Asia Should Fix Its Megacities Not Move Them


Asia’s biggest cities, from Shanghai to Dhaka, are struggling to manage the impact of decades of growth. Some are sinking. Most are traffic-choked. And almost all struggle with chronic air pollution. Worst of all, coastal cities face the threat of being inundated by rising seas
Indonesia’s capital Jakarta suffers these urban ills more acutely than most, which is why President Joko Widodo announced a plan last week to shift the government some 1,450km away, to a relatively undeveloped section of Borneo
Indonesia isn’t the first Asian country to move its official capital and won’t be the last. But evacuating government officials and their families won’t solve the problems of Jakarta, Bangkok, Dhaka or any other megacity
Given how many people will continue to live in those urban conurbations, the focus has to remain on fixing what ails them
The challenges faced by Jakarta and other developing Asian cities were seeded in the 1970s as countries across the region liberalised their economies
In Indonesia, land-use controls were aggressively deregulated in the 1980s while entire sectors of the economy were opened up to direct investment. Economically, the results were spectacular: Factories, shopping malls and housing developments sprouted up across Jakarta and the surrounding region
Meanwhile, Indonesians, keen for opportunity, flocked to the city
Between 1970 and 2000, the population of the greater Jakarta region – which now encompasses 12 municipalities or regencies – grew from roughly 5 million people to over 20 million. And from 2000 to 2010, it added another 7 million people, making it the world’s fastest-growing urban region outside of China
By 2030, greater Jakarta will be home to 35 million people, topping Tokyo for the title of world’s most populous city
The results are well-known. Jakarta is home to some of the world’s worst traffic jams; drivers are accustomed to spending two hours to move three miles
That traffic accounts for 75% of Jakarta’s air pollution, which also happens to be among the world’s worst. Jakarta’s metro only opened this year and isn’t expected to make a noticeable impact for years, if ever
Meanwhile, 60% of Jakarta’s residents rely upon often illegally pumped groundwater, in part because of how polluted other sources are
That’s caused the land to subside: Since the 1970s, parts of Jakarta have sunk as much as 4.2m, at a rate of almost 25cm per year. Today, roughly 40% of the city is below sea level and floods are a regular occurrence
There’s little reason to think that relocating 1.5 million bureaucrats and their families – as the current plan contemplates – will relieve these problems for the tens of millions of people left behind in Jakarta. Indeed, the experience of other Asian countries suggests it will merely divert attention and resources
Malaysia’s decision to relocate its capital from Kuala Lumpur to Putrajaya in the 1990s was partly intended to reduce traffic and pollution in the older city. Yet, 20 years on, both have got worse
Like Malaysia and other countries, Indonesia has favoured top-down technocratic solutions to Jakarta’s problems, including building seawalls, clearing low-income communities from flood plains and now establishing a new capital
Indeed, the government recently announced that it plans to spend US$40 billion on needed infrastructure improvements to Jakarta, in addition to the money promised to its new capital city
Yet the real issue remains failures of governance in an era of fast urbanisation. If the government can’t effectively regulate real estate developers and land use, it certainly can’t stop the city from sinking thanks to illegal groundwater pumping
In this, Indonesia is hardly alone. In China, more than 50 cities, including Shanghai, are struggling to control land subsidence due to overuse of groundwater and uncontrolled development
Fast-growing Dhaka, Manila and Bangkok are facing similar struggles. And it seems every up-and-coming Asian city confronts a crippling traffic and pollution problem as rising incomes increase the number of cars on the road
To address these issues properly, Asia’s governments need to be more responsive to voices beyond the vested interests that have been so crucial to building the region’s economy
For example, in recent years slum communities along Jakarta’s Ciliwung River have engaged in large-scale mapping of their environmental vulnerabilities, as well as local polluters
That should help efforts to clean up the river and ultimately reduce the use of groundwater. Effective, responsive governments – not new cities – are what the denizens of Asia’s megacities really need
Adam Minter is a Bloomberg columnist. -FMT

Artikel ini hanyalah simpanan cache dari url asal penulis yang berkebarangkalian sudah terlalu lama atau sudah dibuang :

http://malaysiansmustknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2019/08/asia-should-fix-its-megacities-not-move.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+MalaysiansMustKnowTheTruth+%28Malaysians+

Kempen Promosi dan Iklan
Kami memerlukan jasa baik anda untuk menyokong kempen pengiklanan dalam website kami. Serba sedikit anda telah membantu kami untuk mengekalkan servis percuma aggregating ini kepada semua.

Anda juga boleh memberikan sumbangan anda kepada kami dengan menghubungi kami di sini
You Want To Reconcile But You Have Not Made Your Move Zuraida Tells Anwar

You Want To Reconcile But You Have Not Made Your Move Zuraida Tells Anwar

papar berkaitan - pada 30/8/2019 - jumlah : 83 hits
PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has yet to meet with key party leaders in an effort to reconcile with them amid their absence at some party meetings Malaysiakini reported vice president Zuraida Kamaruddin as saying the request for re...
Khat Issue We Do Not Trust The Ministry And Its Transparency

Khat Issue We Do Not Trust The Ministry And Its Transparency

papar berkaitan - pada 25/8/2019 - jumlah : 95 hits
A coalition of 30 national NGOs and parties from the peninsula Sabah and Sarawak has urged the government to put the implementation of Jawi script on hold until a transparent and proper discussion with all relevant parties is held Coalition...
Top 10 Scary Homes You Should Never Move Into Part 2

