No Immunity For Those Who Tell On Police Reports Court Warns


PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court today cautioned that those who disclose their police reports to the public may face the risk of civil action against them in court
Justice Azahar Mohamed, who read the judgment in a case involving defamation, said people who disclosed the contents of their police reports to the public did not enjoy the right of absolute privilege
Absolute privilege is an immunity for individuals, especially elected representatives, who make statements within the legislature regardless of whether their statements are malicious or not
Azahar said the legal position in Malaysia was that a person making a police report was immune from legal action against him or her
“However, we do not see a reason, on grounds of public policy, that the complainant should be free from accountability by way of defamation when publishing their statement to the public
“There is no sufficient basis or necessity to expand the ambit of absolute privilege to cover the subsequent publication of the report at large,” the judge said in delivering judgment in the defamation case against local actress Zahida Rafik
Zahida was sued for defamation by her former driver, Noor Azman Azemi, whom she accused of stealing RM200,000 six years ago. She was initially ordered to pay RM150,000 for slandering him over the stolen money
She later won a counter-claim against him when the Court of Appeal ordered Azman to pay Zahida RM200,000, the amount she said he had stolen from her. The court also set aside the earlier judgment in favour of Azman
Azman then appealed the Court of Appeal’s decision, and posed a legal question as to whether disclosing the contents of a police report was protected under the defence of absolute privilege
The question of law came about when Azman pointed out that Zahida had, after making her police report against him, divulged the contents of her report to the media. Zahida, in the course of the trial, had claimed absolute privilege
In answering Azman’s question, the Federal Court today said those who repeated the contents of such reports could not enjoy absolute privilege
The court said this in upholding the lower court’s decision ordering him to return the RM200,000 allegedly stolen from Zahida
Azahar also said the courts should not unnecessarily extend the perimeters of absolute privilege
“Otherwise it would result in irresponsible individuals slandering others with impunity,” he said, adding that the country’s laws on libel and slander gave aggrieved parties an avenue to defend their reputation
Lawyer Latheefa Koya, representing Azman, said the decision today set a strong precedent as police report complainants should avoid repeating the report’s contents
“A police report is filed because the complainant wants the authorities to investigate their claims
“When a person comes out of the police station after filing the report and then repeats what he or she said to the police, what would be their intention? They have to justify their remarks,” she said
Today’s five-member bench was chaired by Court of Appeal president Ahmad Maarop. Others on the bench, apart from Azahar, were Alizatul Khair Osman, Rohana Yusof and Zawawi Salleh. FMT

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth/~3/VCRmTCe7FoU/no-immunity-for-those-who-tell-on.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
Why No Police Action Against Those Who Provoke And Incite Hate Against Our Multi Racial Community

Why No Police Action Against Those Who Provoke And Incite Hate Against Our Multi Racial Community

papar berkaitan - pada 21/1/2019 - jumlah : 36 hits
Of late there had been a lot of statements and speech provoking and inciting hate against a certain race in Malaysia At the Cameron Highlands parliamentary by elections this provoking and inciting has intensified But to our surprise no arre...
Still Un Named T Ganu Rep Hides His Face With Cap After Court Remands Him For 3 Days To Help In Macc Corruption Probe

Still Un Named T Ganu Rep Hides His Face With Cap After Court Remands Him For 3 Days To Help In Macc Corruption Probe

papar berkaitan - pada 21/1/2019 - jumlah : 64 hits
KUALA TERENGGANU A Terengganu state assemblyman with a Datuk title has been remanded for three days to help in investigations in connection to alleged false claims of RM500 000 made last year The remand order which begins today was issued b...
No Need For A Constitutional Court Law Minister

No Need For A Constitutional Court Law Minister

papar berkaitan - pada 28/1/2019 - jumlah : 59 hits
There is no need for a Constitutional Court in Malaysia as the Federal Court can handle such cases Minister in the Prime Minister s Department Liew Vui Keong said today According to Liew the seven judge bench of the Federal Court will handl...
It Was Husam Who Lobbied For Ku Li To Become Pm

