People Over Cars Rethinking Highway Development For Real Growth


 
The West Coast Expressway (WCE), which links Banting to Gelang Patah, is unlikely to drive meaningful growth in smaller towns along its route, despite what deputy minister Ahmad Maslan claimed recently.
There’s very little evidence to suggest that toll highways actually do spur local development in smaller towns. In fact, they have often had the opposite effect—bringing about economic stagnation or even decline.
The experience of towns in Perak along the North-South Expressway (NSE) is a telling example.
When the NSE bypassed these communities, it took much of their economic vitality with it, resulting in lower property values, dwindling businesses, job losses and a steady population decline.
Towns like Taiping, Kuala Kangsar, Batu Gajah, Sungkai, Bidor and Tanjung Malim—once bustling stops on traditional routes—have seen their vibrancy fade over the years since the NSE opened.
Toll highways discourage travellers from stopping for leisure or business; they’re designed for swift transit between cities, bypassing the local economy altogether.
This suggests that toll highways may not be the best strategy for fostering regional growth.
Planning alternatives
Rather than investing heavily in toll highways, the government should focus on real transport infrastructure planning — aimed at directly connecting communities, reducing travel barriers, and providing opportunities to use public transport over private cars.
A better approach would be to develop comprehensive road and rail networks, integrated with commuter services, to support the economies of smaller towns.
Currently, development is heavily concentrated in the Klang Valley, and most infrastructure projects—road and rail—run north to south, once again centred on Kuala Lumpur.
There’s a glaring lack of connectivity between the west and east coasts of the peninsula. Vast areas on the eastern seaboard of Pahang and Johor remain isolated, undeveloped and largely inaccessible.
A more thoughtful approach to infrastructure planning would prioritise direct connections between the west and east coasts, connecting small towns to big cities and fostering movement within regions, rather than simply channelling traffic past them.
The belief that highways stimulate local economies is outdated and unsupported by empirical data.
If small towns were connected by rail and commuter services were made available, the cost of living there would be much lower compared to the expense of big city life.
Instead of relying on toll-based highways, a community-focused road network plan, complementary to rail travel, would better support small-town growth.
Similarly, rather than running a high-speed rail line only from north to south, the government should consider developing a network of double-tracked railways to encourage development across the entire country.
Other countries—Japan, the UK, France, Germany, and China—have built thriving economies on the backbone of extensive rail networks across smaller towns and cities, east and west, north and south, supporting both passenger and freight transport.
That is the true meaning of development—an equal opportunity that supports regional growth.
Cost per km
Many transport studies have shown that the per-km costs, both for passenger and cargo services, are much lower for rail than highways. This means rail fares and cargo charges are lower, benefiting the lower-to middle-income groups—the B40 and M40.
Government planners and politicians need to understand these calculations if they are to make informed decisions that benefit 80% of our country’s population.
Toll highways are primarily designed to facilitate inter-urban travel, efficiently moving vehicles—especially freight traffic—between major urban centres while largely ignoring the towns and communities in between.
But when compared on a per-tonne/km basis, their service costs are much higher.
By contrast, a well-integrated network of roads and railways could enable direct connections between smaller towns and nearby cities, creating a sustainable foundation for local economic growth.
A comprehensive rail network would make it easier for people to travel within a region, encouraging regular commutes and inter-town business. Making smaller towns more accessible without imposing tolls would drive passenger traffic and boost local businesses.
Quality of life
When communities are connected by affordable and direct transit options, travellers are more likely to stop in these towns, supporting local shops, businesses, restaurants and tourism activities.
This continuous flow of people would be more beneficial to local economies than the toll-driven traffic of expressways that bypass smaller towns.
Rail connectivity, in particular, could be transformative for smaller towns, offering a cost-effective alternative to car travel.
An integrated commuter rail network would allow residents to enjoy a better quality of life—living in quieter, less congested towns while working in nearby cities.
This, in turn, could relieve urban congestion, revive local real estate markets, and stimulate small-town economies by fostering both residential and commercial growth.
Focusing on accessible, integrated transport options would also yield significant environmental benefits, promoting long-term sustainability.
Improved rail and public transit options reduce dependency on individual cars, cutting carbon emissions—an essential consideration in any new infrastructure project today.
By enhancing connectivity without creating financial barriers like tolls, the government could support an economic and environmental landscape that benefits residents, attracts visitors, and strengthens small businesses.
In summary, shifting from toll highways to inclusive transport networks which combine rail lines with road networks will create a more connected, economically viable region.
It would stimulate local economies, support sustainable development and build resilient communities.
By focusing on moving people instead of moving cars, the government can enable real, lasting growth in these towns and regions. - FMT
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2024/11/people-over-cars-rethinking-highway.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
The Real Mandate Putting The Economy First For Malaysia S Future

