confuse themselves or confuse others on the real extent to which the Malay community is lagging behind other communities
The data is also important as it will inform on whether past efforts at corrective policies have been successful or unsuccessful. This can then assure the public that the alleged imbalance in higher education and professions is based on facts and accurate data; and is not trotted out for political or racially opportunistic reasons
In this respect, it is encouraging to see that the UiTM vice-chancellor has come out with figures showing the lack of progress of bumiputera participation in two fields - medical (49 percent of total doctors) and engineering (34 percent of total engineers)
These figures do give the impression of a stagnation or decline in bumiputera participation in the two fields at least over the past decade
However, the figures that Prof Mohd Azraai Kassim cites come from non-official sources so there can be an issue of reliability. Also, they provide only a partial picture as they relate to only two occupational categories
It is obvious that data from non-official sources need to be compared with that emanating from government sources to enable a more objective and even-handed assessment of whatever topic is under scrutiny
A more holistic and comprehensive perspective of Malay participation is obtainable from the official data on bumiputera employment in 10 areas of high occupational categories found in the Third Outline Perspective Plan, 2001-2010. In fact, the data from this official source shows an encouraging and upward trend of bumiputera participation in key sectors for the period 1990 to 2007
Key questionsToday, 12 years after the authoritative picture of bumiputera participation provided by the BN government, has there been a regression or stagnation of the bumiputera position in the 10 high occupational areas to justify concern and the continuation of discriminatory policies
If the answer to this key question is yes, it must be backed up and confirmed by data which is unbiased to have any credibility. It is also best that this answer be provided by the appropriate authoritative agency rather than by individuals so that it can become the basis of policy deliberation at the highest level of government
In fact, data from UiTM where non-Malays are not permitted entry indicates that more than a million bumiputera, predominantly Malays, have graduated from that one university alone since it was established
As there are 20 public universities and even more polytechnics in the country with all of them having a Malay majority enrolment, this makes it scarcely believable that the Malays are still lagging so far behind in the higher education and professional fields as postulated by some quarters
A related consideration is that it may precisely be the massive over-production of Malay graduates and professionals which has led to the inability of the job market to absorb them. This over-production and lack of labour market appeal should be the focus of policy concern as much as the racial bias of employers
However, if the answer is no, then there is no justification whatsoever for the racial quota policies currently in place to bridge what is an illusory racial gap
And again, if the answer is yes - Malay participation is still lagging badly and thus warrants 90 percent of allocated matriculation places - a key question is:Why have the 20 public universities and UiTM which have taken up so much of the nation’s budgetary resources - tens if not hundreds of billions of ringgit at least since 1990 - not been able to do better in bridging the racial higher education and professional gap
A “yes” response also needs to be further analysed to find out whether it is Peninsular Malay or Sabah and Sarawak bumiputera participation that is lagging. If it is the latter, then what is needed is a different policy strategy that can secure the harmony and social justice ends that the UiTM VC has advocated
Hopefully, the UiTM and USM vice-chancellors and others defending the matriculation quota can respond to these questions so that we can light a candle rather than curse the darkness on this issue
LIM TECK GHEE is a public policy analyst and author of the book  - ‘Challenging Malaysia's Status Quo’. - mkini

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth/~3/IFuTnUeANjE/are-malays-really-lagging-far-behind.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
So If Umno Is Corrupt So Are Malays Do Malays Agree With Mat Hasan If Umno Looks Bad So Do Malays

So If Umno Is Corrupt So Are Malays Do Malays Agree With Mat Hasan If Umno Looks Bad So Do Malays

papar berkaitan - pada 12/5/2019 - jumlah : 71 hits
How the public perceives the Malays is tied to how they perceive Umno said the party s acting president Mohamad Hasan As such he said Umno must be mindful of how to act and speak Protecting the good name of Umno means protecting the good na...
What The F K Are You Doing Pelancong Kurang Ajar Berang Ditegur Kerana Mengemis Di Jonker Walk

What The F K Are You Doing Pelancong Kurang Ajar Berang Ditegur Kerana Mengemis Di Jonker Walk

papar berkaitan - pada 12/5/2019 - jumlah : 103 hits
Viral di media sosial video sekumpulan pelancong asing yang menjual barangan cenderahati di Jongker Walk Melaka mengundang pelbagai reaksi netizen Bukan sahaja jelas melakukan kesalahan dan menyalahgunakan pas lawatan sosial di negara ini m...
Selangor Sultan Malays Must Unite And Prevent Further Division