Top 10 Scary Homes You Should Never Move Into Part 2

papar berkaitan - pada 3/9/2019 - jumlah : 62 hits
Download 5KPlayer and get 4K Video Converter for Free http bit ly 5kplayeren Play 4K HEVC videos music and streaming video hassle free Top 10 Scary Homes You Should Never Move Into Part 2 Subscribe To Most Amazing Top 10 http bit ly 2Ibyk6i
Yoursay Penang Should Not Change Official Cars During Lean Times

Yoursay Penang Should Not Change Official Cars During Lean Times

papar berkaitan - pada 26/8/2019 - jumlah : 77 hits
YOURSAY Consider what sort of message it is sending out to the people Malaysian United To be fair I think the Penang chief minister deserves a car in the Toyota Camry price range But for the other state exco members it should be somewhere b...
Iran Says It Will Not Negotiate Missile Work Wants More Oil Exports

Iran Says It Will Not Negotiate Missile Work Wants More Oil Exports

papar berkaitan - pada 26/8/2019 - jumlah : 88 hits
Iran wants to export a minimum of 700 000 barrels per day of its oil and ideally up to 1 5 million bpd if the West wants to negotiate with Tehran to save a 2015 nuclear deal two Iranian officials and one diplomat told Reuters on Sunday As a...
India Rules By Muslim For 764 Years Why Still Many Hindusme In India Not Muslim

India Rules By Muslim For 764 Years Why Still Many Hindusme In India Not Muslim

papar berkaitan - pada 26/8/2019 - jumlah : 115 hits
An indian man replied in one of my comments saying India have always been a hindu country because majority of them are hindus despite ruled by muslim empire for 764 years to be exact Simply knowing your history wont hurt you Im from Singapo...
Samurai Bonds Not The Only Way To Raise Funds Economist Tells Govt

Samurai Bonds Not The Only Way To Raise Funds Economist Tells Govt

papar berkaitan - pada 27/8/2019 - jumlah : 75 hits
An economist has urged Putrajaya to explore other options for raising funds following reports that the government is considering a second offer of Samurai bonds from Japan Speaking to FMT Yeah Kim Leng said such options include monetising a...
Untuk Makluman Dr Mahathir Bersatu These Maulanas In India Have Not Been Killed Yet Or Di Culik Tengah Malam

Untuk Makluman Dr Mahathir Bersatu These Maulanas In India Have Not Been Killed Yet Or Di Culik Tengah Malam

papar berkaitan - pada 26/8/2019 - jumlah : 131 hits
This is Masood Azhar in the picture here This fellow is a violent terrorist He is the founder of Jaish e Mohammed a Pakistan based terrorist organisation that carries out terrorist attacks against India This year on May 1st 2019 the United ...
Anwar Ibrahim Not Invited For The Meeting Says Pkr

Anwar Ibrahim Not Invited For The Meeting Says Pkr

papar berkaitan - pada 23/8/2019 - jumlah : 96 hits
PKR leader Fahmi Fadzil today shot down Parti Amanah Negara s Datuk Seri Khairuddin Abu Hassan s Facebook accusation that Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim had intentionally skipped a meeting with Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad yesterday Fah...
Safawi Dinasihat Jgn Jadi Mcm Ronaldinho Ada Harta Rm428 Juta Tapi Bila Bersara Tinggal Rm26 Dlm Bank

Kamera Berjaya Rakam Pendaki China Sampai Ke Puncak Gunung Everest Untuk Ukur Ketinggiannya Semula

Tun M Mukhriz Syed Saddiq Maszlee Dan Amiruddin Dipecat Keahlian Bersatu

Hiburan Abby Abadi Bergurau Mahu Bersalaman Dengan Norman Hakim Timbul Rasa Kurang Senang Netizen

Khalid Samad Tahu Tak Rakyat Tidak Memilih Kerajaan Atau Pm

Lebih Banyak Kelonggaran Dijangka Diumum Minggu Pertama Jun

Pangsapuri Paling Padat Penduduk Di Dunia Tinggal Kenangan

Selling On Fb Instagram Is Illegal Unless You Re Registered With The Government



Adakah China Sedang Merancang Rampasan Semula Taiwan Ketika Ini

Info Dan Sinopsis Drama Memoir Karmila Slot Widuri

Farah Pahlavi Permaisuri Terakhir Iran Yang Kini Hidup Dalam Buangan

Kisah Wanita Dipaksa Gugurkan Anak Demi Polisi Negara China

Isu Pelakon Larikan Isteri Orang Ini Lagi Kenyataan Leana Sharif Pengurus Shah Radhi Hazvee


Tun Dr Mahathir Dipecat Dari Parti Bersatu

Hadiah 1 Syawal Sabah Here I Come

Viral Video Ayah Serahkan 2 Anaknya Tak Mampu Beli Susu Saat Wabah Corona

Viral Video Balita Bangunkan Ibunya Yang Sudah Meninggal

Risma Diingatkan Jangan Guyonan Lagi Corona Di Surabaya Berpotensi Jadi Wuhan

Ayam Brand Projek Pantri Makanan Ayamwithyou Di Anjung Singgah Dan Pertubuhan Kebajikan Kasih Nurul Hasanah