The Real Mandate Putting The Economy First For Malaysia S Future

papar berkaitan - pada 7/11/2024 - jumlah : 277 hits
The U S presidential election and Malaysian politics mungkin nampak jauh berbeza but sebenarnya there are many parallels that reveal how divided societies are wrestling with identity power and the future Sama seperti di Amerika Syarikat pol...
Driver Arrested Over Fatal Hit And Run On Bukit Jalil Highway

Driver Arrested Over Fatal Hit And Run On Bukit Jalil Highway

papar berkaitan - pada 19/11/2024 - jumlah : 194 hits
A screenshot taken from a dashboard camera of the hit and run on the Bukit Jalil Highway last Friday in which a seven year old girl died KUALA LUMPUR Police have arrested a man believed to be involved in the hit and run that killed a girl a...
Who Would Be Eligible For Ron95 Subsidy Putrajaya Says It Depends On Size Of Households And Number Of Cars

Who Would Be Eligible For Ron95 Subsidy Putrajaya Says It Depends On Size Of Households And Number Of Cars

papar berkaitan - pada 19/11/2024 - jumlah : 209 hits
Deputy Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister Fuziah Salleh speaks in the Dewan Rakyat Bernama picKUALA LUMPUR Nov 18 Putrajaya said today that a Malaysian s eligibility for RON95 subsidy will among others be determined by the size of h...
Villagers Allegedly Beats Up Driver For Running Over Child

Villagers Allegedly Beats Up Driver For Running Over Child

papar berkaitan - pada 21/11/2024 - jumlah : 307 hits
SHOULD drivers be condemned when they hit and run Ethically help should be offered to the victim on the spot but sometimes the situation isn t always so simple In a viral video post on X by netizen ziqman a child could be seen run over by a...
What Is The Best Laser Cap For Hair Growth

What Is The Best Laser Cap For Hair Growth

papar berkaitan - pada 8/11/2024 - jumlah : 336 hits
What is the best laser cap for hair growthSome studies have found that it s effective on its own in helping to stimulate your scalp to grow new hair The advantages of laser cap therapy are that it s safe effective noninvasive and completely...
Riyadh Summit Mosques Under Jakim To Hold Special Prayers For Pm

Riyadh Summit Mosques Under Jakim To Hold Special Prayers For Pm

papar berkaitan - pada 10/11/2024 - jumlah : 181 hits
Three mosques under the purview of the Islamic Development Department have been asked to hold solat hajat to pray for the success of Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim s mission as he represents Malaysia at the Arab Islamic Extraordinary Summit i...
Vincent Tan Tears Into Muhyiddin Govt For Pushing Single 5g Network

Vincent Tan Tears Into Muhyiddin Govt For Pushing Single 5g Network

papar berkaitan - pada 11/11/2024 - jumlah : 226 hits
U Mobile Sdn Bhd chairman Vincent Tan said RM16 5 billion in public funds are at stake due to the monopolistic single 5G network model chosen by the PN led government PETALING JAYA U Mobile Sdn Bhd chairman Vincent Tan has trained his guns ...
Eaic Calls For Task Force To Probe Large Scale Misconduct

Eaic Calls For Task Force To Probe Large Scale Misconduct

papar berkaitan - pada 10/11/2024 - jumlah : 150 hits
EAIC chairman Ismail Bakar said a task force could carry out investigations jointly comprehensively and openly KUCHING A task force needs to be set up to tackle serious issues involving large scale misconduct of public interest more effecti...
Ayam Masak Palembang Sedap Pekat Dan Padu

Foreign Workers Or Pedophiles Large Number Of Migrants At Playground Sparks Debate

Tahniah Marygrace Juara Calpis Soda One In A Million

Why Asean Needs To Be Understood On The Terms Of The Un And Asean Charter

Ransomware And Medical Devices The Growing Threat And How To Mitigate Risks

Beli Dragon Fruit Di Kuala Pilah

Iphone 11 Akan Dilancarkan Pada 11 September Ini

Tahun Baru Cina Di Menara Condong Teluk Intan


echo '';
Keputusan Markah Konsert Akhir Final Gegar Vaganza 2024 2025 GV 11 Juara Pemenang Finalis

Senarai Lagu Tugasan Konsert Akhir Gegar Vaganza 2024 2025 Musim 11 Minggu 12

Keputusan Markah Peserta Konsert Minggu 11 Gegar Vaganza 2024 2025 Musim 11 Separuh Akhir

5 Undang Undang Aneh Berkait Bendera Kebangsaan di Seluruh Dunia

Benarkah Kajian Sains Membolehkan Gigi Manusia Tumbuh Selepas Hilang


Mvhs Student Melds Fishkeeping Artistry With Dynamic Tankscapes The Lincoln County News

Thomas Arya Hanya Bisa Berharap Chord

Lirik Lagu Melopong Amsyar Leee Feat Bunga

Lirik Lagu Myvi Luqman Podolski

Staycation Pertama Bersama Baby Muqarrabin

Panduan Praktis Cara Memilih Ac Hemat Energi Untuk Lingkungan Kerja