Apex Court Rules Crash Victims Should Be Automatically Compensated


 
Federal Court judge Abdul Rahman Sebli says the provisions in the Road Transport Act should be construed to protect all motorists, including accident victims and innocent third parties.PUTRAJAYA: In a landmark ruling, the Federal Court has held that road accident victims should be automatically compensated without having to sue insurance companies.
Federal Court judge Abdul Rahman Sebli said the provisions in the Road Transport Act 1987 should be construed to protect all motorists, including victims of road accidents.
He said the intention of Parliament in enacting the Act was to also protect innocent third party road users.
Rahman, who led a three-member bench, said this in his 140-page judgment that allowed appeals involving eight different motorists, seven of whom were injured in accidents.
-ADVERTISEMENT-Ads by 
Of the eight appeals, five involved Pacific & Orient Insurance Co Bhd, Amgeneral Insurance Bhd, Allianz General Insurance Company (M) Bhd, and Malaysian Motor Insurance Pool.
The bench, also consisting of Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and Rhodzariah Bujang, awarded RM150,000 in costs to each of the successful parties in the appeal.
In explaining the court’s decision, delivered last week, Rahman said all vehicle owners had to have compulsory insurance coverage.
The law was that without insurance coverage, the road transport department would not issue the road tax, he said.
If a vehicle injured a victim, that person could sue the owner or the driver of the vehicle.
This was because if the vehicle owner had insurance coverage, the insurer (insurance company) would automatically step in and “indemnify” the victim, without the victim having to sue the insurer.
In some cases, compensation could run into millions of ringgit and insurance companies would pay the damages to the victims on behalf of the motorists.
Rahman said the Act had to balance two competing interests. The first was to protect innocent third parties against the risks.
On the other hand, he said, the law had to protect an insurance company from being victimised by fraudulent claims.
In setting the balance between these two competing interests, at the end of the day, the loss had to fall on one party.
In following the principle established in a 1959 Indian Supreme Court case (British India General Insurance v Capt Itbar Singh), the apex court said that if the loss had to fall on one party, the Act had decided that such a loss should be borne by the insurer.
The victims had filed a negligence suit in the sessions courts against owners of vehicles and/or drivers for damages.
The appeals came about as the insurance companies had obtained a declaration in the High Court to nullify policies of motorists due to allegations of misconduct on the part of the vehicles owners.
This had denied accident victims monetary compensation that had been due to them.
In one of the cases, the vehicle owner had “sold” the vehicle to a third party through what is known as “sambung bayar” (continuing payments), without informing the insurance company.
They succeeded in asking the High Court to declare the policies void. Using that order, the insurance companies refused to cover the victim’s loss. In the end the victims lost out.
In another case, despite the fact that after a full trial the sessions court had found the driver of the vehicle negligent, the insurance company had taken a court order, alleging it had been defrauded. It declined to pay the vehicle owner.
Eventually, the victim merely held a paper judgment, which the Federal Court said was “not even worth the paper it was written on”.
The court said this was unfair because the victim’s constitutional rights to be treated fairly had been infringed.
The road victims were represented by lawyers Ganavathy Naidu, Harjeet Singh Sidhu, Rajan Ayyapan, Adrian Thambyrajah, Manoharan Veerasamy, G Ravichandran, BP Jayaprathap and GK Ganesan.
The insurers were represented by RK Nathan, Vinod Kamalanathan, Silva Velu, Reuben Netto, VK Dasaratha Raj and R Ratha Davi.
In response to the judgment, a lawyer said that in the last decade, many grey areas had sprung up in motor accident cases
“This uncertainty has caused huge problems for innocent road victims. This case resolves those difficulties in one fell swoop,” the lawyer, who asked not to be named, told FMT. - FMT


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2022/08/apex-court-rules-crash-victims-should.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Insurers Should Automatically Compensate Crash Victims Apex Court

Insurers Should Automatically Compensate Crash Victims Apex Court

papar berkaitan - pada 10/8/2022 - jumlah : 129 hits
The Federal Court ruled today that victims of road accidents should automatically be given compensation without having to sue insurance companies According to Free Malaysia Today judge Abdul Rahman Sebli ruled in his 140 page judgement that...
Penang Should Withdraw Motion To Disqualify Us From Our Seats Bersatu Reps Say After Federal Court Decision

Penang Should Withdraw Motion To Disqualify Us From Our Seats Bersatu Reps Say After Federal Court Decision

papar berkaitan - pada 4/8/2022 - jumlah : 62 hits
If the Penang state government is genuine in its claim and in the spirit of bipartisanship we believe that the motions to disqualify us should be withdrawn The Penang state government should withdraw its motion to disqualify the four Parti ...
Rewcastle Brown S Bid To Challenge Defamation Charge Premature Rules Court