Selangor Sultan Malays Must Unite And Prevent Further Division

papar berkaitan - pada 30/5/2019 - jumlah : 78 hits
The strongest ever statement from a Malay ruler regarding Malay unity Selangor Ruler Sultan Sharafuddin Idris called upon all Malays to unite and prevent the community from being further divided In his address during the breaking of fast as...
Best Convertibles For 2019 Here Are 10 Fast Fun Options

Best Convertibles For 2019 Here Are 10 Fast Fun Options

papar berkaitan - pada 14/5/2019 - jumlah : 105 hits
Not everyone loves driving with the top down Yet I can think of no better way to welcome the warm and sunny weather than driving a convertible No matter what you call them convertibles have somehow lost their favor among the sea of new cros...
When White People Think They Are Superior

When White People Think They Are Superior

papar berkaitan - pada 15/5/2019 - jumlah : 49 hits
And have we heard people like George Clooney and Clare Rewcastle Brown condemn Saudi Arabia and organise a boycott of Saudi oil and set up Saudi Report to bring down the government so that a western democracy can take over the country and g...
Plant Closure And Relocation Of Production Lines Are Old News Says Chow

Plant Closure And Relocation Of Production Lines Are Old News Says Chow

papar berkaitan - pada 16/5/2019 - jumlah : 66 hits
Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow has criticised the MCA for trying to recycle old news about plant closures and relocation of production lines in Penang Chow said it was most unfortunate that MCA vice president Tan Teik Cheng tried to recycle o...
The Bright And The Dark Side Are We Being A Fake

The Bright And The Dark Side Are We Being A Fake

papar berkaitan - pada 16/5/2019 - jumlah : 97 hits
So I ve been thinking deeply about the personality of a human lately It s nothing too serious but just some kind of thoughts that occupied my head Tak tahu kalau orang lain ada terfikir macam ni jugak but if yes let me know your viewpoint a...
Palestine Arabs Malays

Palestine Arabs Malays

papar berkaitan - pada 30/5/2019 - jumlah : 31 hits
A commenter asked me what help I gave to that Palestinian student Years ago my wife and I set up a sort of fund for students at the UIA We wanted to help students who needed financial assistance It was not much just a very low key few thous...
Mat Hasan If Umno Looks Bad So Do The Malays

Mat Hasan If Umno Looks Bad So Do The Malays

papar berkaitan - pada 12/5/2019 - jumlah : 69 hits
How the public perceives the Malays is tied to how they perceive Umno said the party s acting president Mohamad Hasan As such he said Umno must be mindful of how to act and speak Protecting the good name of Umno means protecting the good na...
Dapat Pingat Dato Ke Haha

Ada Video Dari Indonesia Video Apa Tu Hishammuddin Rais

Benarkah Beliau Seorang Homoseks

Aliff Aziz Ditahan Polis Didakwa Mencuri Duit Artis Indonesia

Mesir Lebih Selamat Tanpa Morsi

Kini Menduda Ariff Aziz Dedah Digoda Ramai Wanita

5002 Mesyuarat Ppim Bersama Jabatan Penjara Dan Gisb Holdings Ppim 19 06 2019

Ali Jumaat Bukti Ilmu Tasawuff Adalah Dusta



Iquitos Bandar Terbesar Dunia Yang Tidak Boleh Diakses Melalui Jalan Darat

Sejarah Dan Sumbangan Besar Sultan Abdul Hamid Halim Shah Terhadap Kedah

Rujuk Ariff Aziz Rasa Nak Muntah

20 Tahun Diculik dan Diseksa Ayah Tiri Sendiri Kisah Rosalynn Michelle McGinnis

Fahami Tsundoku Budaya Beli Buku Banyak Banyak Tapi Tak Baca


Positifnya Seorang Guru

Panya Batik Group Kedai Pembuatan Batik Di Pak Bara

Cara Semak Samada Doktor Klinik Berdaftar Atau Tidak Dengan Kkm

Model Antarabangsa Tawan Dunia Dengan Muka Jeragat Mereka

Kincir Angin Pulau Perhentian Yang Semakin Tak Terjaga

Cara Yang Betul Bancuh Susu Formula Untuk Anak