It Was Husam Who Lobbied For Ku Li To Become Pm

papar berkaitan - pada 23/1/2019 - jumlah : 56 hits
So that is the full story and Kit Siang has just related a small part of it regarding PAS wanting Ku Li and not Anwar as the Prime Minister The key people in pushing for Ku Li as Prime Minister have all since left PAS and are now in PAN or ...
Police 17 Reports Lodged Over Camerons By Election

Police 17 Reports Lodged Over Camerons By Election

papar berkaitan - pada 22/1/2019 - jumlah : 45 hits
A total of 17 police reports have been lodged during 10 days of the campaign for the Cameron Highlands parliamentary by election said District Police Chief DSP Ashari Abu Samah He said the reports were in connection to giving money damaged ...
Court Sets Feb 7 8 For Hearing Of Najib S Appeals

Court Sets Feb 7 8 For Hearing Of Najib S Appeals

papar berkaitan - pada 23/1/2019 - jumlah : 46 hits
PUTRAJAYA The Court of Appeal has set two days beginning Feb 7 to hear three appeals by former prime minister Najib Razak over interlocutory matters in relation to his criminal charges on SRC International funds Court of Appeal registrar No...
Altantuya S Cousin S Testimony In Court Contradicts The French Police Testimony

Altantuya S Cousin S Testimony In Court Contradicts The French Police Testimony

papar berkaitan - pada 30/1/2019 - jumlah : 86 hits
The French police report done at the behest of Suaram destroys the RM100 million suit as none of the stories in the Malaysian court match what the French police reported to the French court NO HOLDS BARRED Raja Petra Kamarudin The testimony...
Ex Mp Police Probe Against Me For Fb Post On Guan Eng S Son Is Clear Abuse Of Power

Ex Mp Police Probe Against Me For Fb Post On Guan Eng S Son Is Clear Abuse Of Power

papar berkaitan - pada 17/1/2019 - jumlah : 53 hits
A former MP has accused police of abuse of power for investigating him over a Facebook post in which he took potshots at a minister s son for his clothes Former Nibong Tebal MP Tan Tee Beng today said he was willing to face any civil suit b...
15 Absolutely Easy Diy Crafts For Kids To Do Over The Weekend

15 Absolutely Easy Diy Crafts For Kids To Do Over The Weekend

papar berkaitan - pada 19/1/2019 - jumlah : 102 hits
The weekend is here and you gotta find some way to get your kids busy otherwise they ll get bored You could always watch a family movie together but that should not be your first choice The post appeared first on

Nampak Tak Mana Silapnya Lepas Sejam Gambar Diambil Ibu Hilang 2 Anak Dalam Kemalangan

Video Daripada Tukar Moara Baik Tukar Perdana Menteri Tmj

Baca Ayat Ini Sebanyak 7 Kali Selepas Solat Fardhu Pesanan Ustaz Ebit Lew

Mahathir Tak Faham Perlembagaan Shad Saleem

Penyamun Melawat Penyamun

Inilah Gaji Para Pelakon Avengers Untuk Setiap Filem Marvel

10 Fesyen Selebriti Hollywood Yang Ditiru Semula Dalam Versi Bajet Ini Serius Menghiburkan

Dr Mahathir Bidas Pengkritik Mb Johor



Ini Sebab Kenapa Kereta Buatan Amerika Syarikat Tak Laku Di Jepun

8 Fakta Dan Fungsi Sebenar Paru Paru Yang Ramai Tak Tahu

5 Filem Superhero Marvel Paling Mengecewakan

Kisah Piramid Di Sudan Negara Paling Banyak Piramid Dan Dilupakan

Kisah Hermann G ring Orang Nombor 2 Nazi Yang Jarang Diperkatakan


Senarai Tonggak 12 Perkhidmatan Awam

5 Sebab Berbuka Puasa Dengan Buffet Ramadan

Semperit Red Velvet Cheese Enak Rasanya

Yang Di Pertua Negeri Pulau Pinang Cadang Bangunan Dun Baru

Zakat Fitrah Ikut Harga Beras Rm7 Makan Beras Tempatan Rm14 Berat Import

Norwegian Cruise Line Unveils Photos Of Norwegian Sky S 2019 Bow To Stern Renovation