Rewcastle Brown S Bid To Challenge Defamation Charge Premature Rules Court

papar berkaitan - pada 12/8/2022 - jumlah : 54 hits
Clare Rewcastle Brown is accused of defaming Terengganu s Sultanah Nur Zahirah in her book The Sarawak Report The Inside Story of the 1MDB Expose KUALA LUMPUR The High Court here has ruled that it is premature to refer to the Federal Court ...
In 2 1 Decision Court Of Appeal Rules Malaysian Mums Cannot Pass Citizenship To Overseas Born Kids

In 2 1 Decision Court Of Appeal Rules Malaysian Mums Cannot Pass Citizenship To Overseas Born Kids

papar berkaitan - pada 5/8/2022 - jumlah : 63 hits
In this case the Malaysian government had appealed against the High Court s September 2021 decision which recognised that Malaysia s citizenship laws discriminated against women and which had ruled that Malaysian mothers whose children are ...
Penang S Anti Hopping Law Is Valid Apex Court

Penang S Anti Hopping Law Is Valid Apex Court

papar berkaitan - pada 3/8/2022 - jumlah : 115 hits
The Federal Court has ruled in favour of the validity of Penang s anti hopping law The seven person bench chaired by Chief Justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat today made the unanimous ruling over the referral question on the legality and constit...
Accept Fate With An Open Heart And Be Grateful Sanusi Tells Baling Flood Victims

Accept Fate With An Open Heart And Be Grateful Sanusi Tells Baling Flood Victims

papar berkaitan - pada 3/8/2022 - jumlah : 129 hits
Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor today urged the victims of massive floods that ravaged 12 villages and killed three people in Kupang here to accept their fate with an open heart and be grateful for the other blessings grante...
30 Election Seats For Women Should Be Law Says Wanita Bn

30 Election Seats For Women Should Be Law Says Wanita Bn

papar berkaitan - pada 15/8/2022 - jumlah : 82 hits
BN women are ready for the general election Wanita BN chairman Noraini Ahmad said at the women s wing congress today KUALA LUMPUR Wanita Barisan Nasional has called for a 30 allocation of seats for women to be made a legal requirement for a...
Scam Victims Harrowing Tale Of Trafficking Torture And Escape

Scam Victims Harrowing Tale Of Trafficking Torture And Escape

papar berkaitan - pada 6/8/2022 - jumlah : 158 hits
In January 23 year old Mah boarded a flight that would land him a lucrative job at a casino in Sihanoukville Cambodia Or so he thought The Sibu native was told about the job by a friend and so he took the plane from Singapore to Phnom Penh ...
Forgotten Malaysian Victims Of Hiroshima Atomic Bombing

Forgotten Malaysian Victims Of Hiroshima Atomic Bombing

papar berkaitan - pada 14/8/2022 - jumlah : 77 hits
The grave of Nik Yusof Nik Ali one of two Malaysians who died in the atomic bombing of Hiroshima GEORGE TOWN Every year when the world mourns the victims of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima Japan on Aug 6 1945 only a few people remember the ...
Sorry Kak Saya Tak Tahu Dia Ada Isteri Isteri Londeh Amp Tampar Pelacur Yang Lakukan Hubungan Intim Dengan Suaminya

Perodua Axia Baru 2023 Harga Auto Manual Model Terkini

Kisah Kota Lgbt Yang Di Lenyapkan Dari Muka Bumi

Pelanggan Louis Vuitton Ditikam Darah Berlumuran Di Lantai

Suami Fatin Afeefa Dikecam Kerana Berlagak Sekali Ada Orang Cuba Nak Dedahkan Kisah Silam Dia

Senarai Taska Di Malaysia Kadar Yuran Terkini

Bahaya Bulu Kucing Untuk Kesihatan Manusia

Senarai Travel Agency Memiliki Lesen Pengelola Jemaah Haji 2023



5 Permainan Video Popular Sepanjang Zaman

8 Fakta Biodata Pelakon Sophia Albarakbah Gandingan Terbaru Aliff Aziz Drama Ku Akad Kau Dengan Bismillah

8 Kenderaan Ikonik Dalam Industri Filem dan Drama

Kahwin Beristerikan Nad Zainal Ini 10 Fakta Biodata Pelakon Ungku Ismail Aziz

5 Kelebihan Terbesar Sewa Rumah Berbanding Miliki Sendiri


Kj S Sacking H2o S Suspension Are Long Overdue

Petnah Dengar Ahlong Gulung Tukar

Imam Fahreza Feat Cica Rama Serpihan Cinta Chord

Disheartening That Malaysian Muslims Have To Defend Their Religion In Their Own Country

Friends Family And Colleagues Say Goodbye To Sri Ram

Projek Csr Darihati123mamanet Kali 9 Sempena Ulangtahun Bandaraya Shah Alam Ke 22 Tahun