Israel And The Principle Of Self Defence Under International Law


 


At the hearing of South Africa’s application for provisional measures before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) recently, the Israeli legal team raised its theory of self-defence in rebutting South Africa’s arguments that Israel had committed the crime of genocide.
If such a defence is accepted by the world court, the allegation by South Africa that Israel has committed genocidal crimes under the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (“Genocide Convention”) would not be legally sustainable.
This article, therefore, seeks to discuss Israel’s claim of self-defence under international law. As far as international law is concerned, a state’s right to self-defence in any armed conflict is duly enshrined in Article 51 of the UN Charter.
We may safely say that the right to self-defence in Article 51 of the UN Charter is essentially an exception to the prohibition of the use of force duly prescribed under Article 2 (4) of the same Charter.
In relying on Article 51 of the UN Charter, Israel certainly has no problem in establishing one of the important ingredients of that provision, ie, the existence of an armed attack. It is not disputed that there was an armed attack against Israel on Oct 7, 2023.
According to the typology of armed conflicts in International Humanitarian law (IHL) there are basically two types of armed conflicts. namely international armed conflicts (IAC) and non-international armed conflicts (NIAC).
In simple terms, the IAC entails an armed conflict between two or more sovereign states whereas the NIAC deals with any armed conflict involving non-state actors. The question is how do we characterise the present war between Israel-Hamas? Does such an armed conflict fall under the IAC or NIAC?
Two arguments
Apparently, there are two opinions on this issue. One view seems to suggest that such a war falls under the rubric of IAC. The Supreme Court of Israel clearly holds this view.
But the problem with this proposition is that Hamas is neither a state nor are its attacks likely attributable to a state.
As Hamas is definitely a non-state actor as far as IHL is concerned, some scholars are of the view that the current ongoing war between Israel and Hamas could only be categorised as an NIAC.
Assuming the second view is legally correct, can Israel, therefore, be salvaged under self-defence in Article 51 of the UN Charter, thus justifying its counterattacks against Hamas?
To begin with, it is well accepted that the right of self-defence is limited to states. In an article published in the American Journal of International Law on this very subject, Josep L Kunz argues: “But the ‘armed attack’ must not only be directed against a state, it must also be made by a state or with the approval of a state.”
Kunz’s argument is duly fortified by the ICJ in the case of Nicaragua v United States when it ruled that armed attacks shall consist of state regular forces’ attacks outside its borders or attacks by irregular forces executing on behalf of that state.
Hence, for self-defence to bite, Israel badly needs to prove either Hamas is part of state regular forces of the Palestinian Authority or that when Hamas launched its armed attack or aggression against Israel, it executed such an armed attack on behalf of the Palestinian Authority.
Proportionality
It is also pertinent to state here that in 2003 the ICJ also ruled that an occupying power like Israel cannot claim the right to self-defence. The decision was delivered by the ICJ when it gave its advisory opinion in a case involving Israel’s construction of a separation wall in the occupied West Bank (“The Wall case”).
Anyway, for the sake of argument, let us assume Israel is entitled to rely on Article 51 of the UN Charter. Does it mean Israel can exercise such a defence without any restraint whatsoever?
It is a trite law that any exercise of self-defence would be subject to some recognised qualifications or restraints. The world court has decided in a few cases that self-defence ought to be exercised proportionately.
When South Africa categorically states in its pleading that Israel has allegedly killed over 21,110 named Palestinians, including over 7,729 children - with over 7,780 others missing, presumed dead under the rubble - and has injured over 55,243 other Palestinians, Israel, in my view, might face an uphill task to convince the ICJ that it has exercised its self-defence proportionately.
In the case of Nuclear Weapons Advisory Opinion Armed Activities Judgement the ICJ also held that self-defence is also subject to a condition of necessity (see para 41 of the judgment). - Mkini
MOHAMED HANIPA MAIDIN is former Sepang MP and former deputy minister in the prime minister’s department.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.


Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2024/01/israel-and-principle-of-self-defence.html

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
The Opposition S Fake 120 Mps List

The Opposition S Fake 120 Mps List

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 282 hits
With less than 3 weeks before Sultan Ibrahim of Johor is scheduled to be sworn in as Malaysia s 17th Yang di Pertuan Agong the clock is ticking as more crooks are in the queue to be charged At least two former Prime Ministers Muhyiddin Yass...
Let The Market Deal With Ali Baba

Let The Market Deal With Ali Baba

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 258 hits
The call for anti Ali Baba legislation ostensibly aims to curb the use of business licences by migrant workers and contribute to better targeting and use of government subsidies Unfortunately it also stirs unpleasant anti foreigner overtone...
Looking At The Anwar Ibrahim Administration Through A Situational Audit Framework

Looking At The Anwar Ibrahim Administration Through A Situational Audit Framework

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 251 hits
Murray Hunter This was a journal article published in the Conflict and Peace Studies Journal at Prince of Songkla University This article looked at the Anwar government s first 3 months in office The notes I have added looks at how the traj...
The Holes In 120 Sds Claim

The Holes In 120 Sds Claim

papar berkaitan - pada 7/1/2024 - jumlah : 261 hits
Political observers are on alert after a blogger in exile claimed that the opposition has managed to gain around 120 statutory declarations to topple the Anwar Ibrahim administration PAS election director Muhammad Sanusi Md Noor who has bee...
Is The Chinese Miracle Over

Is The Chinese Miracle Over

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 232 hits
China s economic performance over the last year has been disappointing so much so that some observers argue that growth has already peaked and that it is all downhill from here But it is far too soon to write off China s economic resilience...
The Art Of English Elegance In Rural Home Design

The Art Of English Elegance In Rural Home Design

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 262 hits
Nestled within the picturesque landscapes of the countryside rural homes offer a unique canvas for design that echoes the charm and sophistication of English elegance The art of infusing classic English elements into rural home The post app...
72 Hari Survivor Nahas Pesawat Jadi Kanibal Demi Teruskan Society Of The Snow

72 Hari Survivor Nahas Pesawat Jadi Kanibal Demi Teruskan Society Of The Snow

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 201 hits
Sebenarnya yang meninggal lebih selamat berbanding yang masih bernyawa Itu ungkapan yang boleh penulis gambarkan kepada sebuah kisah keajaiban dan tragis ini 72 Hari Jadi Kanibal Society of The SnowSeorang penumpang di dalam pesawat malang ...
Kisah Misteri Tanah Perkuburan Kim Hyunjoo Kembali Dengan The Bequethed Januari Ini

Kisah Misteri Tanah Perkuburan Kim Hyunjoo Kembali Dengan The Bequethed Januari Ini

papar berkaitan - pada 8/1/2024 - jumlah : 131 hits
Pelakon Kim Hyun joo dan Park Hee soon bersama dengan pengarah Yeon Sang ho telah bekerjasama untuk sebuah projek ARTIKEL BERKAITAN Di mana mereka akan mendedahkan kisah misteri yang tidak dapat diramalkan melalui siri terbaru Netflix iaitu...
Unlocking Savings Expert Tips For Finding Discounted Cigarettes In Australia

Anwar Slams Hypocritical Criticism Over His Response To Najib S Apology

A Sucker Punch For Rm1 000 What S The Value Of Dignity In Malaysia

Sindiket Caj Rm15 000 Bawa Masuk Warga Bangladesh Ke Malaysia Tumpas

Makan Malam Tiga Beranak Di Adam Kitchen

Rakyat Malaysia Jadi Tentera Upahan Di Ukraine Dipercayai Masih Hidup Kpn

Tan Sri Vincent Tan Dan U Mobile

Empat Sekawan Dipenjara Tiga Tahun Culik Budak Perempuan


echo '';
Biodata Terkini Penyanyi Illa Sabry Peserta Gegar Vaganza 2024 Musim 11 GV11

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Senyawa iQIYI Malaysia

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Berepisod Project Projek Exit Astro Originals

Pelajari Asal Usul Nama Makhluk Seram Kisah Fiksyen Barat Yang Terkenal

10 Fakta Filem Kahar Kapla High Council Yang Ramai Tak Tahu Prekuel Drama Project Projek High Council


Anwar Selar Kritikan Hipokrit Atas Respons Mohon Maaf Najib

Resipi Sup Keting Masak Sendiri Baru Puas Boleh Makan Banyak

Tak Perlu Layan Dakwaan Jejaka Umur Baru 35 Tahun Dah Ada Simpanan Kwsp Lebih Dari Rm2 Juta

Perang Ekonomi As China M Sia Pas Sertai Brics

Mistakes To Avoid When Installing Glass Block In Your Next Project

Malaysia Singapore To Jointly Nominate Chingay For Unesco List